HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

0xDEAFBEAD

3,098 karma · joined November 17, 2021

Please consider what you can do to help stop omnicidal AI: https://pauseai.info/

Some HN users like to "flag" comments which are compliant with the HN rules, on the basis that the comment in question goes against their ideology. You can turn on "showdead" in your profile to see flagged comments. (I recommend doing this.) If a rule-abiding comment has been flagged, you can click the comment permalink to "vouch" for the comment and vote against the flag. For reference, the comment rules are here: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

You can try to contact me if you want, by emailing my username on protonmail, but I probably won't see it. Sorry.

submissionscomments
0xDEAFBEAD··on Updated Google Maps shows destruction of the city of Rafah
>US supporting Iraqs invasion of Iran

More distortions on your part. (I notice you said nothing about the hospital point.) The US supported Iraq when Iran's counterattack was going too well, to prevent Iraq from being conquered by Iran, a regime you yourself say "should not be in power".

>Saddam was a dictator supported by the US when it was convenient for them, like they've done many times before.

I don't think this is intrinsically bad. The US also supported Stalin during WW2. Our rapprochement with China helped lift millions out of poverty. Were those mistakes?

>But I also know why they are in power and it is yet again because of US direct meddling in the region as them helping with the coup in 53 and installing a western aligned leader lead directly to the religious fanatics taking power as that regime had suppressed all other viable options with the support of the US to keep power.

This is some serious mental gymnastics to blame the US for a rebellion motivated in part by anti-Americanism. By your own logic, maybe the US is actually in the wrong for not giving the Shah even more support in order to crush the rebels.

If anti-Americanism caused a rebellion that you acknowledge as destructive, why do you lend support to anti-Americanism as an ideology?

You've created a catch-22 where the US can be the bad guy even if it supports a leader that's better than the plausible alternative for the country in question. What if the USSR had turned Iran into another satellite like in Eastern Europe? Ask the Poles how they feel about life under the Soviets.

I think these questions are simply not as obvious as you're making them out to be.

>The US is a lot more than a distinctively bad actor

We haven't initiated a war of conquest since the late 1800s. Even being a superpower after WW2, our territory actually shrunk when we gave the Philippines their independence "for free".

How many historic great powers can you name which were so restrained when it comes to territorial conquest? Considering the great powers during WW2: Nazi Germany, Imperial Japan, British Empire, French Empire, Italian Empire, USSR, PRC, USA. Who among those is the angel that you would've liked to see crowned global leader?

The world has generally become a much better place while the US has been hegemonic:

https://thumb.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/0/06/The...

0xDEAFBEAD··on Pacing the Frontier is not the actual goal for AI labs
>the agents haven't seen the ceiling as far as improvements can go.

Interesting! Agents are the presumed bottleneck for recursive self-improvement.

>Scare tactics are the old salesman pitch

People keep implying this, but I've never seen a concrete past example of a product that was sold by scaring customers about it.

"The equities here could not be more one-sided. Defendants admit that they provide a service without fully knowing how it works. This is not just any service. It is one that Defendants themselves concede poses an existential risk to the continued survival of humankind. Defendants claim they cannot stop barreling forward with their potentially civilization-ending endeavors unless they are forced to do so by the government. They have asked the government to tie them to the mast. Plaintiff brings good news to the Defendants: The Florida Attorney General is answering your cry for help with a motion to enjoin you from harming Floridians with your reckless, unacceptably risky product."

Source: https://www.myfloridalegal.com/sites/default/files/plaintiff...

I legitimately don't think there has ever been anything like this. You suppose this is just a ploy to strengthen their IPO??

>catapulted Open AI to the moon essentially

I see you doing serious mental gymnastics here. Consider the possibility that people invest because their numbers are good, and their numbers are good because their product is useful?? I mean, that is Occam's Razor.

>I do not see any evidence that models are going rogue, or that agents are going rogue.

