Wtf? what is the justification for this?
Wtf? what is the justification for this?
It's called a "money grab". Wouldn't you love to be able to tax photographers for taking pictures of public places too?
I mean, it's not as if there will be no pictures of the Eiffel Tower at night, that'd be silly. They'll just be able to restrict those photos to those willing to pay licensing fees.
But this is Europe we're talking about... the same people who think the label "cheddar cheese" should be copyrightable.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Geographical_indications_and_t...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cheddar_cheese
This actually seems reasonable to me, perhaps because I am European and also rather fond of good cheese!
Another example is champagne. Sparkling wine from other regions is not technically champagne.
However, limiting the ability of the public to photograph things outdoors doesn't seem quite comparable. If a real estate company owned a significant number of buildings in a downtown area, could they then copyright the skyline of a city as the creative work of their collective architectural firms?
If you made a large installation visible from space (say, the Palm Islands in Dubai), could you claim copyright on images of Earth with high enough detail to make out your work?
Basically, what's the limit on this, because it seems like it has a pretty high ceiling for ridiculousness.
Usually copyright belongs to the architect and can't be transferred to anyone in Europe.
> If you made a large installation visible from space (say, the Palm Islands in Dubai), could you claim copyright on images of Earth with high enough detail to make out your work?
I'm pretty sure that's already the case in many jurisdictions, including Germany where there is freedom of panorama. That only applies for images taken without technical assistance to get the view and using a satellite to take the picture is certainly technical assistance (as is a ladder btw.).
Also can shops not sue Google as their window displays have been copied by Google's streetview photographers (and copied and recopied many times over by Google).
Based on such a draconian interpretation of copyright law I imagine a large company could successfully sue Google with this (eg if new owners were asset stripping anyway and so didn't need to use Google for advertising/location services).
On that note: http://streetghosts.net/
That is the most asinine thing I have ever heard.
Soon we won't be able to take photographs of anything...
(I suppose you could argue that the ability to get to said nature is often dependent on roads and other transit networks...)
How? Just like any other regular old copyright violation.
I wonder if there's anything that would stop a European country from copying the Eiffel tower?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Eiffel_Tower_replicas
The Eiffel tower isn't copyrighted anymore so there is nothing that would stop anybody.