And it's not as if their debt hasn't been restructured.
And it's not as if their debt hasn't been restructured.
Yes, we did. And utterly doesn't even give it justice: http://www.truth-out.org/speakout/item/24456-the-math-of-mas...
EDIT: Someone downvoted me for this so I guess they're too lazy to read the article. In which case, I'll just copy paste the important parts.
They destroyed 25% of the country's forests; 56% of the roads; 50% to 90% of the bridges; 65% of automobiles; 60% of the trucks; 80% of the buses; 100% of the trains and railways; 80% of the factories; 100% of the water and sewage infrastructure.
...principal harbors were blown up. Installations, machinery and quays were destroyed." The Germans also blew up the strategic Corinth canal. In addition, the Germans sank 74 percent of the Greek ships and destroyed 100 percent of telephone communications.
"the occupying forces applied a systematic plan for the destruction of Hellenism: the burning of villages. 1,770 Greek villages lie in ashes. In certain parts of the country, particularly near the frontiers, destruction by fire reached the proportion of 90 % of the villages of every region."
The Germans and their allies killed or were responsible for the death of 13% of the Greek population.
Every country that has been a world power is pretty much guilty of this. Why aren't we picking on the English for the old empire or the thousands of wars and skirmishes on the continent between these powers? Or on the crusades? Picking on Germany is stupid and more Yanis Varoufakis-like hysterics. His over-the-top rhetoric and calling his own lenders "terrorists" is what's wrong with the world, not what's right.
Apparently, Greeks are willing to say or do anything except actually collect taxes and cut public spending. Thus far, Greece has been on the receiving end of historically generous loans.
Why did Germany deserve better terms after their adventures? Or if it's not a matter of deserving them but just a purely pragmatic question of those terms being useful to avoid a future catastrophe, why doesn't that pragmatism apply here?
It was even more "pragmatic" than that; it wasn't about preventing German civilians from starving or anything so humanitarian, it was the US wanting to stop the spread of communism. There's no similar "threat" in Greece today. Maybe if IS starts getting recruits near Greece the calculus will change.
Allowing Russia to trivially attack their borders and put up a Mediterranean blockade is unacceptable to the EU/NATO, but Tsipras is probably crazy enough to make this happen unless he gets the terms he demands. That said, the firing of Yanis Varoufakis probably means Tsipras is serious about cutting down the stupid Greek extremism that has made these talks impossible and probably wants to stay in the EU/Eurozone/NATO and will play ball on some level. I guess we will see.
Can you supply some documentation for this claim?
Millions are still officially listed as missing, mostly sent to slave labor camps in Siberia.
http://www.stern.de/politik/geschichte/kriegsgefangene-viele...
Also, civilian Germans in the territories occupied after the war were also put to forced work.
There's plenty of data on: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Forced_labor_of_Germans_after_...
Also, international humanitarian aid to Germany was initially forbidden. There were mass rapes (some estimates put victims at 2 million German woman) and massive famine (people going through winters with 1000-1500 calories per day).
The general idea after WW2 was to completely obliterate Germany, so it would never rise again. The change in mindset only came when Western countries realized that a strong Germany was the only effective defense agains Soviet expansion.
In the meantime, Greeks are worried that their fat retirement funds and unemployment insurance will be cut...
This makes no sense. The atrocities you list were almost all done by the Soviets, yet you somehow blame the West? The West invested into West Germany from the beginning (Im not arguing this, it takes time to ramp up rebuilding and yes there was a real lag period of post-war crazyiness, fatigue, and lack of money. We had our own dead to bury and our own economies to fix up first) and tried to build Berlin as a model Western city. Yeah, the Soviets did fuck all, but the western side was a totally different story.
Also, there's nothing wrong with forcing soldiers to rebuild what they broke. Oh you guys thought you could drop bombs and mortars endlessly and just go back home? This story should be a message to the young people clamoring for war today. If you lose, its not all hugs and sunshine. Its years of back-breaking work to undo the damage you have done.
