HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

01Michael10

1,189 karma · joined July 20, 2010

submissionscomments
01Michael10··on Quadrooter: New Vulnerabilities Affecting Over 900M Android Devices [pdf]
It's 2016 so you know and that is still NOT true...
01Michael10··on Quadrooter: New Vulnerabilities Affecting Over 900M Android Devices [pdf]
I agree the EU should require phone OEMs to update their damn phones. My argument is Google shouldn't and can't do that...
01Michael10··on Quadrooter: New Vulnerabilities Affecting Over 900M Android Devices [pdf]
Yes, Google adds closed source bits just like any other OEM does and the only difference is Google updates their sit better but we blame them.

My point is AOSP being open source means any OEM could base an OS on it and be fully open sourced.

I understand there is barriers to doing that like most mobile hardware is not open but that is NOT Google's fault.

01Michael10··on Quadrooter: New Vulnerabilities Affecting Over 900M Android Devices [pdf]
>I actually can't produce this document. Google's contracts with OEMs are strictly confidential.

Thanks man... I hear they also keep martians at Roswell.

>Google gets to approve or veto every Android device every OEM sells.

100% Wrong... The only thing an OEM really needs to do is include certain Google apps and have them presented in a certain way to use Play services.

01Michael10··on Quadrooter: New Vulnerabilities Affecting Over 900M Android Devices [pdf]
>Define 'most phones' (Not being able to replace the battery is a problem in my world).

In my world too but most smartphones sold these days in fact do not have removable batteries by design. You don't know this?

>Buying a new (crappy, what do you expect for 50 Dollars?) phone because your perfectly working one isn't supported anymore is NOT satisfying and not a solution

That $50 phone is just as good or better than a phone sold 3 or 4 years ago.

>I feel that you're a bit lost. You want to save a bit of money

No dude... I buy a new phone every two years to have a faster one, better features (camera), and better security features (fingerprint reader). Lucky me, I can afford it. My secondary phone is a 2 1/2 year old Nexus 5 which still gets security updates and will for many more years via custom ROMs. Security updates were not the reason I bought a new phone.

Sorry, you don't really seem to be up on current smartphone technology to comment on this intelligently but philosophically I do agree with you.

01Michael10··on Quadrooter: New Vulnerabilities Affecting Over 900M Android Devices [pdf]
>With replacement of consumable parts (mostly batteries...

What? Most phones sold today do NOT have replaceable batteries.

>For some people, particularly the elderly, the young, and the poor, they'll use it until it literally stops working at all because they literally cannot afford otherwise.

One can get a new Android phone from Amazon for $50 no contract. Landlines still exist and are almost available anywhere unlike cell coverage.

>Cell phones are a literal lifeline device...

I could live with a dumb phone as my PC is way more important. When are we going to make Microsoft start to provide security updates to XP again?

You must be like 20 years old... I hate to break it to you but no one needs a cell phone to survive.

>This is why the security updates either must be performed by the companies in question through the actual use lifetime of the device...

Well start writing Congress but personally I don't want my new phone to be another $50 more because the OEM is required to provide security updates for phones 5 or more years old.

01Michael10··on Quadrooter: New Vulnerabilities Affecting Over 900M Android Devices [pdf]
The platform is NOT sold. AOSP is open source... What OEMs do with it is up to them.

I suppose you can produce this document?

Common sense would dictate if Google could make OEMS provide updates they would already be doing that. Right?

01Michael10··on Quadrooter: New Vulnerabilities Affecting Over 900M Android Devices [pdf]
That don't have leverage... Google is already facing fines from the EU because of what they currently require from OEMs to use the Play Services. Trying to make OEMs accept Google updates is not in the cards.
01Michael10··on Quadrooter: New Vulnerabilities Affecting Over 900M Android Devices [pdf]
No! They absolutely can not! OS updates do not come via Play services... Why can't people understand that Android is open source? An Android OEM can (and does) modify their Android distribution anyway they like UNLIKE a Windows phone OEM. The fact is any OS update directly from Google would probably brick an OEM phone not that Google can unilaterally decide to update someone else's phone anyway.

Samsung bails, Google and Android is screwed...

01Michael10··on Quadrooter: New Vulnerabilities Affecting Over 900M Android Devices [pdf]
I should have said up to three years but you are even more incorrect --> https://android.googleblog.com/2015/08/an-update-to-nexus-de...
01Michael10··on Quadrooter: New Vulnerabilities Affecting Over 900M Android Devices [pdf]
Android OEMs love it when people keep blaming Google for phones not being updated and as long as this happens this issue will never be addressed.

Do you know how open source works? Google has no control over OEM phones or the carrier approval process. Period!

