How We Make Cars Is a Bigger Environmental Issue Than How We Fuel Them
radar.oreilly.com
radar.oreilly.com
The connectors are kind of strange for carbon fiber tubes. The video shows them just slipping the tubes into the larger tubular connectors. They don't show how they attach them. That's just a test assembly. Now they have to glue it all together somehow, which is a touchy operation for carbon fiber to metal bonds. BMW avoids those in their carbon-fiber car.
Building tube cars in a small shop is quite practical, and lots of racers do it. It's not cheaper than mass-produced cars.
The point is to be less damaging to the environment, not less expensive.
Here's one study, http://www.environment.ucla.edu/media/files/BatteryElectricV... - look at Figure 1 and 2, battery & engine so dominate the manufacturing footprints that everything fades into insignificance.
Of course, if you make the car really light you can somewhat reduce the required engine & battery. But not drastically as weight has little impact at cruising speed & you have regenerative braking in city.
That makes no difference because cost is a relative measure, not an absolute one. If you priced in CO2 then everything would be more expensive, but the relative difference between items would be unchanged. (And that money would go back to the citizens giving them more money to buy stuff, so effectively you did nothing at all. It would only work if there were low CO2 alternatives, but there are not any. All the renewable energy sources have decade long payouts, so at least initially emit lots of CO2, which you would have to pay tax on, so the tax makes renewable energy more expensive too.)
Because ultimately everything requires energy to make cost is an excellent proxy for energy, and in a world where most energy is from hydrocarbons, cost is a proxy for CO2.
Which one is accurate then ?
Note that the slide is not talking about the same measure (co2), the slide screenshot is titled "total environmental system damage" which smells a bit like picking an rarely-used but favourable metric here.
The research paper linked to from one of the linked articles (I followed the rabbit hole down a ways... http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1530-9290.2012.... it's the Norwegian study mentioned in http://spectrum.ieee.org/energy/renewables/unclean-at-any-sp...) says " vehicle production is not insignificant, contributing on the order of 10% to the life cycle GWP."
However, the article, and the statement from Maureen Cropper (who presumably knows what she's talking about) says that the majority of the impact comes from the manufacture of the vehicle.
Am I confused? Are people talking about two separate measures of impact, or is there something I'm missing? Having trouble reconciling all of this info.
My first car, a 1974 Land Rover series 3, is still going and will be for a long time to come.
Aluminum cars? Stainless steel?
I worry about the distribution/generation costs however.
I think the main idea should be necessary travel only. In 2015 the idea that most of us need to commute tens of miles shouldn't even be a thought; a big chunk of us can and should work from home or locally.
Case in point, everyone I know works in London in the city. None of them have a job that requires their presence.
Most problems are due to failing gearboxes, clutches, water pumps, belts, electrical components, axles, brake disks, glue deteriorating over time, ... Mostly it just becomes economically unfeasible to replace all parts that start failing over time.
But true, an electrical car has a lot less components that are prone to wear, but there still are parts that will wear down and be bloody expensive.
And then we're not even talking about the electronics that become more and more important in these electrical cars. These are mostly already a bit dated when a car is brand-new - so what about in 5 year? These also don't have an infinite life. Right now cars are being equiped with already aging tech and communication standards. Right now you have Bluetooth, WiFi, Edge/3G/LTE, ... - and in 10 years those things will probably still be around in some backward compatible way. But in 15 or 20 years? Wouldn't put my money on that.
There are people driving cars with multiple hundreds of thousands of miles on them, all of which have been carefully maintained in dry countries. I suspect a lot of cars end their life owned by someone who wants the absolute minimum maintenance cost and are scrapped at the first expensive repair.
http://www.divergentmicrofactories.com/wp-content/uploads/20...
Materials and methods of processing matter a great deal.
OEs care very much about this but the progressive fuel economy requirements make it worth their while meet the requirements all else be damned