Rent vs. Buy: If You Have to Ask, You Should Probably Rent
mrmoneymustache.com
mrmoneymustache.com
I appreciate the frugal advice offered in these posts, but they feel incomplete without the inclusion of tax implications into the discussion.
(Disclaimer: I am not an accountant, seek professional advice.)
This calculator the NYT made is pretty good.
Another strong point for "buy": If your horizon is indeed 30 years then house is truely yours at the end of the loan. Most people would be planning to retire after 30 years and not having to have rent expense during this period is a huge deal. You can even move out to much less expensive area and use the difference to maintain your life style. Also note that rents almost always go up over long duration. If inflation happened to kick in high gear when you retire, you will be toast because your rent would skyrocket while you are living on a fixed income.
The decision for rent vs buy is therefore very simple: If you think you are going to be living in given area for 18-30 years of time range, buy is no brainer provided that (1) your retirement savings remains same (2) you still have "rainy day" funds (3) there is reasonable income security and (4) you have recovery plan if natural disaster stricks. So those people doing long commute are not all fools and "drive until you can buy" is in fact the best strategy for them. There are some people arguing that you should buy even if you had time range as short as 5 years but then you will need to time the market and that's where most failures occur causing people to lose their life savings. Unfortunately lots of people are in this state and frankly it sucks to be in that state. You pay huge premium to be mobile and you don't know if you will ever use that mobility.
[1] http://www.dce.harvard.edu/professional/blog/how-use-real-es...
[2] http://www.estateofmindsites.com/subscriber_new/map.php?user...
"The lesson? If you live in an area where houses cost more than $300,000, take a close look at the rent prices around the areas you currently drive. Budget your driving costs at at least a dollar per mile (80 cents/km in Canada to account for higher costs) because you absolutely must put a high value on your spare time to get ahead in life. Doing the math on life decisions like this was by far the biggest factor in my own early financial independence.
Buying a house is a great thing to do when you’re settling down in a beautiful, affordable spot right near everything you need to do for the next ten years. And if your schedule and temperament allow some time for a good several hours a week of maintenance work. But for the rest of us, it’s worth having another look at Rent vs. Buy."
Which seems to be good advice.