He seems to disagree with OP completely. But, I find OP's point about noobs valid:
> People who get down voted (esp noobs to the community) have no idea why they were.
> People who get down voted (esp noobs to the community) have no idea why they were.
I suggested an idea to inform new users in a post upthread (link to guidelines next to any comment of yours that is score-negative), but it would probably be better to link to a page with the guidelines plus a blurb about accidents, confusion, and just not taking it too seriously.