Philae lander finds complex organic molecules like acetone on comet
cbc.ca
cbc.ca
http://blogs.esa.int/rosetta/2015/07/30/science-on-the-surfa...
Which is not to detract from the magnificence of the accomplishment, simply to note that this isn't from Philae's recent reawakening.
http://www.planetary.org/blogs/guest-blogs/2015/0722-what-in...
(And shame on you, silly ESA, for allowing your publicly-funded science to be locked away by a third party).
There's some fascinating, very suggestive CNOH compounds in that list. Here's what the last paragraph says about them:
CH2OHCHO [glycolaldehyde] is an efficient initiator in the prebiotic formation
of sugars (21). HCN [hydrogen cyanide] is a key molecule in the prebiotic
synthesis of amino acids (21, 22) and nucleobases (21) and even offers an
elegant pathway to sugars (23). HCONH2 [formamide] provides a prebiotic route to
nucleobases (24). HCONH2 (24) and CH3CONH2 [acetamide] (21) catalyze
phosphorylation of nucleosides to nucleotides, in which amines also play a role
(21). Isocyanates play a major role in the prebiotic synthesis of peptides,
through the so-called isocyanate route (22). The complexity of cometary nucleus
chemistry and the importance of N-containing organics imply that early solar
system chemistry fosters the formation of prebiotic material in noticeable
concentrations.Boy am I confused.
1. http://phys.org/news/2006-04-astronomers-alcohol-cloud-spann...
What were the "complex organic molecules" that were observed.
All the COSAC organics can be formed by UV irradiation and/or radiolysis of ices
due to the incidence of galactic and solar cosmic rays: alcohols and carbonyls
derived from CO and H2O ices (19), and amines and nitriles from CH4 and NH3 ices
(20). Hydrolysis of nitriles produces amides, which are linked to isocyanates by
isomerization.
"Organic" only means "made of C,H,O,N", and doesn't imply biology. (But these are actually pre-biotic chemicals, which is why it's very interesting).I'm pretty sure "organic" has an entirely different meaning to most of the population, and it's not helping anyone...
In fact, organic food is known in some other countries as "from biological agriculture" (often abbreviated to "bio food").
It's how language change works though. Very few words still mean what they meant several hundred (or even tens of) years ago. The people who write dictionaries are perfectly pragmatic about this. What is the aim of journalism on a mainstream news website? To communicate? If you want to communicate with someone who doesn't have a science background, a member of the public, you have to be sensible about it.
So what's the alternative to "organic" in that context? "Carbon-containing"? The latter is far less misleading to the average person. And to people who understand both, either works. So why wouldn't you want to do that?
It's pure stubbornness on behalf of scientists (and I say that as a professional scientist myself) to be prescriptivist about this sort of thing. And, again, I'm not suggesting we stop using the word in technical contexts (the classroom, textbooks, journals, etc.). It's just that I've been at a few outreach events recently, and I talk to people casually a lot, and so many people read "organic" in a headline and think "signs of life" that it's obscene. It's a real problem. We can either choose to try and communicate better, or we can carry on misleading people–because we are misleading them, whether we like it or not. Burying our heads in the sand and just pretending otherwise doesn't help anyone.