Ok, so let's say you don't buy the angle that he deserves the success he's had. Do you think Sublime Text's success is a coincidence? Jon is a single engineer who's built pretty much every aspect of it, from a custom cross-platform UI that doesn't suck, to a custom editor control, more recently a parallel custom regex engine to make syntax highlighting faster and more robust. He's taken performance seriously from day one.
By contrast, Atom started development in 2008 and had a team of engineers working on it. It has more community involvement and bells and whistles, but still seems a bit behind in performance.
I would argue that Jon and his priorities and decisions are one of the biggest reasons Sublime Text has been successful. Would open sourcing it help Jon keep up the focus and insight he has shown in the past? Or, would it likely take up a large amount of his time?
I don't have an insight that anyone else doesn't have. And I could be completely wrong, but I feel like if open source would ensure a better product, Lime would have taken off. Or there would be other, strong, cross-platform text editors written in desktop technologies.