> Given that they had virtually 0 real users, I'm not convinced the strict fintech laws are a necessity.
They had virtually 0 real users because "strict fintech laws" were applied to them while they were still actively limiting their number of users and scope of use while planning to scale out.
I'm not sure how that is a demonstration that the "free market on its own is already pretty good at avoiding dodgy companies".
> One might think of Mt.Gox as a counterexample.
Well, yeah. Among others.
> However, I see that debacle more as an unintended consequence of too much regulation: making it too hard to setup legit exchanges reduces consumer choice and forces users onto alternatives like Mt.Gox even though they don't really trust them.
So, if a "dodgy company" fails before it gets many users (even if that failure is a direct result of regulatory action!), this proves that financial regulation isn't needed and the free market works to constrain dodgy companies.
And if a "dodgy company" gets lots of users and lots of real money before it fails and inflicts widespread harm on a large number of users when it fails, that also proves that financial regulation isn't necessary.
Is there any conceivable set of facts which you would not characterize as demonstrating that financial regulation isn't necessary?