It's a structural Greek problem, not a German one.
It's a structural Greek problem, not a German one.
If you were Greek (Especially a young Greek) and had no prospects for a future and no hope for job in a country with highest unemployment (especially among the youngest) in EU, the black economy might be very attractive...
Also I am sure the "I did not cause this debt hence why should I pay taxes for it" attitude might be very prevailent
And do you blame them? You might feel all fine and mighty sitting in your chair reading HN (probably while at work) towards those "lazy" Greeks, but all you have to do is imagine yourself in the same situation.
The Greek economy already has contracted more and for longer than the US during the Great Depression (which did not have a larger debt burden then), let that fact focus your mind, here is a graph
http://i.imgur.com/LKQ6Mov.jpg
Don't forget that the Great Depression years where the golden age for criminals in the US, like I said its symptom of the problem not the root cause.
8| What sort of weird alternate universe can this sort of statement come from? Are you claiming tax dodging would go away if there wasn't austerity? So, 8 years ago there was no tax evasion in Greece, or at least no more than average?
While I do not condone it, it is plainly obvious that the average person in Greece will have no "ethical" issues dodging taxes especially seeing that unemployment is high (hence black/gray economy might be the ONLY choice) and many people especially the younger generation did not rack up this debt and are the ones suffering the most, might rightly be asking themselves why they should be the ones suffering and paying for it via taxes.
This won't blow over easily.
In fact this is the reason why its so difficult to turn around things in such countries. The issue is not technology or government policy. When you have a whole generation of people grow up in such a ecosystem, these practices seep into your culture and everyday life. You can only undo them gradually overtime, and sometimes it takes 2-3 generations to get out of it.
Another defining characteristic of a society where cash transactions are common - Every day corruption is omnipresent.
If that's so... and I generally agree it is... then why do people keep lending them money? Or perhaps rather, "lending" them money?
I actually find that a rich and interesting question not amenable to snap answers. But it doesn't make anybody involved look very good or ethical. Call it old fashioned of me, but neither borrowing money that you basically know you can't be paid back, nor lending money you basically know can't pay back, is very ethical. (Perhaps that's why the discussions about who's at "fault" keeps going around so viciously... the answer isn't "A XOR B", the answer is the union of everybody involved.)
Most of the money that's being lent is for repaying existing debts that come due. Like any bankruptcy (which is what this is, formally declared or not), the ECB is trying to smooth out the process and ensure creditors are treated equitably. As for "keeping lending them money", the bailout loans are tied to political reforms intended to fix the problems. How else would you do it?
If you're asking why creditors lent them money in the first place, a lot of that predates the financial crisis. A lot of it was before rampant fraud in Greek governmental accounting became apparent. And perhaps people had more faith in European integration and expected Germany to pay Greece's debts if they ever get into trouble.
Me personally? Try a lot harder to not get into that problem in the first place.
I don't mean that sarcastically or as a snap answer exactly. My views on debt are right now somewhat old fashioned, and they're getting older-fashioned pretty quickly, directly in response to current events. Humans have a long experience with debt, a lot of that experience has boiled down to "treat it as radioactive waste", and I'm increasingly unconvinced that all of our fancy financial tools have actually removed the underlying reasons for that millenia-old assessment, rather than pushing those reasons around with ever-more sophisticated tools into ever-more complicated cognitive blind spots, until one day it blows up even worse than it used to be able to.
A sober analysis of a lot of the debt in the world right now is that it simply isn't going to be repaid, for mathematical reasons, and that's been true for quite a while now. (The crisis merely revealed what should already have been obvious, and it is obvious that many people still don't think this is true even after that.) And a lot of that debt has been moved behind things like "guaranteed pensions" and other things that are amenable to various forms of jiggery-pokery on the accounting.
So, that's great and all, but what do we do now, right? Because no amount of wishing for changes in the past will cause them to manifest. To which my answer is basically sunk-cost fallacy, stop throwing good money after the bad. Political restructurings don't appear to be working, so stop that. But then, I'm an engineer, not a politician... "stop doing things that don't work" is very easy for me but might as well be a concept from the planet Vulcan for a politician, who is so full of nuance that they can talk themselves right out of reality and consider it not merely moral, but noble.