West didn't "invested into West Germany from the begininng". Seriously, read the links I posted.
"Also, there's nothing wrong with forcing soldiers to rebuild what they broke."
Geneva conventions?
I'm not defending German actions or anything. I'm just showing that there's absolutely no way to compare Greece and post-WW2 Germany.
These only apply during wartime.
Yeah, the Germans suffered a lot after the war. But what do you expect to happen after the unbelievable suffering they inflicted on so many? The conditions you describe are pretty minor compared to what they put others through beforehand.
Now, that's not to say they deserved to suffer. Many, perhaps most, of those people were still innocent. But of course the same goes for the Greeks. Very few Greeks actually caused this debt crisis themselves, while many of them are now suffering for it.
Germans were forced into slave labor? They did it to others first, and worse. Germans starved? They starved others first, and worse. And yet despite never coming anywhere close to repaying the damage (how could you?) or experiencing suffering on anything like the scale they caused others (again, how could they?) the world didn't use that to keep holding their feet to the fire. They did for a bit, then moved on.
The business with containing Soviet expansion seems like the heart of the matter. Morality and retribution (not the same thing, of course!) get put aside when it comes time to resist a powerful enemy. But really, morality isn't a factor in international relations, except when it comes to attempting to sway the opinions of populations. It's all about what you want to happen and what you can do to make that come about. After WWII, what the Western Allies wanted to happen was for West Germany to become strong again and serve to resist Soviet expansion. They made it happen by forgiving debts and helping Germany rebuild. The Greek crisis seems to have no such goals or methods. Instead, it's a bunch of "they should do this and that" because of some idea of morality. And that argument falls really flat when the country making that moral argument benefitted greatly from other countries doing things differently for them within living memory.
It's not really about Germany or WWII or morality or revenge or any of that. It's basically, stop wagging your fingers and talking about what you think should be done, and start figuring out what your goals are and how to achieve them.
The article compares the current situation in Greece to post-WW2 Germany, I'm explaining why it doesn't make any sense to make such a comparison. I'm not talking about who deserved what or whatever, morality, retribution or anything related to that.
Go talk about morality or retribution somewhere else.
"After WWII, what the Western Allies wanted to happen was for West Germany to become strong again and serve to resist Soviet expansion."
Wrong, they wanted to transform Germany into an under-developed agrarian state that would never pose a threat again. Read your history. It only changed due to the Soviet threat, but that was after years of the previous policy.
https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html.
That means posting civilly and substantively, or not at all.
This is low. How does the last sentence relate to the rest of your comment? You present a dire situation for post-war Germany, which let me assure you is nothing compared to what Germans did in Greece (and Russia for that matter) during the war (like murdering kids), and then you close it with a comment for Greece which is quite irrelevant to the context. Or is that Greece which was devastated by German occupation more than any other country in WWII has to answer for what happened to Germany post-war. We didn’t even participate in any of that, we were busy killing each other in a civil war orchestrated by the Brits.
I’m sick and tired with the racism and hatred some people in here have towards Greece.
I'm sorry to add that you've also been making the threads worse by lashing out at other users. Please follow the HN guidelines and remain civil, even when others are being provocative.
https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
There aren't very many HNers who can articulate the Greek perspective first-hand to the rest of us, so you have a special contribution to make to these threads. Of your compatriots who have been posting, the ones I've seen have done so with impressive dignity, and they've raised the whole discourse as a result. So clearly it's possible, because they surely have the same emotions that you do.
Personally I will stop commenting in any posts relating to Greece, or any other non-technical/geeky post for that matter, since obviously my temperament is going ballistic these last couple of weeks.
But the entire discussion seems to keep falling back to "Germans suffered because they deserved". Whatever Germany did to Greece in the war does not change the fact that the situations in current Greece and post-WW2 Germany are not at all comparable.
I don't have any hatred towards Greece or Germany in this matter. But it makes no sense to say "look, Germans got part of their debts forgiven and now don't want the same for Greeks", when Germans were surviving on 1000 calories per day, and Greeks still enjoy full retirements and unemployment payouts.
