HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

13ren

803 karma · joined July 22, 2008

learning how to prove algorithms (unfortunately, without having taken undergrad pure maths)

Interested in data integration and maintenance thereof.

submissionscomments
13ren··on Ask HN: Review our startup (bitloot)
This strikes me as a market research tool - trying to find out what people want, the needs, the problem to be solved, the pain to address. It's tricky for users to make the connection between problem and solution (hell, it's tricky for anyone - so why not users?)

Here's my suggestion: target developing knock-offs (copies of existing products). There's a long and glorious tradition of this in open source (linux, gimp, open office, samba, mySQL, etc). It works because users already know they need it, and how to use it, it's already integrated into their behaviour and their other processes and other software - and programmers have a clear specification to work from. This narrowing the kind of project you seek to fund (i.e. a niche) will help you in many ways, as any business book will recommend (even though narrowing your options seems like a limiting thing...)

But please don't use this to undermine good-guy programmers, who took the risk of working to understand a problem, design a solution and get it accepted - use your bounty powers for good, not evil. That is, use it to break monopolies that are hurting customers in small industries. If they have any sense, the monopolist will back down, and some good will be done (whether the open source product is actually used or not). Sounds like good, heroic fun!

13ren··on How To (really) Trust A Mathematical Proof
The "library of foundational proofs" sounds a little like this graph of hyperlinked theorems online: http://us.metamath.org/mpegif/mmset.html#overview
13ren··on Sun announcing up to 6000 (18%) layoffs
It's the tide.

Digital corporation: very profitable minicomputer business... until workstations were good enough.

Sun microsystems: very profitable workstation business... until microcomputers were good enough.

It's hard for a business to get back to where it was, when the very basis of its success is washed away. See "the innovator's dilemma" (actually inspired by the Digital story). You're right though, that Apple has done it... seemingly by shifting its weight to a different aspect of its business (consumer design) that was present all along. IBM has also done it (from cash registers, to mainframes, to minicomputes, to microcomputers, to today) - however, it seems now to be consulting-based (like Accenture), which is a different kind of business altogether, from IBM's traditional office automation products, but which was always present (like Apple).

13ren··on Balsamiq hits $100,000 in revenue
Sorry about the inflammatory "hydrogen bomb" example - I couldn't think of a better way to express the thought (though maybe that's no excuse), but now I can: when looking for examples of companies that were harmed by opening sourcing their product, it's not the number of examples (find just "one"), but the proportion harmed, of those who open sourced their product. The thing is, not many companies have done it.

Netscape open-sourced their browser... that didn't work out too well for them (but there were other factors). Several companies are based on open source (Firefox, Red Hat), but it was open source before they came along. Some companies do open source their product, once it's old (your id e.g., there's also ghostscript). Cynwin open source their stuff, but they do it by selling services.

BTW: as the poster you replied to: I began as open source, but switched to closed source. Why? I found it very frustrating and disrespectful when people said they would buy a commercial license (I dual licensed), and then took three months to buy it. I clearly wasn't a priority - they didn't need to do anything; I was dependent on their goodwill. (I wouldn't have minded if they didn't tell me they were going to buy until later - I just found the waiting very difficult. Maybe this is a character defect, or I wouldn't have been affected if I had many many sales going at once... ). Anyone, I switched to closed (at the same time as a complete rewrite that was needed anyway), and immediately started getting several times as many sales.

Open source is tantamount to giving it away for free - make no mistake. (you've said you don't want to give it away for free; and that you don't believe open source necessarily means that - this is just my opinion here) You need a business model that works with that, such as: sell a service/maintenance; sell add-ons/upgrades; advertising (e.g. TV; google; firefox).

Your point about "pay it forward" gestures of goodwill - or just plain doing something worthwhile and good - does not mean you have to give it away for free. If you have created something great, or made something people want, or improved people's quality of life, or made something better, or righted a wrong, or fixed something that was broken, of helped people to do what they need to do - you have done something that is good. It's not just a gesture of goodwill, it's actual good. I think the focus needs to be on making something worthwhile in the first place - price comes afterwards.

