HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

0134340

348 karma · joined May 31, 2016

submissionscomments
0134340··on The brilliance of All Gas No Brakes
>When men choose not to believe in God, they do not thereafter believe in nothing, they then become capable of believing in anything.”

That quote is deceptive though and and it's sometimes used, as in your case, to push religious propaganda. For every secular view you'll likely find a theistic view with many commonalities. Theism doesn't stop people from justifying or believing in many of the things agnostics do because out of thousands of denominations of thousands of theistic religions of thousands of gods and thousands of years, theistic belief is just as varied as non-theistic belief. And often they're just as vague and meaningless while virtue-signalling as something more meaningful and sometimes the love they espouse is something committed only for that tribe or out of fear of gods rather secular motives which may often be for the tribe but not because they feel they have to. Sorry if I seem course but I'm tired of this meaningless 'life has no meaning without belief in gods' trope pervade my favorite forum for which I'd rather view tech news and not be denigrated for not having found any believable gods yet. Nihilism isn't defined by lack of belief in gods.

0134340··on The brilliance of All Gas No Brakes
>fill the void left by the lack of traditional societal structures that people used to find meaning in life

Or maybe they're finding meaning in the void that traditional structures couldn't fill.

0134340··on Instagram faces $500B in fines alleging it harvested biometric data
Autonomous cars do so when you're in a public space. And by pixels, you could make that same reductive argument when violating anyone's private space via digital or physical, that it's only pixels, bits, molecules, etc. Don't forget laws and ethics work on scales.
0134340··on Entropy explained, with sheep (2016)
>symmetry of time

Time isn't symmetric.

"Since the second law of thermodynamics states that entropy increases as time flows toward the future, in general, the macroscopic universe does not show symmetry under time reversal." - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/T-symmetry

0134340··on Entropy explained, with sheep (2016)
Dorion Sagan (Yes, Carl Sagan's son) also covers this in his book Into The Cool. That life is only a force multiplier in increasing it universally, basically.
0134340··on Entropy explained, with sheep (2016)
>"Everything just always was"

Or it wasn't and came into existence with a 'big bang'. So how did it come into existence? There's no scientific or religious answer for it. You'll still be skirting the question with the old 'who made the gods' problem. I know what you're getting at and trying to conflate science with religion. Spoilers here: Scientists don't know these answers and just because we don't know doesn't mean the thousands of denominations of thousands of gods of thousands of religions of thousands of years has a true answer either.

>we are supposed to be satisfied

No one said you should be satisfied by it. That's what's good about science, you're expected to not be satisfied and to survey and question, it's not infallible nor claim omniscience.

>God manipulates the minds of top scientists so that they do not definitively prove his existence, which would ruin the point of his simulation. Each time they get close, he finds an idiosyncratic way to make them forget about it or dismiss the idea.

And of course it's the gods, or all created thereof, who are behind helping or hurting belief in gods. Ask a god believer and it's always god's plan.

0134340··on Entropy explained, with sheep (2016)
>then there must have been a time where it went from zero to non-zero.

Take a step towards the door. On the next step, take half that step. Keep taking half the step as before and you'll never get to the door. Perhaps the multi/universe is so infinite that there's no end or beginning as we know it. You can fill in the blank with deities, anthropomorphic or what have you, but that's where science ends and religion begins.

0134340··on UK officially in recession for first time in 11 years
Recessions aren't "normal times". Despite externalities, whether economic abnormalities, pandemics and so on, it still hits the savings account the same and worth comparing for history's sake.
0134340··on Google speakers are listening to more than just voice commands
Ah, google and their hapless hardware updates accidentally spying on users, killing my friend's and others Nexus phones as well as my own Nexus Player (oops!). No more Google hardware for me.
0134340··on Neanderthal gene linked to increased pain sensitivity
That immediately came to my mind also. Apparently it's due to a variation of the MC1R gene which according to what I've read here, fourth paragraph [0], both developed independently of one another. Fascinating.

0) https://humanorigins.si.edu/evidence/genetics/ancient-dna-an...

Also it's not necessarily the reception of pain itself that's different, as someone else said, but the perception or anticipation of it [1] that changes the degree of anesthetization required.

1) https://www.verywellhealth.com/do-redheads-really-need-more-...