I never said so. But comparing 1/3 under the poverty line vs. living on average on 1000 calories a day makes no sense. I'm not saying:
(1) Conditions in Greece aren't difficult (2) Greeks deserve what's happening
I'm saying:
(1) The two situations, Greece now vs post-WW2 Germany, are not comparable
Hopefully, despite today's harsh agreement, Greece will recover and be part of a strong Europe.
There's other reasons a second debt relief for Greece is a hard sell. They basically asking for new funding of about 50 Bil EUR while at the same time asking for a haircut. They're also asking for funding from economies that are much worse of and went through similarly bad recessions[1]. So at the moment the general stance (not only in germany) is quid pro quo - do your reforms and we'll fund you. Then there's the argument that extending the payment deadlines is actually a debt relief in all but using the word. The debt gets devalued at the inflation rate.
[1] Edit: obviously I'm not talking about germany here, but the east european members of the EU.
Which is insanity that will never work. You will just end up in an endless cycle of the Grecian economy worsening, the Grecian debt rising, and more pleas for debt relief, as has already been happening.
> They're also asking for funding from economies that are much worse of and went through similarly bad recessions[1].
These same destructive austerity policies have destroyed most economies in Europe. Look at the number of European economies that have not even reached their pre-2008 GDP due to these policies. Many are only beginning to recover now as austerity tapers off. In several the debt actually worsened because of falling GDP and rising unemployment.
Austerity policies have achieved nothing except for needlessly higher taxes, the rollback of parts of the welfare system at the expense of prolonged recessions and minimal (or no) debt reduction or debt increase.
And yet, people think more austerity is the solution for Greece? How can this be? How many times do troika GDP estimates have to be radically and totally wrong before people realize austerity is only destructive?
So what will work? Do a haircut and then hand them more money? Will that work? Because that's what they're asking for. A third bailout is what's being asked for.
Monetary policy in the Eurozone that put inflation above the present 0.2% would be helpful.
A Grexit would work and is probably the only realistic option, because the above two things are not going to happen.
Some of these options would also be painful, but at least there would be an end in sight. There is no end in sight with the loan request -> austerity demands -> worsening economy -> loan request cycle. Almost anything Greece does will be better than continuing in the same self-destructive cycle.
That might indeed work. But who's supposed to foot the bill? Since greece does not have the money and greece is openly stating they can't even pay the current loans. And I don't see how debt-forgiveness is helping here. A default might help, but greece is running a marginal primary surplus at best, so even with a default they'd be stuck where they are - in a pretty shitty place.
The only thing I could see that would help is a fiscal union, but a fiscal union would require all parties to give up some part of their control and seriously, I don't see that happening (though I wish it would)
[1] Yeah, these are technical terms. See Timothy Snyder, Bloodlands, 2010 for definitions.
A conflict that was furthermore started by an illegitimate government (literal nazis). On top of that most of that debt was because of reparations for the previous largest military conflict. Reparations that arguably led to the nazis taking power in the first place.
I understand why people like comparing the situations, but they are really completely different.
It was about learning from history.
You cannot compare this to the disastrous economic mismanagement by successive Greek govs.
No, but neither did Germany. In fact, despite bombings etc. the industrial infrastructure post-war was bigger than 1933 (because it was heavily built out during that period).
edit: Here is a source from German public television (skip to 4:20): https://www.planet-schule.de/sf/php/sendungen.php?sendung=91...
And beside the infrastructure destruction there were the ravages of war, disease, psychological, nutrition, etc.
Not to mention the obvious generation of men who died. A whole generation of men dead from warring.
No, it really wasn't :)
Heres a documentary from German public television. The interesting part starts at 4:20. I hope you can hear the English language, it has been dubbed in German:
https://www.planet-schule.de/sf/php/sendungen.php?sendung=91...
The national socialists came to power as a consequence of the severe deflation in the 1930s, not the hyperinflation 10 years earlier.
After all, they did the same thing to Japan too, which didn't have a treaty of Versailles.