Reddit is basically a society of 36M people now, roughly the size of Iraq. If it were a country, it'd be the 36th largest, bigger than Canada, Venezuela, and Taiwan. r/IAmA alone has 8.6M subscribers, r/AskReddit has 9M.
The biggest challenge of a leader is aligning interests. Many of those "citizens" are not aligned with the board, and are not even aligned with each other. It's no wonder that they keep burning through CEOs. Yishan may have been more aligned with the Reddit userbase (although even then, a good portion of the site hated him) and clashed with the board, while Ellen tried to please the board and ended up pissing off the whole userbase.
* She was CEO at a time when Alexis Ohanian terminated Victoria Taylor. But Ohanian was the chairman of the company, Pao's immediate superior. And the circumstances of Pao's accession to CEO didn't leave much time for the company to sort the problems of an operational chairman out: Pao was brought in as interim CEO at the same time as Ohanian was installed.
* She was a principal in a high-profile gender discrimination law suit against a giant venture capital firm where she previously worked. One wonders what this had to do with her tenure at Reddit, but it leads off the popular petition for her ouster.
* She presided directly over the termination of David Croach, who had leukemia. Croach claims he was terminated because he was unable to perform his job as community manager, and that he was unable because he was required to work from San Francisco --- a policy created by Yishan Wong. Reddit, through a spokesperson, disputed the veracity of Croach's story. We don't know why he was fired, but it seems like we do know that he was not --- as Pao's critics are very, very fond of saying --- simply fired "for having leukemia".
* She is married to Buddy Fletcher, who presided over a failed hedge fund and is accused of impropriety. This too is prominently recorded in the petition for her ouster, and, like her lawsuit, has little to do with her operational role. She is also accused of having deleted posts critical of her and her husband, but admins at Reddit later clarified that she not done that --- which makes sense, since we're talking about someone who couldn't even figure out how to send a private message on Reddit.
* She presided over a policy that banned the FPH subreddit. Reddit "free speech" advocates are very fond of suggesting that Pao was cracking down on objectionable speech at Reddit, and doing so selectively, so that white power subreddits were left to stand while FPH was banned. Of course, this leaves out the fact that FPH was banned for harassment, not for hosting hate speech.
What am I missing?
I don't know that any of these summaries are dispositive. Maybe the FPH issue is more complicated than I realize. Maybe Croach's termination really was mis-handled (if he was fired simply for having leukemia, he has a very straightforward legal case against Reddit).
I only ask that we do not accept uncritically the notion that Pao placated the board at the expense of Reddit's community.
Your answer to this question might relate to the "popular" perception of the leader of reddit in the past ~year, whether honestly and solely earned by them or not.
To me, the most important moderation goal for HN is ensuring that members remain collegial and capable of discussion, even though we wildly different backgrounds and experiences.
"Hot" controversies --- Reddit is one, most political stories also --- can harm that goal. People get nasty in them. If dropping hot stories off the front page reduces nastiness, I am all for it.
Reddit is not HN. I have no idea how Reddit should be moderated. I try to minimize my participation on Reddit, because it's not moderated in a way that I find compatible with how I want to interact with people. That doesn't make Reddit evil, just, not for me.
(I am a semi-avid consumer of the "good" stuff on Reddit, though).
For very many habitual users of Reddit, the way in which it is probably most valuable is as the canonical general discussion forum of the web. An important part of the infrastructure of their perception and interpretation of the world around them, for pretty much any domain beyond the most incommunicably personal.
To read Reddit can be, in a surprisingly real way, like participating in a collective consciousness -- with all the addictive dependence [I say that in a non-judgemental way, not being able to come up with a less negative way to characterize it at the moment] that the type of speculative fiction which imagines such living arrangements usually predicts.
The practical side of this is that, for any given news event, cultural phenomenon, popularly-circulating idea, whatever: for these users it is instinctive to consult the reddit threads on the topic, as a deeply-ingrained part of their process for digesting and interpreting it. That those reddit threads will exist and have an active discussion on any given topic is a given. Even if the local source of a news piece has a forum/thread of its own, it is fundamentally not the same thing.
It's been, in a hazy golden age that may have never actually existed, something close a total function for processing the events of the world, big and small.
One day, there was an event, a dumb internet drama event, but one for which the primary Reddit discussion thread was displaying a count of 20 thousand comments -- but on inspection, every single last one of those was showing up as [deleted]. That was the start of it for most users. Many have fixated on the specific topic of that initial drama as the source of the problem with Reddit, and many others have fixated on this fixation as the source of the problem with Reddit.
But there is a general sense that this is growing, spreading, and mutating, and seems to be cropping up in places that are not strictly predictable.
