HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

11thEarlOfMar

9,936 karma · joined October 18, 2013

Waiting for the brass ring to come around again.
submissionscomments
11thEarlOfMar··on Our nation cannot censor its way back to cultural health
Please explain why that is true.
11thEarlOfMar··on Opinion: Remember reading the paper?
There was always a political divide.

What’s new is Americans killing each other over it.

The polarization is extreme in part because news sources now need clicks to survive, and Outrage gets more clicks than reason.

End result is some Americans become so outraged they loot and burn cities and in some cases, kill. And seemingly, their peer pole finds the mayhem understandable.

That’s what’s new.

11thEarlOfMar··on The new hire who showed up is not the same person we interviewed
Seems pretty hard to successfully pull this off. The better your chances of being successful, the more likely you could have gotten the offer on your own. If you needed the stand in to get the offer, you're not likely going to be qualified and won't last.

Perhaps it could be successful for people who are technically competent, but have a severe stage fright when interviewing. At the lease, you'd want the stand in to record the interviews so you could watch and learn who's who and get the context of the job before starting.

11thEarlOfMar··on Boyfriend-alert – A light based alert system
My mom used a referee's whistle. There were 5 of us and the number of toots indicated which of the 5 she wanted (two toots for me). If we were outside playing in the neighborhood, we'd get alerted directly or indirectly from someone who was tired of hearing the whistle.

If it was dinner time and she needed us all, she'd blow 'Shave-and-a-haircut-two-bits'.

11thEarlOfMar··on Chip shortages due to lack of investment in right fabs
There are a several factors that conspire to make the shortage worse:

- These legacy chips fabbed at legacy nodes are made with legacy equipment. In many cases, that equipment is a) fully depreciated and b) no longer available. Yes, most chips can be made with new equipment, but the profits with a new tool set are not going to justify the expense. You wouldn't buy a new $8 million CVD tool to make a 180 nm microcontroller that might sell for $2.

- Many chips are fabbed at 1 place only. The chip company owns the IP and has a defacto monopoly on the features of that chip, or even class of chips. If that fab is shut down, no more are being produced and customers have to buy up what brokers can scrounge. The more warehouses get picked out, the higher the prices go. In one extreme example, a chip made at Infineon's Kulim fab in Malaysia, that sold for $0.47, was purchased for $100 @ by (ironically) a chip equipment company.

- Hoarding has made the issue far worse. Companies are instructing buyers to order more than 1 year ahead, and seeing lead times exceed 1 year as well. The more these lead times extend, the farther into the future buyers extend their horizon and lead times just keep rolling.

- It may actually be the case that organic demand growth is not the main problem. More likely, it was the successful (and therefore vulnerable) just-in-time supply chain that collapsed as soon as COVID interrupted the choreographed flow of material.

11thEarlOfMar··on Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspection After 3 Years
No, but I'd like to. Which do you suggest?
11thEarlOfMar··on Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspection After 3 Years
It's always an 'on balance' determination vis a vie what owners care about.

Yes, not everything fits right in my 2018 Model 3. The right headlight is not flush with the hood. You can hear that the windows aren't secured when rolled down and you close the door.

Everything else is brilliant. 95k miles in, I've had zero drive train or mechanical issues. Three sets of tires and an underbody shield that tore when I hit 6" of standing water at 70mph. Conversely, the punch when you hit the accelerator is exhilarating, takes curves flat and fast, the sound system is excellent, it's so quiet, I can drive for hours without physical discomfort, the seat material is durable and doesn't scuff or fade.

I drove a 328i for 20 years that I loved dearly. I haven't given it a 2nd thought since buying the Tesla.

11thEarlOfMar··on Over 10% of Tesla Model S EVs Fail Germany’s Strict Inspection After 3 Years
You're dismissive of an exceptional auto quality technologist.
11thEarlOfMar··on Ask HN: FOMO by working in startups only vs. Big companies
I have a corollary question.

If you're a hiring manager in a large company, what are the pros and cons you see about hiring engineers who have only worked in startups?

Vice versa, if you're a hiring manager in a startup, what are the cons and pros you see about hiring engineers who have only worked in Fortune 500 companies?

11thEarlOfMar··on Results from Semiconductor Supply Chain Request for Information
There are a several factors that conspire to make the shortage worse:

- These legacy chips fabbed at legacy nodes are made with legacy equipment. In many cases, that equipment is a) fully depreciated and b) no longer available. Yes, most chips can be made with new equipment, but the profits with a new tool set are not going to justify the expense. You wouldn't buy a new $8 million CVD tool to make a 180 nm microcontroller that might sell for $2.

