How the Recession Reshaped the Economy, in 255 Charts (2014)
nytimes.com
nytimes.com
The growth in (mostly) all-things related to software is not much of a surprise, though that old gas related activity was the only other bright spot in the economy (more jobs, higher wages) was. However, even in software, average wages are increasing, but not by a lot. Obviously the average wage is probably not that informative but perhaps it does point to a fundamental limit in human productivity that will only be overcome with better tools and techniques.
In inflation adjusted terms, worker productivity has increased almost 75% between 1973 and 2013, while compensation for production workers has increased less than 10%. Wages at the top 1% have grown 138% since 1979 compared to 15% for the bottom 90%, and it gets direr if you start looking at the bottom 50% (stagnant) or bottom 10% (5% decrease) instead.
Our economy is producing more and more, we are far from hitting any kind of limits on productivity, but it's only enriching a select few while the vast majority deal with flat income and ever-rising cost of living.
>Using wages as a picture welfare is unproductively restrictive. Using total compensation yields a very different picture.(http://i.imgur.com/nCCCuSC.png) Real compensation accounts for all forms of income paid to employees, including health care costs and defined contribution plans. Additionally, the CPI overstates inflation, and changing household dynamics/other forms of income (https://www.minneapolisfed.org/publications/the-region/where...) have substantive implications for any picture of overall income growth. Context matters for how we should view these trends.(http://www.igmchicago.org/igm-economic-experts-panel/poll-re...)
https://www.reddit.com/r/Economics/comments/3by8tb/elizabeth...
It shouldn't take much thought to realise that's exactly how taxation works.
So effectively that argument simply treats benefits that would be funded from taxation in more rationally managed countries as somehow magically equivalent to private income.
Clearly, that's not even good sophistry - although it's about par for the course for a modern orthodox economic argument, so I suppose no one is going to be surprised by the low quality.
Exactly. It's not very reassuring to tell me my total compensation includes $8000 "worth" of insurance that turns out to cover very little in the event of a catastrophe.
Post-ACA, a company calling health insurance part of your compensation package is like them calling payroll tax part of your compensation. Which almost no one does historically, because that's stupid.
It's not reasonable to argue that "real compensation" has increased between year X and year Y by counting tax burdens in year Y but not in year X. The reason that such a comparison is stupid and wrong should be obvious. It's slightly more reasonable to argue that additional taxes have eaten up projected wage increases. (But that argument is wrong.)
> If your employer promised you a full pension, wouldn't you consider that a part of compensation?
The difference here is that the Government more or less never requires a private company to provide a full pension.
it's not reasonable to argue that "real compensation" has increased between year X and year Y by counting tax burdens in year Y but not in year X.
It is when the government introduces new "taxes" in year Y, which would have been equivalent to salary in year X.
This is a different argument and I've already addressed it in my post above:
It's slightly more reasonable to argue that additional taxes have eaten up projected wage increases. (But that argument is wrong.)
Again, the argument you are making is that taxes offset increases in income that would have increased otherwise, NOT that income has actually increased.
But, as I stated above, this argument is clearly and obviously wrong -- a conclusion that is unambiguously supported by the data. Tax increases cannot explain a multi-decade stagnation in income, ESPECIALLY because NET corporate taxes have net decreased in that period of time [1].
(As a complete aside, when every corporate tax break is passed on to either the customer or the employee, I'll be ready to entertain even the criteria I established above. But while companies pocket the difference and perform stock buy backs [2], economists who argue tax increases count as increases in income are being disingenuous (edit: changed wording).
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corporate_tax_in_the_United_St...
[2] Clinton mentioned that H.W. Bush warned him not to provide a no-strings-attached tax holiday for this exact reason; see his latest interview on the Daily Show.
All your verbal arguments are obfuscation. This is simple arithmetic.
What we would like to measure is the total post-tax and post-govt spending utility of a person:
total utility = post-tax compensation + govt spending per person.
That is what should be going up. But it's hard to measure all these things, so instead we can try to measure total compensation. When you redefine health care to be a tax, you are moving health care from the "post-tax compensation" category, to the "govt spending per person" category. Then you are arguing that post-tax compensation is going down, but that is just because of your accounting choice.
Your logic would only apply if the government was initially providing free healthcare, and then moved to a regime where healthcare was provided by employers, which is not what happened. The problem with your reasoning is that it deals with everything except economic fundamentals, i.e. total consumption per person.
Sorry, I didn't mean you specifically (unless you're an economist, I guess). You're right though, I've changed the wording.
> Your logic would only apply if the government was initially providing free healthcare, and then moved to a regime where healthcare was provided by employers, which is not what happened.
The government shifted the responsibility for insurance from individuals to corporations. Fact: if a company does not provide insurance, then they pay a tax. Fact: SCOTUS called this requirement a tax.
> The problem with your reasoning is that it deals with everything except economic fundamentals, i.e. total consumption per person.
The problem with your argument is that you assume that taxes attached to empoyment are somehow different from other taxes, and ignore the fact that businesses have benefited from decreased taxes for decades and yet wages have stagnated. (Edit: Concretely, if I impose a new flat tax on corporate profits, does that count as "compensation"? No, it doesn't. The issue of how it effects compensation is separate. Just because a tax is attached to employment doesn't make that tax part of compensation.)
Again, the issue is dead simple: do increased corporate taxes explain income stagnation? Given that corporate taxes have in fact decreased over the time period we are talking about, the causation you're proposed is literally vacuous ("vacuous" here is a technical description of the problem with your argument, not an insult).
In general, think of taxes attached to income "use taxes" on the country's human capital, rather than "mandatory employee compensation". Because historically we have never included taxes as part of "compensation", and starting that practice now is uninformative unless we take into account the global perspective on corporate taxes.
PS: Wellness programs are a classic case of 'fake' compensation. When the net cost is ~zero it's not compensation. It's like calling safety equipment compensation, because it's an expense.
In many cases is roughly what social security does. In almost all cases, this is not too grossly far off from what social security does.
No, employer's contributions to social security are not typically counted as compensation.
More importantly, though, this is beside the point because a) the exact thing you describe doesn't happen in the US; b) to the extent things like it happen, we don't historically consider them compensatory; and c) again, taxes can't explain income stagnation when net taxation is down... so even if what you're saying is true, it's irrelevant to the central point of the discussion.
If your employer is paying $6K per year, that is additional compensation beyond the $2K per year minimal plan the have to pay for.
https://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/graph/fredgraph.png?g=...
They were tied together until the 1970s, and then they began to diverge. The economic success of the country has been reflected less and less in the total compensation of the average worker since then.
Here's centered at 1950: https://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/graph/fredgraph.png?g=...
Here's 2009: https://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/graph/fredgraph.png?g=...
That being said, if you look at the slope of the lines in all three views, it's still easy to see that they diverge. In the 1950s one, you can tell that the GDP takes off in the 80s without bringing compensation with it, and the productivity does the same in the mid-70s. This is directly contrary to the whole "rising tide raises all boats" arguments from that era.
Cost of living goes up when there's more desirable stuff to live on, not just bare monetary inflation. And wages aren't equal to income. Also, demographics! Many more workers, including more per household and more newer to these shores.
I'd take that bet. Pay off my 15-year mortgage in 5 years and dump the rest of my money into savings. Then when the kids got old enough for college I'd write a check for the hundreds of dollars it would cost for a 4-year education.
Do you know anything of the 70s economy?
edit: grammar
Also, I'd imagine at least some of the decline is for the same reason we've seen decline in lots of other sectors -- HR processes are some of the easier ones to automate (no robotics, often tasks are fairly well defined)