Solve actual problems to which you currently do not have a solution and observe the process, not the solution.
Solve actual problems to which you currently do not have a solution and observe the process, not the solution.
http://www.deathandtaxesmag.com/200732/google-admits-its-fam...
I mean actual as in 'problem that you actually have and that needs solving'.
OTOH if you feel that the problems you are dealing with are solvable (and they had better be) then working together with your new prospective hire on some aspect of them will quickly give you insight into how they would go about this and whether or not they have something to contribute.
It's by no means a super necessary skill to have though. And certainly it makes for a rather silly interview question. I would guess it takes no more than half an hour to an hour to train yourself to do estimation problems.
What are the exact instructions for "observing the process"?
Does it measure some underlying factor that's independent of the examiner?
How do we disentangle the influence of youth, good looks, and verbal skills?
I suspect the answers won't be flattering to those who think they can measure creativity today.
Essentially you are saying that there is no such thing as a fair interview process (and I'd agree with that).