- Many chips are fabbed at 1 place only. The chip company owns the IP and has a defacto monopoly on the features of that chip, or even class of chips. If that fab is shut down, no more are being produced and customers have to buy up what brokers can scrounge. The more warehouses get picked out, the higher the prices go. In one extreme example, a chip made at Infineon's Kulim fab in Malaysia, that sold for $0.47, was purchased for $100 @ by (ironically) a chip equipment company.

- Hoarding has made the issue far worse. Companies are instructing buyers to order more than 1 year ahead, and seeing lead times exceed 1 year as well. The more these lead times extend, the farther into the future buyers extend their horizon and lead times just keep rolling.

- It may actually be the case that organic demand growth is not the main problem. More likely, it was the successful (and therefore vulnerable) just-in-time supply chain that collapsed as soon as COVID interrupted the choreographed flow of material.

11thEarlOfMar··on Intel's $20B Ohio factory could become world's largest chip plant
Bigger than these 5 monstrosities?

http://shorturl.at/yHLW2

11thEarlOfMar··on Basic income would not reduce people’s willingness to work
If there were basic income, the payments would be incremental to the salary. The worker, though unhappy, could upgrade other elements of their life.

Perhaps jobs are scarce and this worker really has no place to go and must endure the abuse. Once BI is introduced, what percent of workers would quit and stop working, vs. quit but find new employment using the BI to bridge expenses in the meantime and be able to make a full time effort of the search?

BI should make employees more mobile and employers with unpleasant work will need to pay more to get those positions filled.

11thEarlOfMar··on Tesla Model 3 Owner Discovers Car Was Delivered Missing a Brake Pad
Hyper growth yields hyper growing pains.
11thEarlOfMar··on New theory proposes ‘forgetting’ is a form of learning
I frequently find myself contributing to conversations with knowledge that I don't recall specifically learning. Once in a while, I think "Wow, how did I come up with something that insightful? When did I ever learn that?"

It seems there's a background activity in the mind that is actually synthesizing a wide variety of inputs from our environment. As in what I read, movies I watch, meetings I sit in on, Tweets that transpire, hikes I take, visits to distant cities, and so on. In many cases, it seems the connections and support for ideas, notions and realizations that then become knowledge are made without explicitly reasoning through them.

I'd say this happens most frequently in conversations related to my work, which makes sense since that's where most of the inputs are sourced.

11thEarlOfMar··on The Righteousness Fix
The big challenge: How to get 2 opposing, self-righteous groups to a place they can talk and learn the fallacies each holds of the other.
11thEarlOfMar··on YC’s $500k Standard Deal
From YC's perspective, it's protection against dilution at the 2nd round.

Also shows additional confidence in selecting a winning cohort.

11thEarlOfMar··on Toyota to remanufacture cars up to three times in UK
My read is that Toyota is trying to find a way to continue to make money from sales but without strictly producing new cars. Overall, if this program is not extending the useful life of their products, it's not a gain for the environment.

Toyotas have positive resale value up to an average of 210,000 [0]. After that point the cost of maintaining them is (theoretically) greater than the resale value.

It seems they are targeting a refresh about every 3 years, and doing that 2 times. The lifetime would then come in at about 10 years, which is right in the ballpark of 200,000 miles.

[0] https://www.forbes.com/sites/jimhenry/2014/05/31/toyota-lead...

11thEarlOfMar··on What the world will be like in a hundred years (1922)
If you're curious about the writer, W. L. George, he was hired by the Herald to write a daily column in the Women's Page:

https://www.newspapers.com/clip/24655109/new-york-herald/

11thEarlOfMar··on Ask HN: Why is there a chip shortage?
Here's an interesting anecdote: Tesla cars have traction control that monitors the differential in rotation speed among the four tires. If you put new tires on the rear and leave worn tires on the front, the rotation differential between the inside rear and outside front on a tight curve is enough to fool the traction control into thinking the worn front tire is slipping and will pulse the brakes on that wheel only. It's pretty unnerving.

Put new tires on the front and the problem is solved.

11thEarlOfMar··on Ask HN: Why is there a chip shortage?
The $0.50 for $75 is a short term situation that will resolve once the fab's pipelines get filled again. We buy >1,000,000 per year and had no trouble getting them until the fab shut down. We'll be fine soon (looks like they've opened production again).

The primary costs of starting up a fab are 1. facilities, 2. equipment. Facility per square foot is likely the most expensive you'll find due to the appurtenant systems required for air flow and purity, a variety of gas handling systems, ridiculous electrical power systems, possibly gas plant systems, water purification and then treatment systems for both air and fluids exiting the plant. Some truly scary toxins are used and produced and have to be contained or captured and neutralized.

