You've displayed correlation and insisted causation. Of course, Ezra seems to have done so as well, but your correlation isn't any more impressive than his.
You've displayed correlation and insisted causation. Of course, Ezra seems to have done so as well, but your correlation isn't any more impressive than his.
Would not company performance be the vehicle, and stock price simply one measure of performance? It's not like stock price and business performance are identical, it's very possible for a company to be over or under valued.
Could we not say that company performance causes both stock price AND ceo pay, thereby showing that stock price and ceo pay are NOT in a causative relationship, only correlated because both are caused by actual business performance?
I'm not persuaded of the existence of some more accurate measure of company performance than market cap that CEO compensation committees are aware of but Wall Street isn't.
I'm insisting that such an extreme coincidence is impossible.
You could get a better idea by looking at the value of options granted and their vest dates, but I don't care enough to dig that deeply.
Technically speaking (the best kind of speaking) you have demonstrated only that these two things are correlated, but you have not proved that one caused the other.
For example, the rise in CEO pay could have caused the stock increases, not the other way around. Or, both could be caused by another even more perfect factor.
Without a causation analysis to factor for error, we cannot know, and its simply wrong to assume that one caused the other.
However, the causal account is easily tested: http://web.stanford.edu/group/knowledgebase/cgi-bin/2010/09/...
From the paper: "Based on a sample of 4,000 publicly traded U.S. companies, the average (median) CEO stands to gain roughly $58,000 in wealth for every 1 percent increase in stock price. Among the largest 100 companies, this figure approaches $640,000.6"
So the hypothesis the observed correlation was used to generate appears to be plausible given the further evidence that CEO wealth really is tied to stock price, whether directly through options or other means.
This is how we actually use statistical analysis, as part of a dialog between reality and propositions, rather than repeating the empty matra "correlation is not causation", which while true is something I too often see deployed to denigrate interesting and potentially fertile observations.
Whenever we have the urge to say "correlation is not causation" we should step back and ask, "How can I investigate the question more deeply?" Often more fruitful avenues will present themselves to the inquring mind.