Y Combinator, but with 20x the red tape
nsf.gov
nsf.gov
BTW - DoD is pretty cool about not requiring an advanced degree, unlike some other departments. If you have a background full of successful projects but no degree, you can still win by stuffing some MS/PhD's in as advisers.
That being said - for some of these it can take six months to hear whether you even won the grant, so this is not a primary funding strategy. It is a supplementary funding strategy. Its something to do, then forget about until you hear back. You don't want to try and setup a company with the government as your only customer - they will bleed you dry with delays. But if you're going to build something anyway, and are an expert in the area... why not go for the cash?
Your state may have an office setup to assist you in applying for these. The folks at ATDC in Atlanta were very helpful: http://innovate.gatech.edu/Default.aspx?alias=innovate.gatec... There are numerous companies in Atlanta that have 'bootstrapped' to the tune of several million dollars using SBIR/STTR, and have gone on to success in the broader market.
This doesn't really compare to Y Combinator, but it is (almost) free money. Uncle Sam dolla dolla bill, yo.
A long time ago, when a Phase I SBIR was a lot of money to a tiny company, we got one and spent 6 months on it only to find that the department which was supposed to accept the report had been organized away. After a year of trying to get someone to sign off on paying us we gave up. Five years after the money was to be paid, out of the blue we got an panicked call from an accountant that we had to accept the money right now! Seems it was going to get returned to congress for being unused for too long and that is bad form.
But that was the '90s. Don't make your plans based on that.
Topic DARPA ST061-004: ttp://tinyurl.com/yzuqxwh
This was our fourth SBIR/STTR proposal and only win. SBIR/STTR topics are very competitive (winning teaches you how so you are more likely to win again). This particular topic received ~30 submissions of which an unusually high number were awarded (3) Phase I money. Winning Phase I does not mean you win Phase II because of poor results or no Federal funds available. For this topic we also had two competitors for Phase II funding. You cannot win Phase II without first winning the Phase I.
The marketing, regulatory, and compliance process that comes with this money has been VC-pitching-intense but the advantages and cautions are very, very different. One advantage is that the Federal government pays in a recession. The catches are important and I found surprising (e.g it is non-trivial to negotiate a contract with a U.S. university under a deadline and to do so while complying with the Bayh-Dole Act). Also DoD SBIR/STTRs train you to become a government contractor (NSF might be different). Selling commercially is unusual but laudable - just don't expect people to be very familiar with what you need in the way a VC is "supposed" to be.
As a result of this process, my company (Freytag & Company, LLC), has products, enough money for one other employee, and huge experience going to the government market.
Since, our Phase II contract was "cost plus fixed fee" (most bigger government contracts are), and most costs are labor hours, regulatory compliance means tracking labor hours with contract codes. We passed our first Defense Contract Audit Agency (DCAA) audit just before we won our Phase II and are about to undergo another audit less than two years later. As a result we have probably one of the tightest accounting systems for a company this size you will ever see (and a damn fine accountant).
Because we took a lot of money and are doing something that might fail despite the money, we (well, -I-) decided to give our time-tracking tool away free. Figured it was a certain way to: 1. help the SBIR/STTR program grow our economy by 2. helping other firms immediately solve one part of their compliance problem - that of being able to track employee and contractor hours in the particular way the government expects.
If you need to track your labor hours over a distributed team of developers and would like to use a tool that has taken at least one firm through a government audit (and soon another - joy!) email me at timesheets@freytag.us. Please tell me who you are and what your problem is when you write.
Can you spend 2 weeks in a different way to generate > $10k in extra money 6 months down the road? If the answer is yes you should probably stick with your other work.
http://www.nsf.gov/awardsearch/progSearch.do?WT.si_n=Clicked...
Looking at a few of the awards to software companies, they appeared to reach $150K.
That is if you try 100 times you will win 10 times and get $100k each time you win, or $1m total, or $10k per attempt.
100 topics is about how many are in each list of SBIR/STTRs circulated on topics as diverse as new techniques in field medicine to better translation to new power storage mechanisms. It would require considerable technical range to propose to them all and succeed.
You do not get to make up your own topics. They are posted by Program Managers working for the government.
If you attempt to propose to more than one personally in an SBIR/STTR cycle you will lose. That is in part how my first two failed. I find it takes a considerable effort to put together a good AND short proposal.
Then there is the catch that you must inform all agencies of similar proposals sent previously or at the same time to other agencies (so you can't win two with one proposal).
Proposals are judged against your ability to execute upon award. The bottom line is that the odds are quite a bit lower than 10%.
My advice is go read the solicitations and then get out and meet the program managers a'la Steve Blank. You will learn a lot and your proposal will benefit from it. It is a tough process but does seem to reward determination.
One last word - keep yours, government contracting is a small town.
I hope this helps you assess the risks and how you can reduce them. Best of luck!
Does it make more sense now?
Another poster indicated the money comes with no strings attached, other than quarterly reporting. Is there a multi-year contract I have missed?
