Accessibility and the iPhone - a tale of woe
theweaselking.livejournal.com
theweaselking.livejournal.com
9. It's almost impossible to get the right letter without being able to see the screen. Because you have to place your finger, listen for the right letter, then "lift it off" and place it again. Trying to slide your finger inevitably results in it thinking you're "holding" the wrong character and "pressing" the one next to it.... which then causes the phone to input that first character. Of course, you don't "know" whether it just inputted the wrong character, or whether it just announced that you'd re-selected the same wrong character, because there's absolutely no difference in the audio cues.
Is there a market for making some sort of Braille screen overlay for the iphone, similar to something like http://appadvice.com/appnn/2009/11/your-iphone-can-also-feat... ??
While this instance may be specific to the iPhone with screen reader and setting up wireless, this kind of make-it-easy-by-removing-options-and-attempt-to-probe-for-everything is especially frustrating when you know what the options are but the device or UI wants to do something itself in the name of helping you. I find these kinds of things especially frustrating because it's often difficult to verify the settings after it's been automatically set up.
No, you need to leave the Mail app, then find Settings, scroll down (see 2), select mail and other things, select mail, select this account, select this account, find the password field (without it reading the field names, I remind you), and put in the password, then save the settings and restart the mail app.
Finally, an example of "having all the settings in one place", but divorced from the place the setting is used is a bad idea. I never really understood the mindset that this is supposed to be easier. I know that the app needs the settings, I can find the app no problem, but its settings are some where else, with navigation totally separate from the app. I guess it makes accessing the settings consistent across apps, but this is a weird thing to optimize since you should rarely be messing with app specific settings, and when you do, you're already in the app.
Seriously? People still say this? This hasn’t been true since Apple standardized on the Mighty Mouse (horrible mouse that it was). That was a long time ago (in internet time, anyway), and now the Mighty Mouse is dead.
also, he might be a bit misinformed. sure, itunes makes you install apple software update, but safari and bonjour and all that? I don't think so. power user customization that Linux, Windows users expect? I think he hasn't discovered the terminal.
and the "1 button unless you buy a peripheral" er, no. two finger tap on the mousepad, better than sliced bread.
On the other hand, voiceover comes with all iPhone 3GSes and voiceover on Mac OS X is free and comes built into the OS (even during OS installs!). I guess that's Apple's way of telling blind people that Apple doesn't care about them and they should go buy other products..
i've seen simplified mobiles (look and work like a cordless home phone) in japan aimed squarely at this growing market.
That said, I would agree that there are more compelling markets out there. I wouldn't be surprised if most accessibility developers have altruistic motives.
For the author of the above-linked article to claim that Apple's purposefully making voiceover suck to annoy the blind is a bit rich and ill-informed, given Apple's accessibility team want to help, are very helpful if you ever email them about issues (accessibility@apple.com), and could probably address most of those issues as best they can if they were informed of them. A true "fuck you" to the blind would be to not have included voiceover on the iPhone 3GS in the first place.