I think their are two very basic pricing concerns, with respect to social good: (1). price it low enough so it's worth buying for the values it gives, and it's affordable for anyone who needs it. Too high, and you prevent some good you could have done - you can have different prices for different value given (e.g. per seat, functionality); and for different people (e.g. zero for charities); (2). price it high enough so that it's worth your own investment in doing it, and that you can afford to devote the needed time to it without starving etc (same arguments as above).

Within those two limits, anything goes, including giving it away for free if that helps.

Lastly, an exception: another way of doing good is just by price - Microsoft's DOS was cheaper; PC clones were cheaper than IBMs; web apps are cheaper than desktop apps. Often, a new conception of the whole business can reveal a cheaper way of doing it. These things are good because they make them affordable to more people, for more purposes. I'm not sure on the goodness of making something even cheaper that is already affordable to everyone... I guess it is good, but not as good as making it cheap enough to be worth buying in the first place; or, more importantly, creating the valuable new thing in the first place. Maybe it's just because I think the latter is exciting and cool.

for one discussion of "be good": http://www.paulgraham.com/good.html

13ren··on Michael Crichton on talent: "I just work hard"
This isn't a bad strategy to try, for morale, confidence and people wanting to help you: http://www.paulgraham.com/good.html
13ren··on Michael Crichton on talent: "I just work hard"
Another good "talent vs effort" article: http://www.sciam.com/article.cfm?id=the-secret-to-raising-sm...
13ren··on Michael Crichton on talent: "I just work hard"
Great article, I refer to it often, especially points 6, 7 and 8.

However, I find the example of Steve Ballmer... uninspiring. It seems more like the luck of knowing Bill Gates, and he gets to oversea Microsoft's demise.

13ren··on Balsamiq hits $100,000 in revenue
I'm personally troubled about the right attitude towards competitors... I but I think it's:

Don't worry about competitors. Worry about making something people want.

Constantly improving your product, for what your users want, automatically protects you against competition. I also find that worrying about competitors (instead of customers) can lead to a self-defensive mindset.

If [users] take you up, no competitor can keep you down. http://www.paulgraham.com/startuplessons.html

13ren··on Balsamiq hits $100,000 in revenue
Some other options: You could open source the engine, but not code that is specific to the game (then people couldn't run the game). For a legal distinction, you can also make source available, without making it open source. e.g. "look, modify but don't redistribute." See the creative commons licenses. Or make it available only to buyers of the software.

A benefit to open sourcing the engine: it would make it possible to become a platform, with other games built on it - and the publicity etc could help you. (Of course, open-sourcing isn't enough to automatically have your platform adopted - you'd have to promote it and work at it. More work!)

BTW: your art assets are copyrighted automatically. You don't have to do anything (in the past this was necessary in some jurisdictions).

The vast majority of companies choose not to open source their products. It's therefore hard to draw conclusions from what happens to those that do. Please forgive me for this parody, it's for illustration purposes only: can you find just one example of a company that failed or was harmed because they exploded a hydrogen bomb in their head office?

balsamiq on piracy: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=337821

esr discusses id's decision (near the end) in the section "when to be open, when to be closed": http://www.catb.org/~esr/writings/cathedral-bazaar/magic-cau...

13ren··on Is Apple Building A Search Engine?
There's a sort of Gresham's Law of trolls: trolls are willing to use a forum with a lot of thoughtful people in it, but thoughtful people aren't willing to use a forum with a lot of trolls in it. Which means that once trolling takes hold, it tends to become the dominant culture. http://paulgraham.com/trolls.html

I think this is also true of "diluting" comments. Once they become acceptable, the forum has had it. Everyone will say "it's already diluted, so what's the harm?"

13ren··on The freemium business model: giving away pays
I wasn't defining Freemium; just using it as a jumping off point for talking about social good (because the blog author mentioned "do good" and "do well").