0134340··on Google offers refunds after smart glasses stop working
This also happened with many people's Nexus Players, a Roku/Firestick competitor, myself included. It's co-developed by both Google and Asus. Of course after the update bricked them Google tried to blame Asus and put it on their shoulders to provide a fix and Asus seemed to do the same. Needless to say, I won't buy Google products anymore.
0134340··on An even worse anti-encryption bill than EARN IT
>For that time in history, it could be argued that the decision made sense. Japanese subs did shell the US mainland, and Japanese-Americans in Hawaii did help a Japanese aircrew try to escape after Pearl Harbor. Japan planned to return to Hawaii after Midway to occupy Hawaii.

It could also be argued that it made sense to do the same for Germans since we had a minority of Germans siding with Hitler and even holding Nazi rallies before we got involved in WWII. We weren't exactly good arbiters of fairness when it came to race either.

0134340··on Justice Department to propose limiting internet firms’ Section 230 protections
You may not legally be held liable though in many cases you can. It's a common trope within law and I'd guess derived from common sense that if you host illegal content then you are therefore bound to scrutiny for potentially enabling it. So by extension, if you care about being a free person, you are responsible for it. Anything illegal in my home and I'm bound to scrutiny and law. Why should big co's get a free pass? To me, I couldn't care less either way but consistency in law would be just lovely.
0134340··on Justice Department to propose limiting internet firms’ Section 230 protections
Someone correct me if wrong but I think phone co's can get away with it as they're deemed an information carrier instead of a host. Besides, calls and texts are rather benign, it's visual media that tends to attract the most calls for censorship, not to also mention that real-time censorship of text and voice would be infeasible but much more viable for an information/media host.
0134340··on Justice Department to propose limiting internet firms’ Section 230 protections
Really, even though the platform you're using voluntarily chooses what you're allowed to post, as with almost all online platforms?

Besides that, you're framing this wrong. If I host a platform as I host you in my house, I have a right and a duty to make sure you aren't committing illegal actions within my domain. This is a fairly universal law, written and unwritten, that who and what you host in your domain is your responsibility. Why should a few privileged platforms get a free pass?

0134340··on U.S. Economy Shrinks at 4.8% Pace, Signaling Start of Recession
Bernie isn't trying to solve a problem, more correct it. Why fault the people for trying to correct a problem that's more to their advantage when hospitals, to this day, still haven't tried to correct the problem of expenses. One shouldn't have to forego their home to pay for small surgical procedures. When people try to correct these things we get replies like yours saying you shouldn't correct them but leave them to the system to correct them. We have to realize the "system" won't inherently do these things, we the people as part of the system have to take measures to look out for ourselves also because the system won't do it for us.
0134340··on Entropy and Life
>does this not put a pretty big nail into reductionist scientific worldviews

It's just generalized enough to be vaguely descriptive, not prescriptive, at least not yet. And I don't think it ever will because just as we have biologists, we still need medical professionals that can diagnose and understand more specifically the bottom layers.

Second question, someone mentioned Into The Cool, a book I'd like to also read that seems to take on this question.

Third question... to evoke the previous answer, why not both?

0134340··on Entropy and Life
I don't disagree with the proclamation here but can't say I agree with the result. The economy is tied to productivity and without productivity we're doomed to be stuck on an earth that will eventually stop existing, no matter how long we try to keep it habitable. I don't know what the best answer is but I don't think it should be to decrease productivity, at least not in the STEM sector.
0134340··on Entropy and Life
That sounds similar to what I arrived to when I became somewhat obsessed with the topic yet admittedly lacking much knowledge about it. Lookup hormesis (basically life needing some amount of chaos to keep it strong) or 10th man rule, there's some interesting correlates that I wrote about here [0]. It's all pretty interesting but being stubborn as I am, it took me a while to realize I'm better off leaving it to smarter people more versed in those topics. I eagerly await some very intelligent person who doesn't mind risking being seen as a quack to try to marry thermodynamic principles with human behavior and the like, even though it's more descriptive than prescriptive and may not tell us as much as we'd like to know. It also may be kind of existentially defeating to some as it'd necessarily prescribe deterministic views to life but some say quantum mechanics still leaves some philosophical wiggle-room for us there.

