Furthermore, at what point does it suddenly become OK to chase after a financial security law violation? Is there a valuation limit? Cash flow limit? War chest limit? What exactly is the qualification to no longer be "a shame"?
Furthermore, at what point does it suddenly become OK to chase after a financial security law violation? Is there a valuation limit? Cash flow limit? War chest limit? What exactly is the qualification to no longer be "a shame"?
The reality is that there is a point at which it is no longer OK to chase after a securities law violation. This is why the SEC doesn't go after PE firms that aggressively use carried interest (e.g. a partner puts his salary into the fund and later _only_ pays long term capital gains on his redemptions). There's _too_ much at stake in those cases so the SEC backs off.
Where do you think SEC staff go after they leave the SEC, and what do you think they make there? The SEC makes those enforcement actions against major banks that it _has_ to. The other stuff gets quietly dealt with.
The SEC cannot allow something like this to operate with cash at play, but the whole thing should have been cleared up with a couple of visits and phone calls.
How much do you think it cost them to go after Sand Hill?
The SEC has limited resources. I think the grandparent is questioning whether this is the best use of them.
I mean just juxtapose this (from the article):
"For added credibility, we randomly generated trading histories for each company going all the way back to last year.....
We pasted descriptive text cribbed from the websites of banks and registered exchanges to make our website look like a serious business."
Source: https://medium.com/@eiaine/how-startup-growth-hacks-resulted...
With what Ivanplenty said in this thread:
"'Sand Hill Exchange' accepted items of real value (USD and BC) that could be used to 'purchase' (or bet on) things named after real securities that trade (or are expected to trade) on public markets for a profit."
(Source https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9642353)
What a scary world if the SEC didn't shut these guys down with a slap on the wrist! (Assuming Ivanplenty is correct and they monetized as he stated.)
I mean they are literally inventing trading histories and collecting bitcoins and dollars to trade on them. That's the kind of market that sends real investors scurrying away from it, and I'm glad the SEC protects investors from that happening, by simply shutting it down. It is positively a good thing. (Also, the history of investor protection is because snake-oil salesmen really did take advantage of investors, selling them the clear blue sky:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blue_sky_law
So it's not like this is some theoretical thing. The problem happened first, and the solution simply solved it. There are a lot of areas where the legal system can improve, but the existence itself of the SEC and the fact that it shut this exchange down is not one of them. This is absolutely warranted and called-for. Yes, you need to register if you want to do this type of thing, and you need to play by the rules.)
Squashing tiny companies might make them feel better, but it's not impactful. Going after companies defrauding investors / playing it fast and loose for millions is how you clean up finance.
Putting out big fires like that is a good -- but expensive -- way to grab headlines, sure. Something the SEC definitely needs to do to the extent it can.
Dealing with small things like a little market that lets you bet real money on company valuations in a market with deliberately falsified trade histories is how you prevent something from becoming one of those big fires, relatively cheaply for all involved, and before lots of people get hurt by it. Also an important thing for the SEC to do.
See eg Coinbase's comments on the BitLicense. There's an opportunity to move fintech forward in the US, and actions like this- regulators trying to pad their resume- are stifling.