The Dark Web as You Know It Is a Myth
wired.com
wired.com
The lies were incredibly obvious to anyone that's read about the previous incidences of Satanic Ritual Abuse panics, but it still took the press some time to catch on. It also inspired the usual crop of well-meaning fools saying things like - "well clearly these children are traumatised and this is their reality, even if there is no evidence"
I'm also not completely clear on what they think is a myth; it would be helpful if excerpts of other media were included and shown to be false.
edit: there's a legitimate point that people confuse the deep web with the dark web, but that doesn't make either a myth.
...And in the dark web -- they now have a Tor-friendly Onion address!
Facebook profiles that can only be found by using Tor (which I don't believe exist) would be in the dark web.
Maybe that's where the "Dark Web is bigger than the regular internet" meme comes from.
They somehow mix up the Dark Web and Deep Web (which are ill defined terms already) and combine their mythologies into one hilariously incorrect idea that there is a whole underground society 10 times bigger than the regular web.
More hilarious is how many of these charts put 4chan or the Pirate Bay just below the surface, as if they are hard to find sites. These diagrams are incorrect every way you look at them, besides maybe a "the lower you go, I'm implying the sites are less moral".
As someone who's done a fair bit of 'dark web' browsing, still the most frightening things I've seen have been on 4chan.
And of course the govt would love for you to think that the dark web is something only for criminals.
There are literally dozens of websites on the darknet that source much of the content that is disturbing on 4chan and act as exchange points for such content.
However, both you and the article are correct that there's nothing particularly surprising or disturbing about this -- there are plenty of other dark corners of the internet where such things lurk. The interesting parts of the dark web are the same parts as the normal web -- the deep web. Just like with the normal internet, you need to know where you're going and a few of the right knocks before you see anything really interesting.
On the open internet, a few magic nondescript addresses, a few specific keys that are indistinguishable from random ones -- and suddenly, you're playing fluid dynamics engineer on someone's hardware instead of just reading about fluid dynamics. Similarly, there are dark net sites that are essentially access portals to other places on the internet, are generally not advertised to people (and so don't make the news rounds like Silk Road or Tor Wiki or Freedom Hosting), and are considerably more interesting than things like hosting child pornography, selling drugs, or instructing on how to make bombs (which is what most of the surface dark net consists of).
Everything else is just showrooms and advertising posters.
You can't just leave it at that, tell us more!
Another frightening thing, since we're on the topic, is a bit more complex for me to explain, but if you search for "Perth Group" you will find there is a group of people who seriously question the viral model in Biology and to what extent it explains AIDS and HIV.
I wrote this way back in 2001, and I'm not convinced that in the intervening years much has changed: http://www.alphadevx.com/a/30-The-Invisible-Web
It sounds like you're discussing some grotesque subterranean civilization, but it's really an awful lot of people walking around the same city you are, with crime that isn't really that organized.
"These aren't the webs you're looking for."
grins