My wife and I have a 2 year old and we did #1 till we were broke. We're having another in June and have used FreeCycle and friends this time around. We have far more useful items this time around and have spent nothing.
New parents are scared and research and buy everything. Smart parents borrow and inherit. We have gotten some amazingly (expensive) and useful items on FreeCycle (including all the baby room furniture. We'll be passing it along when we are done as well).
No offense to the creator. But as a parent of young kid(s), this makes me cringe. I think clutter-crate might be a better name.