0: https://0134340.blogspot.com/2019/02/playing-tenth-man.html

0134340··on John Conway – The Free Will Lectures (2009) [video]
Probably no more dangerous than free will beliefs because as with some determinist beliefs, it's moderated by thinking life is dictated by a greater order, see Calvinism or the many determinsts who aren't "dangerous" as well as those of us who think deterministic belief leads us to more nuanced and moderate views on societal events, that something begets something begets something, ad infinitum which can lead to better prevention and help mechanisms. I'm certainly not a danger other than to cheesecake or endangered anymore than anyone else who believes the will is free of physical influence and that at its core it's random, or a god or something fueling the RNG or whatever.
0134340··on John Conway – The Free Will Lectures (2009) [video]
I agree with most of your reply but imposing a contentious philosophy upon others wouldn't go well nor would I want to condone it. I'm not very determined to believe in determinism but I do and it doesn't change my views on punishment very much as I'm still determined to have a sense of self and societal protection in that I'd prefer "bad" people kept from society until reformed although I am less judgemental as a result from thinking about it more over the years.
0134340··on In slime molds, evolution selects 'loners' who refrain from collective behavior
Speaking as someone who used to worry about people so much, even those large degrees from my circle, that I'd drag myself down to very depressive episodes, I can see how some amount of psychopathy would be selected evolutionarily. Besides that, any work where you're dealing with people in pain such as a soldier, police, medics, etc, it's not often beneficial to be squeamish to others' pain, especially as a medical professional since the pain (negativity) you induce will often have positive effects. Perhaps psychopathy is just an extremely selective form of this.
0134340··on A song that was constructed to reduce anxiety
Sigur Ros is like magic. Bon Iver almost has that same effect. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8T0cHQb39GY
0134340··on A song that was constructed to reduce anxiety
I get that music can be calming but also agree, I've had the issue before and I've heard it called 'relaxation anxiety' or something. Like a baby trying to fight their sleep, when things feel too calm it can be unnerving and the body wants to fight it.
0134340··on In slime molds, evolution selects 'loners' who refrain from collective behavior
>So even though Neandertals had a more advanced brain

I'm aware that it's accepted Neandertals might've been as capable in many areas of survival, however I'm not aware that it's been accepted they had more advanced brains. Got a source?

I remember hearing somewhere, one source I remember [1], that despite their intelligence, they tended to rove in smaller tribes partly perhaps due to less inter-communication skills, which may've led to a disadvantage in warfare.

Or perhaps, my own thoughts, the 'loner genes', for lack of a better term, iterated more throughout the Neaderthal ancestry which led to smaller tribes. Another guess, maybe forested Eurasia, which may act as natural barriers compared to more open African plains caused a selection for smaller groups or gave way to human genetics that naturally selected for smaller groups. Of course, take it all with a grain of salt.

1. https://www.history.com/news/neanderthals-likely-lived-in-sm...

0134340··on In slime molds, evolution selects 'loners' who refrain from collective behavior
>Unlike computers, cells like to do their own thing

As an ex-repair tech, I can't applaud this comment.

0134340··on Farewell
>Posting information about someone

One of the biggest problems is that anyone can make up the same username anywhere online and use it in false flag attempts to harm someone's reputation and the dramaqueens at Kiwifarm don't care as long as it's "verified" by their very ambiguous standards, something which has happened there before many times.

>to stir up drama

Ironic since the whole product they're selling there is drama and invoking it not only on their own boards but elsewhere.

0134340··on New process for preserving lumber could offer advantages over pressure treating
One advantage they don't discuss is perhaps lack of toxicity. I used to do Carpentry during summer break and sometimes we'd burn scraps for heat. I was advised not to throw treated lumber into the pile as it's toxic so this would be a good step in the right direction towards less toxins introduced into homes and groundwater.
0134340··on Richard P. Feynman on the Distinction Between Past and Future
Which was created by work and the by-product of that work is more entropy if not locally but elsewhere in the system. The laws of thermodynamics yield for no one. At least not yet.
0134340··on Tradition Is Smarter (2018)
True, quality over quantity, investing more in few is a valid evolutionary advantage, both short and long. OP should've used the term "evolutionarily advantageous on the short term in some conditions" instead of "massive evolutionary advantage" if correctness is valued.
← PreviousPage 7 of 8Next →