In terms of equipment, you'll need at least one of each of 40 types. Lowest cost is about $500,000. Highest is likely $25,000,000 (at the geometry you're talking about). Average in the area of $3,000,000 - $5,000,000. You'll need a cadre of engineers and scientists to keep it all running, and 2-3 years from breaking ground to producing product. If you did buy one of each tool type, you'd have most of them sitting around doing nothing most of the time, since the process times vary dramatically. In reality, you're looking at $500,000,000 minimum to build a fab that can produce $0.47 chips. Seriously, you don't want to do that.

11thEarlOfMar··on Ask HN: Why is there a chip shortage?
State of the art fabs retail for US$10 Billion. TSMC, Samsung, Intel & China can afford to build them.

(for context, Freedom Tower cost US$2 Billion.)

11thEarlOfMar··on Ask HN: Why is there a chip shortage?
EVs require 2.3x the chips of ICE. (not orders of magnitude, apologies for the hyperbole)

https://www.idtechex.com/en/research-article/ev-power-electr...

11thEarlOfMar··on Ask HN: Why is there a chip shortage?
State of the art machines are used to make state of the art high-value chips. FPGAs, GPUs, CPUs, RAM, SRAM

As those chips run through their life-cycle, their value drops. After 15 years, the price the chips can sell for will drop 90% or more.

If there is a spike in demand at that point, there is no ROI on purchasing brand new equipment.

The demand spike is seen as temporary. Hence, the chip makers are telling the buyers to design out the old chips and upgrade to new. Many companies can do this. But some are constrained by industry regulation (aerospace) or industry practice (semiconductors).

I've mentioned before the irony that companies that make semiconductor equipment are struggling to ship more tools because they can't get enough (of certain chips) to complete building them.

11thEarlOfMar··on Ask HN: Why is there a chip shortage?
This is correct. Shortages of new generation chips can generally be resolved by new capacity. We are seeing record levels of capacity spend by the chip companies.

However, older chips are difficult to increase capacity for. The tools are not available, and the profit from legacy chips from them is many times insufficient to make the business case for.

11thEarlOfMar··on Ask HN: Why is there a chip shortage?
Several factors:

1. There was real and relatively sudden increase in demand:

a. COVID-driven in part, all students and many additional employees had to buy computers to study/work from home,

b. a., driven by video, lead to increased demand on Internet & telecom infrastructure.

c. Electric vehicles consume an order of magnitude more chips than ICE cars. EV demand is also skyrocketing.

2. There were fabs (semiconductor factories) shut down due to COVID. This one in Malaysia [0] makes power chips and was particularly problematic for ICE auto makers.

3. The first indication of problems manifested in chip lead times pushing out. As buyers started to see more and more of this, they started increasing orders and soon adopted a hoarding mentality, similar to why many of us couldn't find toilet paper in stores early in the pandemic.

Result: As a personal anecdote, a chip that sells for $0.47 from that fab in Malaysia recently sold for $75 on the broker market.

Note that no, the state of the art fabs cannot be re-outfitted to make legacy chips. The old equipment they were developed on is generally no longer available and the profit from making those inexpensive chips would not justify the capital spend on new equipment.

[0] https://www.reuters.com/article/infineon-results-malaysia/in...

11thEarlOfMar··on 2021 Letter
The word that caught my attention was demise. It doesn’t square if you believe that the US is seeing record employment and record stock market returns, as more than 50% of US households have stock-based investments.

I was asking, and still hoping to see, the metrics and data that point to demise of the US middle class.

11thEarlOfMar··on Tesla Q4 2021 Vehicle Production and Deliveries
Oh, Right. I’ve used up three sets of tires.

BTW, the car came with 310 mile range. Tesla upgraded that to 325 after about a year.

Now, range is 290.

11thEarlOfMar··on Tesla Q4 2021 Vehicle Production and Deliveries
You'll understand the Bull case if you calculate the revenue growth rates of Tesla vs. incumbents.
11thEarlOfMar··on Tesla Q4 2021 Vehicle Production and Deliveries
Interesting. I have 95,000 miles on a 2018 Model 3. No rattles. The maintenance has been a windshield, underbody cover for the rear wheels (got torn when I hit abou 6" of standing water), and one bad SW update that required a hard system reset that put the car back to factory settings (had to re-configure Homelink, audio, etc).

Otherwise, it's been a fantastic experience. Incredibly fun to drive.

11thEarlOfMar··on 2021 Letter
Thanks. According to Rand[0], the % of households in the middle class has shrunk, primarily because they are moving into the upper class. While technically, yes, the middle class is shrinking, it's not for a negative reason (from the perspective of the middle class themselves).

Overall, American households are increasingly wealthy, class divisions notwithstanding.

[0] https://www.rand.org/blog/2021/05/most-americans-consider-th...

← PreviousPage 5 of 34Next →