It seems to me to be the opposite - most of the crises are caused not by the algorithmic side but by the human side. E.g. LCTM's positions famously were profitable - eventually, if humans hadn't panicked and forced them to sell off. More recently, a lot of the subprime CDSes never actually paid out - it's just that people worried, and lowered the value of them. As was said of a recent DeutscheBank lawsuit, "Lehman would still be in business if they hadn't had to mark their positions to market".
> So, that's great and all, but what do we do now, right? Because no amount of wishing for changes in the past will cause them to manifest. To which my answer is basically sunk-cost fallacy, stop throwing good money after the bad. Political restructurings don't appear to be working, so stop that. But then, I'm an engineer, not a politician... "stop doing things that don't work" is very easy for me but might as well be a concept from the planet Vulcan for a politician, who is so full of nuance that they can talk themselves right out of reality and consider it not merely moral, but noble.
So you're saying a lot of self-righteous words there, but what are you concretely proposing? Just cut Greece off, revoke their authority to print Euros, and leave them to fend for themselves with their creditors? That is certainly an option, but it's not without costs to say the least. Arguably even if that ends up happening, by muddling through for a bit first we've made things better than they would have been. You can only say the things we've been doing "don't work" if you're confident things wouldn't have been worse without them. The current approach is certainly undignified, but fundamentally I wouldn't say it doesn't work.
I believe I was pretty clear that none of the options are good right now.
And while that doesn't solve the problem we face now by any means, we must also not fall into the trap of being so focused on the near-term that we forget to learn from what happened, which I think is where we are now. It is probably rational for a lot more governments to start getting a lot more nervous about debt load, but instead we've all but talked ourselves into the belief that debt-fueled government spending is a moral necessity, and anyone who disagrees is an idiot. I hope that's right, even as I fear it's not (it's very ahistorical, if nothing else), because it's certainly the path we're committed to now.
"The current approach is certainly undignified, but fundamentally I wouldn't say it doesn't work."
It hasn't worked yet. It has perhaps not "failed" yet, but it certainly hasn't "worked". I recognize this is not a contradiction of what you said, but the same sort of idea through a different linguistic lens.
I consider this as part of the larger picture. We're still in the 2008 crisis, still marching along, still using the same techniques to resolve it. In that sense, this has failed; we're still in 2008, we have no immediate prospect of escaping from it, and our current plan is to continue doing the same things. I feel I'm justified in questioning why our "solutions" are doing so poorly.
I truly hope that you get to continue saying that this hasn't failed for a lot longer, but I fear that we are still in a situation where 2008 was still only the opening salvo, that the "solution" to 2008 was whackloads more debt for everybody, and that the next time the world economy burps it's going to go much worse because that option will have been played out. If this isn't failure, it sure isn't success.
If Greece had collapsed in 2010, the rest of Europe would have been hurt somewhat badly. By buying five years, the rest of Europe was able to position themselves so that a Greek collapse would not hurt them nearly so badly.
It is my impression that Greece did not use those five years nearly so wisely, but that's a different issue.
Let's look at it this way. What if they take that seriously and stop lending them money now?
Please note the amount of diplomatic and geo-political pressure being put on other european countries/creditors currently to bail them out and give them more funds. So this is damned if you do, and damned if you don't kind of a situation.
If what you said is taken seriously, Greece will not get a single penny now either in bail out money or other recovery loans.
You can give all the money to such people and they will only want more, it will fix nothing because they think they are 'entitled' to the free money. They will do no real work because they never have, and it will too painful to get off their high horse and realize they are subject to same standards as every one else in the world.
The dysfunctional tax system in Greece isn't the cause of the crisis. But people keep bringing it up because once the people of Greece can be depicted as corrupt and lazy we can morally justify any amount of hardship we force on them.
The problem with Greece is entirely structural. But the fundamental problem is that Greece doesn't have an economy that's strong enough to compete with northern Europe without substantial subsidies. Everything else is minor in comparison.