A Sharp Spike in Honeybee Deaths Deepens a Worrisome Trend
nytimes.com
nytimes.com
"What decline? The number of honeybee hives in the world is at a record high. The number in Europe is higher than it was in the early 1990s when neonics were introduced. Hive mortality in Britain was unusually low in the year before the neonic ban. It’s a myth that honeybees are in dire straits." (Ref: http://www.thetimes.co.uk/tto/opinion/article4227789.ece, full article here: http://www.rationaloptimist.com/blog/bees-and-pesticides.asp...)
I am not saying we don't have problems. Varroa mites is a serious problem (originally from Russia, where the spread of mites was controlled by long winter/cold temps, it is now a world wide problem). We have other infections, we have CCD, etc. But all in all, bees are just doing fine. Except that they are being trucked all over the country to pollinate almonds, apples, etc etc.
Consider this. If bees were dying in such record numbers, wouldn't you see significant rise in honey prices?
There's enough market control and price fixing going on in the world, that I can simply never put much faith in short term market price dynamics as an indicator.
Since the UK ban my anecdotal evidence is loads more types of bumble bees in my garden.
And I have not seen any 'confused' dying bees at all which was a regular sight before the ban.
I would have thought the publication of the Nature paper that Bees seek out fresh Neonicotinoid sprayings to get the maximum dose as they are totally hooked on nicotine and so getting way above the dose the previous models suggested would have sealed their fate in the US - but I guess not.
Are there any surveys which suggest numbers of bees and wild bees have improved in Europe since the ban ?
Interesting that the scientific concern over Neonicotinoides is given considerably less space than the industry 'facts'.
As there was a industry spokesperson AMAing on reddit about how pesticides were not so bad for bees and this making the frontpage on HN - I expect some well funded publicity machine is getting oiled up.
Is there some critical vote coming up or something ?
The European Ban is a gigantic experiment. Either it will clearly demonstrate that Neonicotinoides are a problem, or that they are a scapegoat.
The Europeans have a history of banning things without scientific evidence like BGH and GMO. In this case it's a useful trait since their ban will provide definitive answers.
With something like GMO, it might take decades for the harmful effects to become clear. Just like it took decades before people became aware of the carcinogenic effect of cigarette smoking.
If you see an actual honeybee outside near your home, the odds are apparently overwhelming that the bee is owned by someone.
If they let about 10% of their acreage go wild, native bees come in and can take over most of the load. However, that's more expensive, right now, than continuing to use honeybees.
Until using honeybees gets expensive, agribusiness will not change.
Professor Einstein, the learned scientist, once calculated that if all bees disappeared off the earth, four years later all humans would also have disappeared.
Abeilles et fleurs, June, 1965.
Here's a list of crops pollinated by bees: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_crop_plants_pollinated_...
I don't see wheat, corn, or rice on there.
Here's a list of crops that don't need pollination: http://www.hortmag.com/plants/fruits-veggies/vegetable-crops...
What veggies do not need pollinators to produce:
• All leafy greens
• Brassicas: broccoli, cauliflower, cabbage and kohlrabi
• Below ground root veggies and tubers such as carrots, parsnips, salsify, potatoes, sweet potatoes, horseradish
• Ground level root veggies such as beets, turnips, rutabagas
• Most legumes including peas and beans
• Corn—like other wind pollinated veggies
• Herbs, like the lemon balm pictured
• Celery
• Onions and leeks
That's a pretty good list of foods for humans to survive on.I suspect that if we looked at arable land and calories per year by different crops, we'd find that your list can't support the dietary requirements for the 7B people.
But, I don't know that, I'm just speculating.
This article is interesting: http://www.ent.uga.edu/bees/OnEinsteinBeesandSurvivaloftheHu...
A recent analysis[ii] of yearly crop data maintained by the United Nations Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) from 1961 to 2006 reached some divergent conclusions and shed light on the interacting complexity of the question “How important is animal-vectored pollination?”
The authors of the FAO analysis concluded that the proportion of global food production attributable to animal pollination ranges from 5% in industrialized nations to 8% in the developing world.
So I think we're going to be fine.
Also, it says there's no evidence Einstein actually said the quote.
If it doesn't impact grasses or beans, it can't impact the world's dietary requirements either. Everything else is a garnish compared to those.
http://www.wired.com/2014/05/will-we-still-have-fruit-if-bee...
The article discusses a series of unfortunate choices that led to the situation, but it is apparently economically viable even in competition with bees.
I'm also not sure that the economics are as bad as you assume. Imagine a worker that pollinates 100 flowers an hour, for $30, with half of the flowers setting fruit. That adds a substantial $0.60 to an apple, roughly doubling the price of a bag, but it isn't crushing poverty for the worker (and I guess they would pollinate faster than that).
There you have it...