Hacker News Reader

I like the "stop dieting" and graph about what causes vs protects against cancer. The "don't get healthcare" is ridiculous though. But then again, especially in the US unnecessary back surgeries for example are insanely common...

View on HN

The don't get healthcare isn't necessarily ridiculous.

It's always a good idea to ask your doctor "what happens if we don't do anything? If I don't take these meds / have this surgery"

Read it carefully - the chart implies roughly equal weighting between 'cause' and 'prevent' for some foods, but the axes are scaled very differently either side of the dividing line.

I believed they are scaled equally. Each 'step' from the middle indicates an increase or decrease in risk by a factor of 2. If you're at 0.5, you're half as likely to get cancer; 2, twice as likely. 0.1 is 10x less risk, 10 is 10x more risk.

The graph was also created by Vox and includes the words 'cause' and 'prevent' for exaggeration, but the individual studies mostly imply correlation.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com