The only reason OEM Windows phones can be upgraded is that OEMs agree to that level of control by Microsoft. Have you ever noticed their are few Windows phone OEMs? LOL Google could try to assert this kind of control on OEMs but Samsung would bail as soon as possible for sure. They would fork AOSP or move to their own OS.

01Michael10··on Quadrooter: New Vulnerabilities Affecting Over 900M Android Devices [pdf]
Who supplies security updates for the "lifetime" of their product in your fantasy world? Three years is a good amount of time for security updates but could be extended to four years since people are keeping their phones longer these days.

You are comparing software security updates to products recalled for safety issues? Well phones are already subject to recalls for hardware/battery problems. Let me know when a phone kills or hurts someone due to lack of security updates.

01Michael10··on Quadrooter: New Vulnerabilities Affecting Over 900M Android Devices [pdf]
Don't you mean Android phone OEMs and carriers?

Google already updates their phones every month for three years which is long enough for a device most people replace or break within two years. Verizon isn't the only carrier of course.

01Michael10··on Nexus phones now identify suspected spam callers
What other people? People I actually know? I would know it's them (contact list/caller ID). It would still probably go to VM as I am not usually just sitting around waiting to answer a phone call. I will just call them back when it is convenient for me.
01Michael10··on Nexus phones now identify suspected spam callers
My phone never rings...
01Michael10··on Nexus phones now identify suspected spam callers
Huh? 99% of telemarketers don't leave a VM.
01Michael10··on Nexus phones now identify suspected spam callers
Why?
01Michael10··on Nexus phones now identify suspected spam callers
What? Why would anyone answer an unrecognized number? I have no problem hanging up on a telemarketer but why let it even get that far?

It's NOT ignoring your friends if you don't pick up the phone every time they call. Regardless, my friends numbers are in my contact list. Crazy huh?

01Michael10··on Vulkan Tutorial
> I would scratch the fully, it's not on iOS or macOS

Vulkan is mostly certainly cross-platform and it's only Apple stopping it from being available on their closed platform.

01Michael10··on Hacked: Private Messages From Dating Site ‘Muslim Match’
Who has a value system where it's OK to lie and cheat on a person you entered into vows with? Regardless, it's not relevant what yours or my values are anyway on this. It's the person who is being cheated on that matters who obliviously doesn't have the same value system as the cheater so the behavior can only be seen as 'bad".
01Michael10··on Firefox 48 Beta, Release, and E10S
I read your comments just fine but you weren't making sense but now you explained it. 200 tabs in 12 windows? Yeah, nobody cares your browser is crashing now. You can switch to Chrome and maybe it won't crash as much but it will use more memory.

Personally, I would reevaluate how you use browser.

01Michael10··on Firefox 48 Beta, Release, and E10S
It doesn't sound like you are doing anything much different than me except I don't use Facebook. I normally keep my browser open for weeks at a time and never break 2GB unless hit some crap website. Addons?
01Michael10··on Firefox 48 Beta, Release, and E10S
Memory issues? I have have never had any memory issues with Firefox and it's been almost crash free now for the last six releases.

It's 2016 now so maybe it's time to upgrade your box and it's 4 GB of RAM.

EDIT: How is Firefox eating up to 3Gb of RAM on your machine? I never seen mine go over 1.5GB and that's been after a week of not closing it (64-bit version/no Flash installed).

01Michael10··on Firefox 47 Release Notes
I dunno, maybe they like their users to be able to play content on the web? People NOT being able to do that on Firefox would just speed up the conversations to Chrome. You know you can turn any CDM module off right?
01Michael10··on Firefox 48 Beta, Release, and E10S
What? You were going to switch browsers because you were having problems using a beta or nightly version? I have an idea... Use the release version!
01Michael10··on Jolla C, a new Sailfish OS phone from Jolla
> What I could not stand on Android is the constant display of ads, just everywhere, in every app.

Huh? I have used Android phones for over 5 years and almost never see ads.

Yes, some free apps have ads but you just need to spend a dollar or two to remove them. Developers don't work for free you know. An app doesn't give you that option? Uninstall it. I have two exceptions to that rule because the apps in question are great and the ads are non-intrusive.

01Michael10··on Eric Raymond's 'The Cathedral and the Bazaar' Turns 19
Link?
01Michael10··on Google.com partially dangerous
No, are you trolling? I was hardly the only one on this post who didn't get ads for that search. You are the first person to mention the mobile version of any browser so I did the same search with Chrome on Android using DDG and... Gee, the Google Chrome website is still the first result. The only time I got an ad was with the Canadian version of Bing. Note, I am using the DDG website NOT the app or extension.
01Michael10··on Google.com partially dangerous
I get the same results... Wow! I would stop using Bing Canada.
01Michael10··on Google.com partially dangerous
My bad... You still have some issue.
← PreviousPage 2 of 11Next →