I can't imagine a scenario where having python installed on a Linux desktop with non-ancient hardware would be a drawback.
This is just an example that some of their packaging policies are a bit odd, but they are working on this. Imagine using Nix on an embedded device. All those extra dependencies might make a difference in terms of resources used.
That still doesn't explain why installing python is such a big deal for you, or why your desire to not install python is stronger than your desire to install mutt.
I'm not even sure what you mean by "your version of python is now tied to your email client and can't be upgraded separately". As long as the deps for each package are satisfied, either one can be upgraded.