I'm concerned about social good, for the reasons pg discusses (morale, confidence, people want to help you). It feels good to do good. That's my topic. Freemium is not my topic.

I agree that Freemium could be used by a "totally ruthless business person" - but that explicitly isn't the case I was talking about (though evidently not sufficiently explicit).

Therefore, you aren't addressing the part of my comment that I'm interested in - that's because you saw it as trying to define Freemium in a way you disagree with. Maybe I could have been clearer that I wasn't defining Freemium. Actually, I consciously chose the qualification "But for selling software" to distinguish my subject from Freemium - I happily concede that this qualification may have been inadequate to the purpose. Maybe also I shouldn't post that in a comment on an article about Freemium - but the article also was about doing good and doing well, so there is a relation - though clearly not the one you expected. BTW what you say about Freemium seems pretty reasonably to me from my wider reading, although I don't take a position on what it is or isn't; I'm not arguing that.

At the moment, the issue of doing good is very important to me, personally, and I can't afford to let it slip away. If my topic wasn't wasn't so important to me, I would happily switch to your topic (definition of Freemium) and discuss that.

PS: That also explains why you give advise me to be careful when I start describing or defining what something really means or what it's benefits are - it's because you thought I was doing that. I wasn't.

13ren··on Balsamiq hits $100,000 in revenue
I had this discussion with a (huge) US corporation, and they weren't interested in escrow, saying it was too complex. They wanted source code; and I had the impression that with appropriate license restrictions (i.e. they couldn't sell/distribute it) it wouldn't be a problem (actually, having source would help them give me bug reports).

A secondary reason (or perhaps the true one?) was a sense of reassurance that the source code really did belong to me (not violating anyone else's IP).

They offered 3 times my top license price, straight up. They arranged an international conference call with their IT VP, and two tech guys with me. I think they would have gone much higher. I didn't actually go with this, because I just felt uncomfortable about it.

My opinion: (1). Big US corporations are amazingly terrified of litigation, therefore you can trust a negotiated license; (2). Big US corporations will happily pay much more than you can realistically imagine your product is worth. The inconceivably rich corporations are not like you and me, they evaluate on a different scale, with different values.

13ren··on Major Breakthrough: First Photos of Planets Around Other Stars
Yes, and those planets are also hotter, therefore brighter and more visible.

The sky might be full of earth-like planets, and we wouldn't know (yet).

unless... detecting star-wobble is already sensitive enough to detect earth-like mass and distance from sun?

13ren··on Major Breakthrough: First Photos of Planets Around Other Stars
If there was a habitable planet in that system with intelligent life, with the same capabilities as us, they wouldn't be able to see any of the planets in our solar system.
13ren··on Google's Plop is implemented in Lisp
Can't you restrict the domain, and so that the program is complete (for that restricted domain)?
13ren··on The freemium business model: giving away pays
I didn't think you were attacking my character - I thought you were saying that my argument was so weak that it was a straw man argument, erected only be knocked down. I replied that your cynicism about my motives was misplaced. And it is.

Since you haven't made any connection between your follow-up and the issues I was raising, I'm assuming there isn't one. You were just posting.

13ren··on Second Life affair leads to real life divorce
I don't see how this is hacker news. flagged.
13ren··on Major Breakthrough: First Photos of Planets Around Other Stars
They do, but it's hard to find: http://www.space.com/php/multimedia/imagedisplay/img_display...
13ren··on Major Breakthrough: First Photos of Planets Around Other Stars
pic: http://www.space.com/php/multimedia/imagedisplay/img_display...
13ren··on "Sequential programming is dead. So stop teaching it"
Well, he did say it was a diktat, which I had to lookup: http://www.tfd.com/diktat
13ren··on "Sequential programming is dead. So stop teaching it"
Itanium
13ren··on "Sequential programming is dead. So stop teaching it"
Maybe we do: faster client-side AJAX would create a much better user experience... but how much this is needed, I don't know. Maybe it doesn't really matter?

