When using Git's mail features -- remember, not everyone uses GitHub -- the first line of a commit is a subject line. It's good practice to just think of it that way. If you write sentences in your subject lines in e-mail, I guess, that's up to you. Don't take it from me, read the Tim Pope counterpoint, with eight extremely good reasons for concise subjects in the closing paragraph:
http://tbaggery.com/2008/04/19/a-note-about-git-commit-messa...
Strong disagree with antirez on this one. Even vim filetype gitcommit disagrees. (Try it on the "smart synopsis" example.)