How Reddit became the Alamo of the Internet’s ongoing culture war
washingtonpost.com
washingtonpost.com
By their fruits you shall know them, and what these harassers are doing to reddit clearly shows what they did inside their subreddits.
Ideals aren't granular and are difficult to assess if you ascribe morals to them. They are standards of perfection. Is freedom of speech "good"? I quite like it, at times America has stood for it, China has had a stance firmly against it. Ideals prescribe consistency. Reddit has embodied the ideals of freedom, community & recursive self-improvement.
> It's rare that I see someone say that "reddit is good" without some qualification like "make sure to unsubscribe from the default subreddits" or "only subscribe to the smaller subreddits".
Television is good, make sure not to watch primetime news. Mass market content caters to the lowest common denominator. Reddit tried to reposition itself as a mass market media company, sort of like yahoo[0]. The "front page" is something that "could" appeal to anyone. It is just like the ycombinator mantra "Make something a few people love rather than something a lot of people like", that is basically defaults vs. your fav "underground" sub.
> If reddit as it is presented to a new user is bad, where are the good ideals?
This is one of the problems with the narrative. "Reddit" is a disparate set of small communities loosely bound by some overlapping users and a URL.
America is bad.
Evaluate that statement. Are people in Idaho "bad" because some people in NY are "bad"? Is NY "bad" because people on Long Island, are "bad"? Reddit isn't one contiguous community. It is tens of thousands of communities. Some of them share users, but there are so many viewpoints on reddit that it is silly to say "Reddit does/thinks/is X" unless you are referring to corporate decisions, or something very general.
> America is bad.
It's my understanding that when you visit reddit without an account, or when you first sign up for an account, you get a list of default subscriptions and it is up to the user to manually unsubscribe from the defaults and manually subscribe to different subreddits so your analogy isn't very accurate. A better analogy would be something like "every new immigrant to America is placed in Wilmington Deleware with $40 in food vouchers." Unless I'm misunderstanding, all new users get the same experience and in my opinion it is a bad one.
Yes.
Apart from that, I don't think anybody who hasn't worked with her gets to judge her. She was a high-level executive at one of the largest vc firms so she can't be entirely stupid.
I also disagree with "anybody who hasn't worked with her gets to judge her". I have never worked with David Cameron either, still I feel I can judge his leadership.
The corporate media is the enforcer of political correctness.
Why? Because the corporate media is supported by advertising purchased by the big corporations, and so the media is the mouthpiece for the big corporations.
Political correctness helps mold and shape the culture of america.
A politically correct culture helps the big corporations squeeze more immigrants into America and into the workforce. The big corporations love multiculturalism and inclusiveness because that helps grow america, help increase the GDP, helps increase the workforce, increase the supply of labor etc.
This all helps increase corporate profits. Which means more money spent on ads in the media.
So the media will demonize and ruin any politically incorrect website that is on the way up. Hence, reddit dances to the tune played by the media.
But maybe I am just not following mainstream media sources closely enough to see what you're seeing. I admittedly stay fairly far away from TV news and stuff.
What I would really like to know is why subreddits like coontown (racism against black people) are still there if fatpeoplehate was banned. What exactly made them ban it. A little honestly and openness would help everyone, at least I see no reason against it?
"When we are using the word "harass", we're not talking about "being annoying" or vote manipulation or anything. We're talking about men and women whose lives are being affected and worry for their safety every day, because people from a certain community on reddit have decided to actually threaten them, online and off, every day. When you've had to talk to as many victims of it as we have, you'd understand that a brigade from one subreddit to another is miles away from the harassment we don't want being generated on our site."
Based on a brief look at coontown, it looks like it is a generic black people are bad forum. The only mentions I saw of specific black people were black people who were in the news.
That seems to be the key distinction.
I'm personally against the PC "SJW's" that force their ideology on people under the moniker of feminism, but the crowd that seems to be pushing the pro-FPH movement is the gamergate crowd. The gamergate crowd needs to distance its selft from FPH and focus on reddit censorship and censorship in general.
All in all this is pretty embarrassing for reddit and everyone involved. All this energy put into "censorship" of a sub for hating fat people and hardly any outrage at things like government surveillance.