Your estimate assumes that if you compete you have at least an average ability to win. This is very probably an inaccurate assumption. In my opinion, if you go in cold you are unlikely to have an average probability of winning on even a minority of the topics unless you are highly expert in the field of the topic and bring something utterly original yet reasonable to execute for the funding.
Assuming you do know the topic at a far-above-average level - you might not know how to write a good proposal, or understand what the proposer is really asking for, or be seen to be able to execute successfully, or be able to commercialize the result of the effort (maybe not as important to NSF as of a few years back) to name a few; but you get the idea.
Fundamentally, your odds depend on a fit with the topic and your personal ability to execute this type of process. That is why your odds go up after you successfully execute once.
Lastly, do a lot of legwork before proposing - figure a generous amount of out-of-the-chair legwork into your expected value calculations.
Look around for colleagues that have done this and pick their brains.
This appears to be the full solicitation of which the "(IC)" area is part:
http://www.nsf.gov/pubs/2009/nsf09609/nsf09609.htm
Looks to be 200-300 awards of up to $150K each
It might be reasonable to assign a much higher expected value, if the applicant knows (via communication with the program officer) that their team and area are in a favored area, or if they expect to also seek government funding past the first stage, or if they get some value (experience/feedback) even from a 'loss'.
Also, the costs of applying could be far less than 2 weeks if (for whatever reason) an applicant is good at the process or can repurpose other presentation materials.
So perhaps the expected value is some multiple of $10K, for just a day or two's effort,
I agree on non-monetary rewards, those can be useful for some people depending on their future plan. I see myself in consumer market, so it's not clear how much benefit will I get from it. Would be nice to know more about that.
I need to look closer into the two-week thing. You might be right, and if it's less than a week I might as well just do it.
Speaking of probabilities, they have funded 395 out of 2067 submissions in 2007, so the estimates are going up slightly: http://www.nsf.gov/eng/iip/sbir/phaseI_map.ppt
You put together a consortium, with partners from at least three different European countries (seven for some proposals).
If you are applying for "Future and Emerging Technologies", you write a 5 page proposal saying what you want to do, how much it will cost, how you plan to do it and why it should be done. Wait three months for the EC to respond. If they like your idea, you get to the next stage.
If you are applying for a specific call or your FET-open short proposal was accepted, you get to write a full proposal. This is 60-90 pages of detailed justification for why your proposal is beyond the state of the art, a detailed work plan, a justification of the concept, the specific tasks of each partner, a timeline, a budget, and what "impact" it is meant to have on Europe as a whole in terms of the objectives of the specific call. This is a rather massive, hard to distribute amount of work. During the three months after the deadline, your proposal is sent to some call-topic-specific experts as deemed by the EC. A lot of these experts are working in the same field and indirectly competing with you. They are almost all academic or bureaucratic, since industry people don't have time for this sort of stuff. Three months later, you are told how you scored, and if you scored well enough, you are put on a list. The commission goes through the list and funds projects until the budget runs out or the projects get too bad. All in all, the feedback cycle can be over a year long, and that's before you even start work on the project itself. Resubmitting an improved/modified proposal takes an incredible feat of enthusiasm across a necessarily large number of people within several institutions. The amounts distributed are in the millions of euros, so it can be worth it, but the process essentially requires the working group to be so large that a lot of efficiency is lost.
Long processing times might effectively require you to have the amount you are seeking in your own bankroll (money comes often late, not before). Thus you can't actually compete without stable finances.
I'm not sure that the scheme produces innovations efficiently, but at least the investment in networking (might prove valuable) and bureaucratic efforts is huge.
More info: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seventh_Framework_Programme
Luckily there are plenty of funding instruments at the national level.
This is the government agency that gave us ARPANET and the Mosiac browser. They also provided funding for Larry Page and Sergey Brin's proto-Google project at Stanford.
Hell, career military guys make fun of military bureaucracy all the time.
2. So what? Yes, we need DARPA, NSF, &co to fund $10^9 research projects like space elevators or The Internet. YC has shown that the real problem with such projects isn't red tape per se. It's the decade-long release-response-revision cycle you're forced to deal with when the stakes get so high. You have to deal with a lot more accountability mechanisms when you beg or borrow that much money. I'd be willing to bet YC's success rate compares favorably to NSF's.
But it takes a long time for the benefits of that kind of work trickle down to the average person, and there's no feedback to indicate what the private sector will want and what it won't. So for every Internet, there are a lot of ITERs: http://www.iter.org
Total cost of ITER has been in the tens of billions, and the project is projected to start producing energy about 40 years from now. In contrast, General Fusion, a startup with under $25M in funding, could be ready a lot sooner: http://www.technologyreview.com/business/23102/
ITER on the other hand has an 85+% chance of working (net energy gain) and only costs the US ~1billion. So while ITER might cost 50x as much it's more than 50x more likely to actually work. Also should ITER work as well as expected a working fusion reactor that could produce 1GW of base load power could be built in 10 years. ITER's initial design was for a 500MW power plant, but ITER was scaled back to a demonstration device to lower cost and reduce risks.