At any rate, speed can be increased substantially without faster hardware, but with: (1) efficient implementations of javascript (Chromium); (2) faster Flash (AS3 + AIR); (3) web-friendlier Java (JavaFX); or even Sliverlight.

But the nice thing about faster hardware is you get faster apps without rewriting or learning new tech - opps, unless that faster hardware is many-core[⁎]...

Another reason to not need many-core is that desktop apps are already fast enough for the staples (word processing, spreadsheets). Hence the rise of sub-notebooks, the iPhone, and the best-selling games console being by far the least powerful (wii).

[⁎] many-core (as opposed to multi-core) technically means heaps of processors - tens or hundreds. It is a qualitatively different situation from one thread per processor.

13ren··on "Sequential programming is dead. So stop teaching it"
I don't think throughput is a barrier at the moment.

The main touted benefit I've heard of Chromium's tab-threading is insulation, so if one tab crashes it doesn't bring the whole browser down.

13ren··on "Sequential programming is dead. So stop teaching it"
Many-core overshoots needed performance for most uses. Hence the rise in sub-notebooks, iPhones, best-selling games console being by far the least powerful console (wii).

+

Concurrency is a unsolved problem. There are locks etc; there's smalltalk/Erlang pure-message passing and Web Services/SOA (it's concurrency). Concurrency is of academic interest, and niche apps (game engines; simulations; etc.

=

unsolved problem that is not needed... so far, anyway

13ren··on "Sequential programming is dead. So stop teaching it"
Please elaborate.
13ren··on The freemium business model: giving away pays
Sometimes that early release simply isn't worth paying for yet

If so, no one buys it - no problem :-) (assuming they can evaluate it first, e.g. free trial).

Though there seems to me a difference between releasing early to get people to use it, and releasing to get people to pay for it.

I don't know. You could be right. But both require a benefit to the user; and both exact a cost from the user - of learning; time and effort of changing behaviour to integrate it into their life and apply to their problem; constraining other choices/products to integrate with the product (depending on what kind of product you have). It's natural to think price is the cost of something - but it's simply not. (It's true though, that customers also think of it that way).

hehe I'm getting a bit of the answering-the-comment-while-being-edited syndrome :-) It's a bit disconcerting seeing from the other side.

13ren··on The freemium business model: giving away pays
My argument also wasn't intended as a strawman, so I don't really understand how your initial reply relates to my comment. Though I think we're probably just talking at cross-purposes, as I'm discussing "being good" while you're talking freemium.

BTW: TV/radio is ad-supported. PayTV has apparently not worked out as a good business.

Interesting your point about the cinema concession stand - though there's also student discount tickets; and "gold-class" premium seating (here in Australia, anyway).

13ren··on The freemium business model: giving away pays
HN discussion thereof: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=337821
13ren··on The freemium business model: giving away pays
My own experience is with software that was free for a year before my first sale (though I made it available for sale pretty much near the start). So I did do what you are thinking. But I developed it entirely in public: the first version (released) took me 2 hours to write. This approach was great for countering my perfectionism.

(1) Yes. You don't need a free version to sell stuff. But what does "leveraged" mean in your case? If it's a network effect, where your offer has no value unless there are already users (e.g. a dating site), you would need some way to build up users.

(2) All products are incompletely tested... it's an opportunity to show customer service... and version 2. There's a question of degree here of course. You're right, you do have a chance to try it out on free users - although bugs are just as annoying for them as for mium/fee customers. Maybe the way to think about it is: are they paying for the benefit you offer, or for the absence of bugs? People complain, but they still buy - because they know no-one is perfect. Provided you treat them with respect, they may even like you more because of it.

(3) People don't like it if you take something away, especially if they started to rely on it. It creates bad feeling. I think a free trial (time limited) will give you the info you need.

13ren··on The freemium business model: giving away pays
Thanks for reading, but your cynicism about my motives is misplaced.
← PreviousPage 2 of 15Next →