You might use one to finance your work. Or market your work, which is their best talent these days.
But you don't need them. You can produce and release your work freely without them.
The fundamentally borken part of the indie ecosystem is marketing/discovery. Publishers still act as gatekeepers for the reading public. Most people don't read and what they do read is almost entirely determined by the amount of marketing done for it, and while marketing is a learnable skill (I've run my own consulting shop, so done a lot of it) it is difficult to do on the kind of budget most indie authors have available for what amounts to a hobby.
The indie music industry has done a better job of discovery but that's in part because music is consumable in much smaller pieces than novels. The solution to this in writing has been--to some extent--to return to serialization, but while that has worked a bit in non-fiction (people write blogs they turn into books) it has so far seen only one or two successes in fiction, and they have been... not notable for the quality of writing, for the most part.
I've experimented with a couple of alternative forms to see if this can be overcome, but no luck so far. One was an illustrated serial prose format (finished version here: http://www.siduri.net/songsofalbion/songs_of_albion.html), the other an somewhat informal poemed illustrations format (http://www.siduri.net/cindylooyou/index.html) that appeared on the artist's blog and developed as a kind of jazz work as we tossed themes back and forth. The latter actually got a bigger following, although we promoted the former a lot more heavily. Go figure.
So far it looks like conventional serial narratives--probably pod-cast--are the best bet for the indie author. Some kind of serial pod-cast will likely be my next move, more in the spirit of exploration than anything else. I'm fortunate to have some training as a voice actor, but the number conditions on an idie author to be successful are many, and the difficulty for readers in discovering work they might enjoy is considerable.
Speaking as someone in the same position as tjradcliffe but in the movie (and now comics) world rather than prose, his analysis is spot-on. Discovery's the problem.
In the indie narrative film world - which is in a much, much worse position when it comes to discovery and distribution than the self-publishing world in most ways for reasons somewhat too complicated to go into in a short comment - there's an aphorism about the current situation that I'm hearing more and more.
"There's never been a better time to make a film, and never been a worse time to get anyone to watch it."
Like tjradcliffe, I'm experimenting with ways around it. And like him I've ended up settling on serial works - both Carcosa, which is mentioned in the article, and other stuff that I'll be bringing out shortly. But that's far from a complete solution to the problem.
It's nice to dream of doing something that goes viral!!11!!! and gets me a lot of new followers but I don't think that's any more likely than me getting "discovered" out of the blue when a major publisher stumbles across my comic and excitedly offers me a publishing deal.
Most artists who were successful at the DIY thing got fame with a major label at some point (Trent Reznor, Radiohead, etc). So as long as artists depend on labels to get their music heard, labels are going to dictate copyrights and licensing to a degree.
No fantasy author in their right mind would think "Wow, my work will stop being censored only 90 years from now, even though I will be dead! I will refrain from writing it because my ancestors will make less money."
If people are to live from writing books, the advance for writing books need to come from somewhere. Crowd funding might be one viable way forward -- I've funded a few graphic novels on kickstarter -- but I don't think any of those have released the work under a CC0 or similar license (I would have been even more exited to fund them if they did).
One problem is that when something is published, it is under copyright. So copyright/the license will need to be changed. I suppose one could print a license text in a book/comic stating that "all rights are reserved until 2020, at which point this work shall be free under a CC0 license". But it will only be under a CC0 license as long as the original author/publisher maintains copyright.
What happens if someone buys the copyright? I suppose the license can't be revoked (that'd be the end of copyleft software) -- but it could create some confusion if a second instalment was released under stricter copyright. Not to mention the need for a trademark license (as I understand it, that's needed for things like characters?).
I don't think I own any notable works of fiction that are recent and not under traditional copyright. I have purchased some music that is, and eg. the TV series "Pioneer One"[2].
Well, I suppose I have a copy of some of Cory Doctorow's novels, but I haven't gotten around to reading them yet -- nor have I bought any of them (yet) either.
Stross (edit: guest poster Hugh Hancock) and zillions of others are complaining about the outcome of this dynamic, not proposing any way to change it. I like your critique (don't complain, go outside system personally) but as a personal recommendation it will be rejected almost always (see above). To have a real crack at changing the dynamic, 'people' need to figure out how to peer produce cultural relevance independent of the system and compete on policy in a way that furthers peer production rather than merely mitigates excesses. Demanding public domain for public funding is one policy item to push on, currently outre for cultural funding/subsidy.
The system is set up in a way that ensures that individual creators (or, rather, their rightsholders) can profit, at the expense of the public domain that no powerful entities can profitably defend.
Basically, copyright is now a one-way street, when it was supposed to be a two-way bargain.
For that matter, how much money has gone into making any of the retellings of traditional fables and myth that has been bread and butter for Disney's animated features since 'Snow White'? (And into relentlessly policing the unauthorized use of the Disney rendition of these characters?)
There is a lot of creative accounting going on in Hollywood, but there is an entire industry built on making these movies that are the only lawyer-approved way of working with these characters. It has its pitfalls but if you can get into it, you can have a fairly comfortable middle-class lifestyle, if you don't mind regular periods of unemployment when one feature/tv show/etc ends and you haven't found a new one yet. And occasionally having some creative accounting fail to pay the last few bills of the subcontracted effects company you working for.
We are even beginning to get better about rewarding the people who work down in the comic-book trenches creating these characters. Creators reaching their prime learnt from the miserable treatment Marvel and DC gave folks like Siegel & Shuster (Superman's creators) or Jack Kirby (co-creator of pretty much the entire fucking Marvel Universe), and became more canny about not signing all their rights away - Eastman and Laird (Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles) are a great example.
It's not a magic unicorn world that automatically reward what's important.
Yeah, nothing except no studio would touch those works if you tell them you want to put them out as public domain / CC, much less fund them (so visually they wont be able to compete in the first place).
Besides, movie theaters have distrubution deals with those same studios and distributions companies, and as they wont be taking those movies, theaters wont get them either.
>And nothing stops the public from taking up these public domain works instead of the for-profit products released in movie theaters or in print.
Yeah, nothing except of actual non availability at a movie theater near them, or (especially for web based distribution) the relative power of hundrends of millions of advertising and marketing vs the obscurity of some new indie movie.
First when the company was founded, and then when they started selling music via iTunes.