The FCC warns Internet providers they’re on the hook now for user privacy
washingtonpost.com
washingtonpost.com
For those wondering about the "explicit permission" mentioned here, there are two methods ISP's we be able to use to use your information, if they indeed follow their telecommunications privacy model[0].
> “Opt-Out” – Your company sends you a notice saying it will consider you to have given your approval to use your customer information for marketing unless you tell it not to do so (usually within 30 days.)
> “Opt-In” – Your company sends you a notice asking that you expressly give it permission to use your customer information for marketing.
Regardless though, this article left me wanting. If you're curious about the details, Ars[1] has a great introduction to it.
[0] https://www.fcc.gov/guides/protecting-your-telephone-calling...
[1] http://arstechnica.com/business/2015/05/isps-really-dont-wan...
Oh who am I kidding, of course not.
Oh, that's right - because they often violate even those laws to help the NSA or FBI or the police, and they don't want to be on the hook for it.
Giving immunity like this to companies creates such terrible incentives. Hopefully after the USA Freedom Act (whether it passes or not) the civil liberties organizations will fight to roll-back that immunity as well - especially if the USA Freedom Act passes and allows carriers to keep the data for NSA.
No one's giving away your browsing history, they're giving away C2C server IPs, md5s of malicious files, etc., and guess what? The bad actors who move this data are customers too.
Comcast still can't share your library books with the FBI.
https://www.fas.org/sgp/crs/intel/RL34600.pdf
The point here is that we do have statutory and constitutional procedures that are supposed to prevent abuses of this process.
If when you break those rules, you just get a "get out of jail free" card, your incentive as a company to challenge illegal requests really does diminish profoundly. If you say no to an illegal request, you get into trouble. If you say yes, precedent suggests the government will bail you out.
But they could illegally, just like anyone could illegally take your car, or charge up your credit card, or any of the other numerous things that are physically possible but illegal.