PS: All fusion devices produce a lot a radiation and need extensive containment and decommissioning costs. The only way you can build a 20 million$ fusion reactor is by avoiding actually producing significant amounts of fusion. So all projects that say we can demonstrate fusion for < 50 million are not going to produce significant amounts of electricity.
That is "working" only under an irrelevant definition of the word. The test of a commercial power system is not whether it can produce a net energy gain, but whether it can produce large amounts of energy at prices which compare favorably to coal and nuclear. Having a zillion hamsters run on wheels all day might well qualify as "working" in the sense of producing net energy, but we don't use it for a reason.
"and only costs the US ~1billion."
Although technically true, this is a gross misrepresentation of the actual cost, which is enormous.
"ITER was originally expected to cost approximately €5bn, but the rising price of raw materials and changes to the initial design may see that amount double." - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ITER
"All fusion devices ... need extensive containment and decommissioning costs."
Evidence? Lead is very cheap.
"The only way you can build a 20 million$ fusion reactor is by avoiding actually producing significant amounts of fusion."
Evidence?
Lead under heavy neutron bombardment becomes radioactive as does all other materials with long term heavy neutron bombardment.
PS: If you are interested in fusion I would suggest you look at fusor.net. It's a message board for amateurs but there are some solid posts relating to the amount of neutrons produced per watt of net fusion energy for the better fusion materials. As well as a look into the cost of shielding etc.
Edit: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/JT-60 JT-60 does not have the facilities to handle Tritium; currently only the JET tokamak has such facilities. In fusion terminology JT60 achieved conditions which in D-T would have provided Q=1.25 where Q is the ratio of fusion power to input power.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DEMO DEMO must have linear dimensions about 15% larger than ITER... Subsequent commercial fusion reactors could be built for nearly a quarter of the cost of DEMO if things go according to plan.[2][3]
Federal research investment stimulates private research investment. Its a symbiotic relationship.
The goal of SBIR is to give out a certain portion of the federal budget to small business. Its a great program. As to ROI: federal funding for R&D provided the entire basis for the early economy of silicon valley in which YC resides. No programs like these = no silicon valley = no YC.
YC is the ROI on federal R&D dollars :)
It's also false that federal R&D funding was the "entire basis" for Silicon Valley. And false that YC is a product of Silicon Valley. In fact, it's hard to find much that you've said that isn't false.
Techniques for comparison that may provide some utility: investment efficiency, total investment adjusted for duration of program, applicants per dollar invested, and so on.
I am surprised that you are engaging in a debate about the relative influence of DARPA funding and YC. It seems like comparing Apples to Filesystems.
Here's how I do it: I look for someone who seems to be trying to score rhetorical points, and then I ask what the chances are that happened by accident.
When people are earnestly but confusedly trying to work something out for themselves, they don't sound like this:
DARPA birthed the Internet. YC birthed reddit.
I guess the jury is still out.So the issue in this case is wether the sarcasm follows from the errant logical conclusion or wether a malicious intent inspired the faulty logic and bad attitude. As the righteous are often petty, I cannot discern if the error is deliberately dishonest or negligently shallow and intentionally righteous.
Either way, I agree that it is a terrible argument and a worse comment.
As for ego, I don't have a window into anyone else's psyche (do you?), but can think of an easy explanation that has nothing to do with ego: YC is a business. It would be irresponsible not to defend one's business against false or disparaging statements.
Beyond that, it's important to hold the discourse to a certain standard; we have many examples of the pestilence that befalls online communities where this isn't actively done. (Your comment wouldn't raise an eyebrow in many of these places, but it was locally acidic.) IMO PG does a pretty good job of pushing back on this kind of thing while at the same time letting reasonable criticism have free rein. That's a hard balance to strike and not likely how a runaway ego would go about things.
(Example of not knowing the system: on my first application, I put forth a very ambitious workplan in order to entice NASA with a high bang:buck ratio; this backfired completely as they loved my proposal except for its unrealistic workplan. D'oh!)
However, I'd still say it was worth the time, as they forced me to do a lot of explicit planning about where I was taking product development, and now I have two well-written proposals that I can cut-and-paste into various new incarnations for other audiences.
That said, my company will never be doing that again. :)
Check the current solicitations and see if there's a fit.
Participants would get enough money to do their thing for a few months in exchange for royalties against a future work. They'd also receive training on the ins and outs of the business, and access to industry people.
It could work well. For all I know, it might exist already.
I think it's unfortunate that the entertainment industry seems to prefer competitions, like "Project Runway" or "Making of the Band". It would be a better investment to coach all those early-stage participants towards something, rather than pit them against each other and declare a winner.
Could you imagine how much better tv/music/publishing would be, if the major players did something like this?
http://www.channel101.com/ is an example where it's a kind of co-operative incubator for comedians, directors and actors. Andy Samberg and his two partners (who are major players on SNL now) were incubated there. Too bad you can't invest in a comedy team the same way you can invest in a corporation - because if you could Dan Harmon (the guy who runs C101) would be rich.
The problem though is that there isn't really any money in books or music, so it's a much tougher sell.