Trying to understand the nature of understanding: the etymologies
0a.io
0a.io
It was nice to see the classical Chinese here. I have some knowledge of it (not an expert - currently translating https://en.wikisource.org/wiki/Translation:Manshu), though I'm not sure how closely the narrative follows. Personally I would suggest 理 should only be taken in the etymological context of 理解 to mean 'logic or reason', and 解 to 'explain'. The character evolution stuff is neither here nor there when taken in isolation (ie. outside the context of the compound double-glyph word), though the basic idea of 'explain' deriving from 'loosen' (in turn deriving from hacking the horns off oxen) is interesting as it seems the core explanatory notion of 'unfastening' or 'allowing access to something that was previously present, but opaque or impermeable' could be one major semantic etymology within the global history of the very human meme of 'understanding'. I suppose there would surely have been alternative ways to express understanding during the classical period of the Chinese language, which brings me to the main point: fundamentally one should first consider that classical Chinese was grammatically a completely different language to either Indo-European or modern Chinese/Japanese/Korean/Vietnamese, in ways which explicitly affect both the frequency and specificity of verb use (if indeed they can be accurately defined in the context of classical Chinese, or are used at all), thus in fact the author is comparing apples to oranges on multiple levels.
As a couple of missed potential tangents for the author, over a decade ago I happened to win a scholarship in ancient Chinese study through a cursory retelling of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/When_a_white_horse_is_not_a_ho... as the story of the Logicians or School of Names https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/School_of_Names - a 5th-3rd century BCE philosophical school that analyzed semantics, particularly around notions of what we would more casually call in English 'the verb to be'. Comprehension or understanding was thus under active research from a very early stage. For another example, take the following statements on Taoism: 道可道非常道 ("The Tao that can be told is not the eternal Tao") and 名可名非常名 ("The name that can be named is not the eternal name.")
It would also have been nice to see an attempt at including Sanskrit, the other obvious alternative in Asia (its vast, heavily philosophical and analytical corpus of text is likely a fertile ground for research) - eg. see http://sanskritdictionary.com/?iencoding=iast&q=understand&l... or http://www.spokensanskrit.de/index.php?script=HK&beginning=0... for an indicator of the potential volume of etymologies within this space. Add more if you try relative synonyms such as comprehend. Tamil, reportedly considered equally ancient in some respects, may also have enough early differences from Sanskrit conceptions of understanding to merit a mention.
Are there any books exploring these unified perceptions of historical linguistic/cultural/semantic etymologies within a global or pan-humanist epistemological context? If not, it sure would be fun to write one!
I’m been trying to look for books on such topic too. I don’t think one that really expatiates on that exists. If I have the time I’d love to do some extensive research and (after having gained arcane knowledge and great insight) write one!