For example, there are persistent rumours that several of the more popular subreddits for which the news would be directly and explicitly on-topic, are systematically removing discussions about various global trade agreements currently being negotiated. Is it true? Maybe, maybe not, but the trust is broken.
----
The main thing is (the perception that):
Now there is a partial function where before there was a total function. That is disastrous damage in an information processing system.
----
To these users, this is a very profound and frightening piece of damage, having extended a part of their cognition into this machinery that now seems to be failing. Panic sets in, which obviously means wild flailing at anything that pops its head up and can be in any way seen as responsible for the damage.
Hence, the reaction to Ellen Pao. Especially after she made public statements of purpose that were easily interpretable by these users to the effect of "whatever else might be the source of the damage to your extended cognition, we intent to start deliberately doing some more damage to areas we don't consider important".
In the end, I very strongly suspect that the problem is much deeper and probably well beyond any control of the central management. If there were a way to, I would put money down on the prediction that the Reddit crisis, a direct continuation of the exact same crisis that's currently associated with Ellen Pao, will continue.
To the users I'm talking about, the "cognitive value" of Reddit is not entirely about directly being fed opinions to take up as one's own.
Many of these users find great value to being exposed to, they deliberately seek out for their own enrichment: idiocy, malice, counterfactuals, cognitive dissonance, debate (honest and otherwise), the whole range of perceptions and opinions.
To them, being exposed to these things is just as much of the value of Reddit as the "good stuff". And that seems to be the aspect of Reddit most strongly and immediately under threat.
Anyone who does not value this kind of experience (which seems to be a very large proportion of the people participating in this conversation at the most visible levels) is going to see any attempt to frame this type of content as valuable in any way as totally incomprehensible, evil, and malicious itself. So this part of things is pretty close to an impossible conversation to have in public.
Same applies to "political" issues, like antigay CTOs, or nearly every gender related thread. It'd be great if there was a way to get high quality discussion, I'll settle for just burying the crap. Even if it's fun and ostensibly relevant.
In an online community - just as in a real-life community - you can always tell who is actually invested in the community and who is using it for their own purposes. Take a look at the reception that Starfighter got on HN vs. the one that a random promotional post on the New page [1] gets. A lot of this is because you and Patrick have both invested in HN - you post about things other than ones directly related to your business.
Yishan made a lot of unpopular decisions when he was CEO at Reddit as well, but the community outrage was blunted because he was, to some extent, seen as "one of us" and the tone he took when communicating with Reddit was "Yeah, Reddit is a business, I have to make some unpopular decisions, but I care about the site just like you, and I've been a Redditor for years." The mistakes Pao made aren't all that different, but she's given very little latitude for them because the Reddit community views her as an interloper, a corporate CEO brought in who doesn't really understand the product.
It'll be interesting to see how Steve & Alexis do now that they're back at the helm. They have immense cultural capital by virtue of being the founders, and so far I think they've managed it well with their public comments. But the Reddit userbase (suspicious as always) is going to be watching them to see "Is Reddit being managed for my benefit? Or is it managed for the benefit of shareholders, and I'm just a product being bought and sold?"
By being a woman and thinking Reddit might do better without the sort of people who would be booted from 4chan.
There's also the "no salary negotiation" thing, which is either offensive to women, men, or workers depending on the argument.
It doesn't seem fair that Alexis isn't getting as much flak. It'd be cool, for the popcorn value, if reddit starts a backlash against him.
Edit: And wow, a lot of reddit users really take themselves seriously and think reddit's really Changing The World. So the CEO's more like a political position, where you get judged on irrelevant-to-the-position criteria.
The Reddit userbase was very much under the impression that it was Pao's decision to terminate Taylor, not Alexis'. Pao was acting CEO, ordinarily that would be a CEO's decision, not the board's, and Alexis never really took responsibility for the termination except for one vague comment which most people took to mean that Alexis was responsible for the termination after all.
The timing of the termination was unfortunate, because it followed immediately after an AMA with Jesse Jackson in which some of the comments Taylor would have forwarded to him were pretty inflammatory. Initial suspicion on most of the site was that Pao terminated Taylor because of that AMA, which fit nicely into the narrative of Pao that much of the userbase had been building.
> She was a principal in a high-profile gender discrimination law suit against a giant venture capital firm where she previously worked. One wonders what this had to do with her tenure at Reddit...
Reddit has two different very vocal groups on it that have slightly overlapping opinions: the MRAs and the anti-SJWs (whatever they call themselves, I dunno). Both groups see any attempt to make a gender discrimination or racial discrimination claim as worthy of ridicule.