Here's the evidence: https://www.dwarkesh.com/p/openai-huggingface

And no, just because it could've been prevented with the benefit of hindsight does not make it any less of an instance of "going rogue". In my tiger analogy, that would be like saying that the cub is not aggressive because it could've been held with a stronger leash: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49859564

0xDEAFBEAD··on Updated Google Maps shows destruction of the city of Rafah
I didn't claim that Iraq's invasion of Iran was justified.

But I notice that you don't seem upset with the idea that Iran would retaliate against Iraq when Iraq invades Iran (including direct attacks on civilian targets, not just dual-use infrastructure!), yet you do see upset that the US would retaliate against Iraq when Iraq invades Kuwait. That seems like the sort of double standard I was talking about.

I deleted my comment because I thought it would be fairly tedious to litigate this. I agree the US has done some dubious things, but I don't think they are a distinctively bad actor relative to other players in the region. I'm also not sure you are telling the truth, e.g. I haven't been able to find a source for your claim that the US targeted hospitals during the Gulf War.

0xDEAFBEAD··on Updated Google Maps shows destruction of the city of Rafah
>The country is completely broken.

"Iraqis celebrate their comeback with soccer tournament after decades of isolation"

https://www.cnn.com/2023/01/09/football/iraq-gulf-cup-comeba...

That was 2023: Iraq hosted the 25th Arabian Gulf Cup, and won the tournament.

I think if you're going to claim that something bad happened to Iraq post-2023, attributing that to the 2003 US invasion is a little dubious. Iraq was also in bad shape before the US invaded! It's a mistake to assume that if any foreign power has had any level of involvement, every bad thing that subsequently happens is therefore the fault of the foreign power.

https://i.imgflip.com/a6ptj6.jpg

>The fact that the dip is so small for both is more a reflection of the dataset. I mean, Gaza is all but completely destroyed, how can the HDI be that high?

Another possibility is that viral news stories are not always a good way to get a representative picture of how life has changed for civilians on the ground.

>Israel is committing a genocide and we are their partners in crime.

If Israel had genocidal intent -- in the sense of attempting extermination of Palestine's civilian population -- what fraction of Palestine's civilian population would you expect to be dead by now?

Once you've got that fraction in your head, try prompting your favorite LLM with something like the following:

"Please estimate the fraction of Iraq's population which died due to the 2003 US invasion, and the fraction of Gaza's population which died due to the 2023 Israeli invasion. Please provide an estimated breakdown of deaths based on whether they were due to invader military activity, destruction of civilian infrastructure, internal conflict, or other causes."

(you won't be able to paste the reply here due to HN rules against AI-generated content)

Another interesting prompt template: "Give me a sense of how civilian deaths happened in [Iraq/Gaza] due to [US/Israeli] military activity. Tell me a few representative vignettes which show various typical ways in which this occurred."

0xDEAFBEAD··on Updated Google Maps shows destruction of the city of Rafah
Here's a line graph of the HDI of Iraq and Palestine:

https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/human-development-index?t...

For Iraq, you can see a small dip for the 2003 invasion, which quickly recovers and in subsequent years grows above its pre-invasion value. Far from being "destroyed", Iraq is now doing better than ever.

For Palestine, the dip is about 3x larger.

0xDEAFBEAD··on Updated Google Maps shows destruction of the city of Rafah
Would you have preferred that the US stay out of WW2 to avoid killing any civilians? Sure, the Nazis took over, but at least our hands are clean!
0xDEAFBEAD··on Japan moves to tighten rules for foreigners
Alright, so add on ethnic cleansing too?

I guess you must be pretty happy about illegal Israeli settlements in the West Bank? Immigrants causing existing residents to leave, right? Woohoo!

0xDEAFBEAD··on Pacing the Frontier is not the actual goal for AI labs
Suppose I've got an urn full of colored balls. I shake it up and draw 5 balls from the urn. All 5 balls are blue. I predict that the next ball will also be blue. It would be silly to counter my prediction on the grounds that this is an "association fallacy".

