Notably, there is enough lithium in the groundwater in certain areas of the US that this "study" has been happening for a long time. El Paso, Texas has high naturally occuring lithium in the groundwater, and is widely reputed to have less violence than comparable cities with less lithium in their water. I haven't read the whole thing, but remarkably, a recent paper seems to have shown this to be true, at least for suicide mortality.
Lithium in the public water supply and suicide mortality in Texas (Blüml et al, 2013)
There is increasing evidence from ecological studies that
lithium levels in drinking water are inversely associated
with suicide mortality. Previous studies of this
association were criticized for using inadequate
statistical methods and neglecting socioeconomic
confounders. This study evaluated the association between
lithium levels in the public water supply and county-based
suicide rates in Texas. A state-wide sample of 3123 lithium
measurements in the public water supply was examined
relative to suicide rates in 226 Texas counties. Linear and
Poisson regression models were adjusted for socioeconomic
factors in estimating the association. Lithium levels in
the public water supply were negatively associated with
suicide rates in most statistical analyses. The findings
provide confirmatory evidence that higher lithium levels in
the public drinking water are associated with lower suicide
rates.
https://www.gwern.net/docs/lithium/2013-bluml.pdfEdit: I just realized that the Op Ed linked from the main article mentions the same evidence, although without reference to that particular paper: http://www.nytimes.com/2014/09/14/opinion/sunday/should-we-a...