IMO, noobs might think HN community is hostile & leave. Not many noobs would ask for reason, if they feel intimidated - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9179609
IMO, noobs might think HN community is hostile & leave. Not many noobs would ask for reason, if they feel intimidated - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9179609
I believe the parent was referring to downvoting comments that are hostile in tone, not using downvoting as an outlet for his own hostility.
The simple logic is that hostility obscures the writer's meaning, invites reactive hostility, and pollutes the conversation. I can see no reason to promote it.
Slow down, try again without invective, be civil. It works better.
We are not the powerless disenfranchised citizens of a dictatorial state with no other means of expression. Some of us might be, actually, but not in this setting.
Edit: I think we're talking past each other on where "tone policing" becomes regular old moderation.
> People who get down voted (esp noobs to the community) have no idea why they were.
I suggested an idea to inform new users in a post upthread (link to guidelines next to any comment of yours that is score-negative), but it would probably be better to link to a page with the guidelines plus a blurb about accidents, confusion, and just not taking it too seriously.