As with colored balls, so with predictions that AI has "hit a wall".

Why were the previous Zitron predictions wrong? Why do you believe your prediction will be right? You've done nothing to differentiate your prediction from the many historical failed predictions along similar lines. They're all "balls from the same urn".

The point about costs is a non sequitur. Revenue alone is proof that people are getting plenty of use out of these models, even if they aren't profitable to serve (doubtful).

0xDEAFBEAD··on Pacing the Frontier is not the actual goal for AI labs
>I wouldn't call it "half-baked" when it's a well known playbook regularly leveraged by large companies.

Really? Give me some examples.

Alex Tabarrok says: "classic regulatory capture takes time, it’s a process of erosion rather than a battle, it happens in the shadows, in the backrooms, away from the public’s eye." https://marginalrevolution.com/marginalrevolution/2026/09/wh...

AI is receiving intense public scrutiny, suggesting that "classic regulatory capture" is quite unlikely.

>Companies won't spend the money and time to lobby to use different models and Anthropic knows it.

They already are! See the "Little Tech" lobby.

0xDEAFBEAD··on Pacing the Frontier is not the actual goal for AI labs
>EA cult members do not take this very real, measurable, non-speculative danger seriously.

That's not exactly true.

"Climate change matters so much, to so many, not just because of the suffering and injustice it’s already causing, but also because it’s one of the few issues that has obvious potential to affect our world over many future generations. We think safeguarding future generations is a key moral priority, and should be a crucial consideration in prioritising problems on which to work.

...

...climate change will be hugely destructive. We’ll see floods, famines, fires, and droughts — and the world’s poorest people will be affected the most.

...

...climate change’s impacts will still be significant – it could destabilise society, destroy ecosystems, put millions into poverty, and worsen other existential threats such as engineered pandemics, risks from AI, or nuclear war. If you want to make climate change the focus of your career, we include some thoughts below on the most effective ways to help tackle it.

...people are right to be angry that too little is being done.

...

Working on this issue seems to be among the best ways of improving the long-term future we know of..."

https://80000hours.org/problem-profiles/climate-change/

A big part of the reason EA doesn't focus more on climate change as a "highest priority area" is simply that many people are already focused on it, and it is therefore not an especially "neglected" area.

0xDEAFBEAD··on Pacing the Frontier is not the actual goal for AI labs
There are many people who have some sort of half-baked "regulatory capture" theory. I find these theories kind of implausible. No US regulation will meaningfully stop open-weight Chinese models. At best you'll get legal restrictions for particular US industries which are especially risk-aware. The CEOs of those industries will counter-lobby to be able to use whatever model they want. Public opinion will most likely come down on the side of removing restrictions. Since there's plenty of public attention on this issue, achieving meaningful regulatory capture will be difficult.
0xDEAFBEAD··on Pacing the Frontier is not the actual goal for AI labs
This is the type of Ed Zitron prediction which keeps being wrong: https://danluu.com/zitron/

Anthropic's revenue is up 50% in the past two months. They're not hitting a wall.

0xDEAFBEAD··on OpenAI bots meddled with multiple US Government agency sites
>Any real work in this field is being done not by the people saying 'stop'.

Not exactly, that Evan Hubinger guy from Anthropic famously said his p(doom) is over 10%

See the signatories:

https://aistatement.com/work/statement-on-ai-extinction-risk

https://www.pacingthefrontier.com/

I'm amplifying their calls to reduce the rate of progress

0xDEAFBEAD··on Japan moves to tighten rules for foreigners
So from a conservative's perspective, you're basically a dictator facilitating an invasion.

This is how you fuel the far-right.

0xDEAFBEAD··on OpenAI bots meddled with multiple US Government agency sites
"I'm gonna put my head in the sand and there is nothing you can do to stop me."
0xDEAFBEAD··on OpenAI bots meddled with multiple US Government agency sites
If it's different sometimes it makes sense to have a different term.
0xDEAFBEAD··on Japan moves to tighten rules for foreigners
Why shouldn't we let Europe do the world policing for a while? They're always complaining about whatever we do.
0xDEAFBEAD··on Japan moves to tighten rules for foreigners
The US is now the world's top oil exporter thanks to fracking:

https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/fossil-fuels?fuel=oil&met...

