99% of consumers would be happy if there were only 10,000 employed musicians in the entire market.
Imagine you write a song. I take that song and I turn it in to a bunch of holes punched in a big long reel of paper. Now I put that reel in to a specially designed piano that will read the sequence of holes and use it to trigger notes. Now I sell that roll of punched holes. Do I need to give you any money?
Imagine you write a song. I take that song and I record it on to thin plastic disc. I sell these plastic discs. Do I need to give you any money?
Imagine you write a song. Someone else records it and I play that recording over a radio broadcast. I sell spots in the broadcast to advertisers and make a profit. Do I need to give you any money?
Imagine you write a song. Someone else records it and puts that song on a website I run. I sell spots on the website to advertisers and make a profit. Do I need to give you any money?
Imagine you write a song. Someone else records it and uploads it to their own website. They don't have ads. However, I have a website that indexes every other website on the Internet. I sell ads around the content that is returned in these search results, including your song. Do I need to give you any money?
This has nothing to do with supply and demand. It has everything to do with people like me making money off of things that people like you made and if that is or isn't how we expect a lawful and just society to work.
Your entire comment is completely nonsensical and frankly insulting. Being a musician was an unprofitable pursuit long before digitalization.
I made you the "songwriter character" in order to try and get you to empathize with their position.
As for the examples, the first three scenarios are based on the actual history of intellectual property as it pertains to music in the United States.
The invention of player pianos led to the foundation of what is known as "mechanical royalties" in the music industry. That is, you can't say that you're just selling a roll of paper with holes in it and that you have the rights to all the profits, rather you have to license that song from the rights-holders.
While my rhetorical approach might not have been the best choice, the points I'm making are not at all nonsensical and were not intended to be insulting.
This comment breaks the HN guidelines, which say:
When disagreeing, please reply to the argument instead of calling names. E.g. "That is idiotic; 1 + 1 is 2, not 3" can be shortened to "1 + 1 is 2, not 3."
Similarly, this comment could be shortened (and considerably improved) by deleting the above sentence.
(This is not a criticism. I'm just reflecting.)
Secondarily, I'm just reiterating how much more helpful it is to the musician to take the extra effort to buy from them directly. The penalty in ones convenience is greatly outweighed by the benefit to the indie/DIY artist.
Being a musician has never been a very good career path.
Why should I buy music from you at a much higher price than paying Spotify $10/m? I have no ethical obligation to ensure that you can make a living off your music, especially considering that I'm pretty ambivalent about whether you make music at all.
The flip side of the coin is that it's pretty annoying to see every musician think of themselves as some sort of unique snowflake, when their music is 95% identical to everything else in the genre.
I know that writing, recording and marketing songs is difficult, but just because something is difficult doesn't mean it is worth a lot.
It's not just about the artists. There's a huge support industry of recording engineers, studio owners, mix engineers, producers, tour managers, festivals, session musicians, electronic designers, software developers, web developers, app developers, and old-style physical instrument makers - among others.
Global music revenue alone is around $15bn. When you include all the support services, that number gets a lot bigger.
So supply/demand is not a very insightful way to look at this. With more investment in better content at every level, there's huge potential for revenue growth.
Nickel and diming the artists kills that for a short term hit of profit that isn't sustainable.
How so? Fundamentally: why do you think we need more music or more professional musicians?
10,000 was chosen as an arbitrary number. I actually suspect the demand for professional musicians is far lower than that.
The fundamental fact is that there are way more people who want to be a musician than people who are willing to pay for random music from indie artists.
This isn't a supply and demand problem. If you could steal at the supermarket and know you'd never get caught or there would be 0 consequences you'd do that. The supply would still be limited.
Piracy is the problem, period. If everybody pirates your awesome and unique commercial software will you still be talking about supply and demand even if your software is the unique on the market? Oh sorry, there are millions of software out there ... supply and demand. Too much supply therefore I should not buy your software but pirate it... /s