This is such bullshit. I had a prepaid phone for a few months, because my previous one was broken, and the new iPhone was going to be out in a few months. So I moved to Verizon prepaid: $40/mo, 2GB data, no taxes/fees/nickles/dimes. It worked great. Best part is: I paid VZ $150 for a used iPhone 4s; and traded it in for $200 credit for a new iPhone. When the new iPhone came out, I switched to it and a postpaid plan. And I have stellar credit.
The point is: just giving up a prepaid phone by itself means nothing. GIGO.