I see that a lot.
I see that a lot.
Maybe you haven't, because society isn't built to put you down and keep you there, the way it is for some people. Check your privilege.
Either way, riots do raise awareness. You might hate the destructive people, but you do pay attention to them, and then you pay attention to the non-violent people who are with them.
I have, in fact, been that angry. I just haven't made the mistake of assuming that that anger, expressed in the form of violence, will get me what I want. Especially since a recent study on the subject shows that the radical interpretation of riots you have just espoused is not consonant with history.
Have you considered not making wild assumptions about me in an effort to invalidate my viewpoint?
I understand rage. I understand feeling helpless. I know those feelings. I have felt those feelings. I could go on and on and on, making all the declarations of sympathy and empathy and understanding you could possibly wish for here.
Yet, at no point did I come to believe that random destruction of property would get me what I wanted to relieve that all-consuming rage. Doubly so when evidence on the subject shows clearly that riots don't work. Whether or not I have felt a particular flavor of rage is immaterial to the question of whether or not riots are an efficacious means of producing social change. The former is a question of unknowable perceptions, while the latter is a question verifiable against reality to the extent that reality is objective.
Might I ask you to consider the basic question of "Do riots work?" Or the related basic question of if desperately wanting something to be true makes it so?
http://www.omarwasow.com/Protests_on_Voting.pdf
Long story short, violence does not make other people want to help you or give you what you ask for. It makes those other people do the opposite.
When people believe something the opposite of both basic sense and history for romantic reasons, I call them deluded. This is the case with those who argue that riots bring support to their viewpoints.
Those I know who hold to that notion do so because they find riots emotionally satisfying. To them, a thing that is emotionally satisfying must also be objectively productive, because it's incomprehensible that such strong emotions could not move witnesses to share, support, and solidarity.
That, and a bunch of radical pablum about how getting people talking about your cause is the same as actually effecting change and similar. Something about symbolic violence and making a statement usually crops up around this point. Occasionally someone argues that destruction of property is non-violence.
The human capacity for finding a way to ideologically justify whatever it is you want to do is truly remarkable.
In retrospect, I was a lot more tolerant of this flavor of toxic radical thought when I didn't live in an area they regard as a great place to go smashing things.
Others just like smashing things.
I've also seen people get very upset when confronted with the links I showed you. It's a treasured article of faith in some circles that riots produce desirable social change.
The delusion is not the goal. The delusion is the notion that violence will achieve the goal because said violence is emotionally satisfying.
If that isn't a valid assumption - and I suppose it's possible, but I would like to think not - then there's a very different conversation to be had.
I'm also not sure that the correlation doesn't run the other way, and that the more right-wing an area was the more likely that people were being mistreated enough to riot.
I dont particularly support rioting, but its clear that in many cases, and the USA in the 60s this definitely applies, that the "fault" for the rioting can be clearly applied to those who are mistreating the rioters.
So, they're "in the right" yet trapped by an entire establishment that both intentionally and unintentionally mistreats them, up to and including well documented COINTELPRO false flag operations against the civil rights movement, and you think the salient thing to draw from this episode is that the people involved were stupid?