628 karma · joined February 2, 2020
I guess this is similar: how do you make trustworthy decisions that seem to inherently depend on the network, in the absence of a network? Before the internet, we had phonebooks instead of DNS, and we had cash instead of cards. Did the phonebook have every number? No. Was every piece of cash not counterfeit? No. But it's "good enough". Portable reference sources and tokens. The references are issued periodically and the tokens have evidence of exhaustion, their decay over time. A dog-eared dollar with a bunch of phone numbers on it, half-torn ... the merchant doesn't have to accept it.
How do you do these things digitally? Periodic issue seems pretty straightforward ... if you have a network. Token issuance, similarly, needs at least occasional communication with other nodes in the network.
So there's a local dwell capability.
Is this part of the same reaction we saw with Denmark starting to have emergency stores within 50 km of every Dane? Is this motivated by a need to prepare for war?
As an example, as you're reading it, try posing a few relevant counterfactuals.
consolation
(1) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_the_United_Sta...
https://www.cs.utexas.edu/~eunsol/courses/data/bitter_lesson...
Given the long list of dead philosophers of mind, if you have a trivial proof, would you mind providing a link?
Correct me if I'm wrong, but I've read (I believe on this very forum though I can't find the link, but also see 1, 2, and 3) that the European universities are often closely aligned with local industries. A challenge here in the US: outside Silicon Valley, what are the manufacturing industries in the US cities with universities? What are the major industries in Kansas City? Are those companies funding research at UMKC? What are the major industries in Dallas? Are those companies funding research at Southwestern?
Ronny Chieng actually breaks down the larger problem quite nicely: https://www.youtube.com/shorts/i1Hi_hacvN4
So now we do in fact have an incredible university system supported in part by a mess of underskilled labor in fly-over states that dropped out of college after saddling themselves with significant educational debt.
Wildly, the one industry that is a major economic driver in most cities is healthcare, which is a pretty dead-end industry in terms of economic output, that is, outside of certain world-reknowned institutions like the Mayo Clinic, healthcare doesn't really generate a significant exportable commodity.
(1) https://education.ec.europa.eu/education-levels/higher-educa...
(2) https://www.jstor.org/stable/24118541
(3) https://sciencebusiness.net/news/universities/deepening-coll...
Can you even even tell what network stack got you this packet?
How about the protocols that got it from the network to your screen?
How about the quantum mechanics of the phosphors that pushed out the photons?
There are certainly techno-luddites/visionaries who are running their own email servers, but it's a pretty hostile environment for personal email servers. Ignoring the spam, just getting the existing big boys to trust you can be humiliating exercise in futility.
Can I get by without Excel? Sure. Google Sheets? Sure. No spreadsheet at all? Gonna be hard.
In medicine, I see the LLMs as a pretty good net outcome. For war, I see this as potentially catastrophic. We need more Stanislav Petrovs, fewer Charles Forbins and his Colossus.
A number of the docs I'm working with describe using ambient dictation as a game changer. Using the OODA loop analogy of the author: they are tightening the full OODA loop by deferring documentation to the end of the day. Historically this was a disaster because they'd forget the first patient by the end of the day. Now, the first patient's automatically dictated note is perhaps wrong but rich with details the spark sufficient remembrance.
Of course MBAs will use this to further crush physicians with additional workload, but for a time, it may help.