0xDEAFBEAD··on I'm the mom in that viral Giants clip. Let me tell you about my husband
This type of content is mostly on reddit, which leans heavily leftist. They censor right-wing views aggressively.
0xDEAFBEAD··on I'm the mom in that viral Giants clip. Let me tell you about my husband
Reddit is kind of a cult. "Ditch your loved ones so you can spend more time on reddit telling people to ditch their loved ones."
0xDEAFBEAD··on OpenAI bots meddled with multiple US Government agency sites
The question was: "What label do you prefer for the agent that did something it was not asked to do?"
0xDEAFBEAD··on Japan moves to tighten rules for foreigners
OK, so considering Sweden, if Sweden is flooded with immigrants, where should the Swedes who just want to live with other Swedes go? Australia??

Also you do realize that your preferred migration policy will lead to microaggressions (and possibly macroaggressions) against immigrants? If people don't have democratic means to keep out disliked foreigners, they may be tempted to try alternatives. The ballot box is ultimately an alternative to violence.

0xDEAFBEAD··on OpenAI bots meddled with multiple US Government agency sites
You could make similar statements about user interface design. That doesn't prevent it from being a legitimate and useful field of study.
0xDEAFBEAD··on Japan moves to tighten rules for foreigners
The US economy did great prior to 1900 or so. During this period, we did not have significant military action outside of the Americas, and we avoided peacetime alliances. From 1820-1900 the US economy exploded from about 40% the size of the UK economy to about 200% the size of the UK economy.

https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/gdp-maddison-project-data...

Switzerland has a per capita GDP exceeding the US while pursuing isolationist foreign policy. They are the world's most popular country in opinion polls.

0xDEAFBEAD··on Japan moves to tighten rules for foreigners
I'm not sure people should be forced to live with those they feel xenophobia towards, even if one grants that the feelings of xenophobia have no basis in reality.
0xDEAFBEAD··on ASML says it sold 'absolutely nothing' in Europe in 2026
Could help put a stop to the AI nonsense for a while, at least.
0xDEAFBEAD··on OpenAI bots meddled with multiple US Government agency sites
>if you cant punish the creation for what it does it leaves only the one who started the process

Agreed, but I think we can do more on the prevention side as well. Traditional liability law is for negligence in case of preventable disasters. Since we currently have no way to prevent AI disasters in principle (alignment problem remains unsolved), I think we should just stop developing the technology for now: https://pauseai.info/

0xDEAFBEAD··on OpenAI bots meddled with multiple US Government agency sites
"AI has gotten cheaper more quickly than any other transformative technology in history. The cost of achieving a given level of AI performance has fallen about 47% per quarter since 2023, or 13× per year. That price drop is four times faster than DNA sequencing, six times faster than compute, 18 times faster than lithium batteries, and (in the century up to 1973) 54 times faster than electricity."

https://epoch.ai/publications/the-plunging-price-of-thought

0xDEAFBEAD··on OpenAI bots meddled with multiple US Government agency sites
Most unreliable computer programs won't launch research programs consisting of thousands of pages of text to find creative ways around obstacles.
0xDEAFBEAD··on OpenAI bots meddled with multiple US Government agency sites
This type of whack-a-mole approach is akin to "fixing a bug" by hardcoding a special code path for known-buggy inputs. It doesn't address the root problem of AI misalignment, and doesn't allow you to prevent catastrophes in advance, only patch things up after the fact.

This might be helpful reading: https://www.lesswrong.com/w/nearest-unblocked-strategy

As AI systems get smarter, we may reach a point where we have to get it right on the first try or face truly catastrophic consequences: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7wy3xyoXYt8

← PreviousPage 5 of 34Next →