Ask HN: Dealing with spam from competition. | Hacker News Reader

Ask HN: Dealing with spam from competition.

1 pointadamzochowski2 comments

I help a friend manage a gaming forum.

Recently we have been spammed (private messages to users and forums themselves). All calling to switch to another forum. How does one deal with these, besides putting caps on messages per minute or catchpas?

My friend wants to do retaliation - to spam the other forum. He feels double-wronged since that other forum already is bigger.

So far I have cleaned up our forum, and told him not to message anyone.

However, what is the proper etiquette for this? How does one handle this cleanly?

As far as I see, this all could have been instigated by a third party. On the other hand, I do not know admins of the other forum, and they could be playing dirty. I have no way of knowing.

So what is best way to deal with this?

Thank you

Adam Piotr Żochowski

You definitely do not want to succumb and retaliate. There is no end game there, except that users leave both forums as they are spammy and unusable. There, all you've succeeded in doing is killing off two forums.

First, contact the admins and establish communication. Explain what happened, and ask if they would mind changing their ToS or put a notice on their board, asking their members to stop. From this round you can figure out if the admins did it, or if their users did it.

If it was the users, then you should probably look to technological solutions like CAPTCHA, user bans, IP bans, etc. Maybe require that someone be a member for X months, or have N minimum karma before they can PM someone else. Start filtering for certain content (URLs, names of other forums, etc.)

If it was the admins, you should plan on doing the same stuff, but you're probably going to be up against some more savvy folks. Start watching your logs seriously, and step up the tech filters. You can do things like flag suspect accounts, and filter messages to / from those accounts (if you do it silently, the other site admin won't realize his spammy techniques are ineffective).

Step 1: open lines of communication Step 3: profit!

Thank you.

I will tell my friend to try communication with the other admins.

Kind regards

Adam Żochowski

Reply on news.ycombinator.com