When I ask why people are leaving their current position, I am actually very curious to hear the answer and it colors my impression quite a bit.
When I ask why people are leaving their current position, I am actually very curious to hear the answer and it colors my impression quite a bit.
Stupid as it may sound, even in this market, most hiring managers run screening as a systematic search for disqualifiers.
The most important thing to remember here is not my opinion on the validity of the question or the reasons any hiring manager gives you for how important the data is to them. The important thing to remember is this: most candidates don't have interesting reasons for leaving their previous jobs.
No matter what any hiring manager tells you about their preferences, the reality is that giving a boring answer really can't disqualify you. Nobody runs hiring processes that select only for people with interesting last job quit stories; they'd reject almost every candidate! But an "interesting" answer certainly can disqualify you.
Candidates should simply dodge this question. The more I've thought about this thread, the more cut-and-dried my judgement on this is.
Edit: There's also the fact that interviewing is a two way screening process, and anyone that thinks is capable of taking offence at homophobia is a "no hire" red flag could and should fail the OP's own personal screening process (assuming they're not working in a country or period of history where few firms aren't actively dismissive towards the concept of homosexuality). Sure, over-elaborating on how bad the place was to work (any competent interviewer won't press for details) is a red flag, as is appearing to be more desperate to leave than interested in the job on offer. But "they're an excellent company in many respects, but I feel I'd be much happier in an environment where I didn't feel I was constantly having to turn a blind eye to several coworkers' derogatory remarks about minorities" doesn't sound like it should alarm anyone the OP might actually want to work for
It's just not true that a boring answer to this question is a "massive red flag". That's terrible advice to give.
The OP - who understandably hasn't provided many details - may be in a situation where a bland answer doesn't sound like an obvious lie, but it's evident from the way the question is phrased that they fear it might be.
Even if they'd in fact been there for 15 months at a run-of-the-mill Series A startup so a bland answer was pretty likely to be the truth, would you have been more likely to have screened them out if they'd answered "I'd prefer a working environment where people weren't constantly making homophobic comments"?
I'm unfortunately not in SV and the tech community is much smaller here. The startups founders are fairly well connected with other founders and I don't want it to become a they said/they said that gets me black listed.
On the other side, I wonder if the HR process of slotting candidates into fixed number of positions don't help. It might make sense for factory workers, but for programming or even IT? This is one reason BTW why I believe anti-discrimination laws are ineffective.