Nice experiment! Link for the lazy: https://github.com/goferito/gapoc
I guess SEO people already know this, the question is: can you trust a SEO consultant?
I guess SEO people already know this, the question is: can you trust a SEO consultant?
Use something like http://zoomrank.com/ to monitor the position of your site in the various search engines over time; establish a baseline, hire the SEO consultant, and look at your placement graphs. Did you fail to improve, or even go down? Then don't pay the snake oil salesman.