According to their story -- and this was stated outright in a lot of high-score comments before the Taylor termination, as the KP lawsuit was unfolding -- Pao is an untalented woman who was using her gender as a weapon against an innocent business in retaliation for being fired, while also attempting to rescue the financial disaster that her husband-in-convenience-only was facing. (Their words, not mine.)
So, to them, they see their worst nightmare helming one of the few sites online where they can all congregate semi-freely.
> She presided directly over the termination of David Croach, who had leukemia. ... he was not --- as Pao's critics are very, very fond of saying --- simply fired "for having leukemia".
Right, but "he was fired for reasons we don't understand and we should all get on with our day or maybe find some other cause to be upset about" doesn't play nearly as well as "Feminist SJW fired an employee because he had leukemia".
Reddit is not exactly a pillar of intellectual discourse.
> She is also accused of having deleted posts critical of her and her husband...
Context matters: this is all happening around the same time as the tail-end of things like "Gamergate" and the whole Hugo Awards mess thing. In that context, the Reddit mass would easily imagine Pao as some kind of SJW version of Rupert Murdoch, where she wouldn't have to understand the workings of the site to make her desires known to the people who could remove content she didn't approve of.
> She presided over a policy that banned the FPH subreddit. ... FPH was banned for harassment, not for hosting hate speech.
Several people pointed that out at the time, but they were mostly drowned out by the outrage. This was the lynchpin that really made the Pao-is-a-social-justice-warrior narrative work.
And -- and I'm a little sick to my stomach for taking this position -- FPH wasn't the only sub that was banned, and there were other subs on the site that were guilty of harassment of some form or another (an oft-mentioned one is SRS), and some of the other banned subs didn't seem to be guilty of harassment.
Setting down anything resembling a sane and consistent policy on what is and isn't allowed behavior on Reddit has been one of its weaknesses for years now. Every time Reddit doesn't communicate clearly enough with its userbase to make sure all the gaps are filled in, the userbase responds by coming up with about the worst possible story that could feasibly fit what they think they're seeing.
There was also the sudden termination of the employee behind the redditgifts site and the huge secret Santa program (/u/kickme444), who, like Victoria Taylor, is seen as one of the few good parts of Reddit, and, like Taylor, can't talk about why they were suddenly terminated. In fact, nobody even knew it had happened until /u/kickme444 mentioned it in one of the Victoria Taylor outrage threads.
--
So I think you're missing a little of the nuance and context for a few things, but most of all you seem to be expecting Reddit's most vocal users to make some kind of sense.
And they don't.
Reddit's user base is awful. They have been allowed to be awful for years, and they're getting worse, not better. There are some parts of Reddit that are really great, but those tend to be the parts that are mercilessly moderated.
The Reddit administration initially took a really hands-off approach to managing its user base, and now it's stuck with a mass of users that represent some of the worst parts of internet culture, all mingling and mixing genes with eachother. And the administration is now trying to figure out what to do about it, and they are just miserably ham-handed at it. They won't commit to making and enforcing clear guidelines that kick out the worst of their users, but every once in a while they find some reason to whack a bunch of them. That just pisses everyone off and creates situations that lead to things like Pao hatred. (And it was hatred.)
They keep trying to find some middleground between a 4chan-style free-for-all and being some kind of hub for kindness and intellectual discourse while hosting the biggest gathering place for internet scum, and it just blows up in their face, over and over and over again.
The fault for that certainly doesn't lie entirely at Pao's feet, I just think she had no idea how to handle a site like Reddit.
Reddit is overwhelmingly 4chan graduates, full of men who perceived themselves to be victimised by women who are trying to assert their humanity.
2. It speaks to her character. She has an affair with a married coworker and the sues for a very specific amount (see point 4)
3. According to posts by Croach, Pao agreed to let him keep his job and then rescinded the next day. we may never know the truth on this.
4. "Failed hedge fund" is one way to put it, lol. The guy is accused of running a ponzi that steals from firefighters pensions. He apparently owes a bunch of money for legal fees and the Pao lawsuit conveniently requested this amount (this might be a coincidence). However, the bans are well documented facts (http://www.reddit.com/r/announcements/comments/35uyil/transp...). Of all the comments in the thread, only the Pao\Fletcher ones received bans. If pao didnt personally click the "shadowban" button, it seems pretty clear she ordered them.
5. They may have technically been banned for "harassment" but the messaging was clear from Pao herself: "Our goal is to enable as many people as possible to have authentic conversations and share ideas and content on an open platform". It seems reddit users really hates "MBA speak" about "authentic conversations" when someone on the site is censoring authentic conversations about subjects the admins dont agree with (see point 4)
I mean, he went on reddit and had an argument with a former employee after that no remote work fiasco.