HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

3pt14159

17,869 karma · joined October 21, 2008

zachaysan@gmail.com

https://twitter.com/zachaysan

www.zachaysan.com

submissionscomments
3pt14159··on Rebuilding after the replication crisis
Yes, I think your way of phrasing it is more correct. Lives are on the line with psychology, but the feedback loop is usually broken.
3pt14159··on Ask HN: What are 100K dollar ideas but not million dollar ideas?
You say that, but the nice thing about an app is that they don't go to sleep.
3pt14159··on ‘Some things never leave you’: Poverty’s indelible marks
When I was poor[0] it wasn't really the food that got to me. No, rice kept well and I'd cut up some hotdogs into it or melt some butter or oil or something. The problem was the crushing depression of thinking of every single quarter.

Things you take for granted like wanting to read a book or going downtown Toronto to visit friends. Every drive with the car was a gamble. It's this sort of constant pressure that eats up so much of your mental energy.

Healthy food on a budget is easy if you're not depressed. Bake some sweet potatoes. Raw carrots with hummus. Eggs. The problem is that you didn't clean the kitchen because you hate your life and now there are all these little ants all over the place. And now you don't want to be home to cook and you can't really go anywhere either because you're broke. But you do anyway, because you want to be around people, and so you stretch that $5 pint of Labatt 50 across as long as you can.

It's not a fun life. I don't recommend it.

[0] Startup poor in 2009, as in, my startup was failing but I could get an above average job with little more than a resume. I understand that this is not the same thing as proper poor, but it sure felt horrible anyway.

3pt14159··on Rebuilding after the replication crisis
Not going to comment on psychology directly, because I don't know enough about it, but there are some fields where there really is no replication crisis.

In structural engineering we literally tore metals apart to find their physical properties. Concrete was mixed. Giant crushing machines were used. Etc. Sometimes I think that half the reason why some fields don't have a replication crisis is because literal lives are on the line if you get it wrong, so people actually do the work to make the testing gear and align the incentives that need to be aligned.

3pt14159··on Ask HN: What are 100K dollar ideas but not million dollar ideas?
Call around 100 high net worth individuals. Tell them you're looking to build an app to help them manage all aspects off their life. Relationship with spouse, how to handle vices, deal flow, whatever. The point is that there are a lot of high net worth people that want something to simplify their life.

For example, "when I get in the car and it is after 6pm but before 9pm and the car is headed west on the 401, text my wife that I just got on the highway and I'm headed home."

Charge $8k per month. Someone will take you up on it.

3pt14159··on Who ranks better? Memgraph vs. NetworkX PageRank
Wait, graph-tool is finally on Python 3? I loved graph-tool. Even did a conference talk on it once. But for years it was Python 2.7 only, so much that I finally gave up on ever using it again.

For me, NetworkX is good for exploration, but shouldn't be used for anything serious in production. Once you sorta figure out what you want to do there are so many other things you should use before NetworkX that may take longer to get the data in, and may be more annoying to query, but are ultimately more suited to the task.

It's hard to even compare these different tools directly because they solve different problems. For example, if data integrity was paramount I'd just use Postgres and recursive querying / intelligent partitioning. If speed were important, Memgraph or sparse matrices in Numpy. If the data were large documents with tag like relationships, some sort of document store (used Riak last time around, but that was over ten years ago).

3pt14159··on Improving Firefox stability on Windows by retrying failed memory allocation
Right. What I'm saying is that swap vs available HD is a tradeoff the OS should be making and it's probably going too far in the "have avail HD" side of the spectrum or at least not employing enough predictive analytics to figuring out the right balance for any given time.
3pt14159··on Improving Firefox stability on Windows by retrying failed memory allocation
Eh—the blame comes down to the swap.

If the swap were allocated to the whole HD that wasn't used for actual files, then this hack wouldn't work.

If the swap were leaner that it already is, this hack would be necessary in every program.

If I had to point a finger at who is to blame, it's the Windows swap allocation team. Some combination of predictive analytics or even just a saner ratio of swap to free HD for an incoming file would fix this problem for most users most of the time.

But computers are hard and people want to keep them running for days on end. I get that memory just slowly, slowly gets eaten up by all the zombie procs out there.

3pt14159··on Pristine meteorite found within hours of hitting Earth
A bit off topic, but can we start straight up catching these in Low Earth Orbit? What's the hard part here? Detecting them before they're close or getting a earth orbiting satellite to the precise right place at the right time?
3pt14159··on Don't hide things that didn't go perfectly
Where are the fire engines this time guys?
3pt14159··on Don't hide things that didn't go perfectly
In the long run this is counterproductive.

First, you end up working with people that make it past recruiters that require you to lie.

Second, you don't end up practicing the skills of tactfully educating someone that is a gatekeeper. For example, if someone said something like that to me I'd say something like "oh, well, the person who sent you that requirement must have meant cryptocurrency experience since, Solidity hasn't been out that long." No need to make some less technical recruiter feel stupid.

Third, you develop the skin you need when you are really wrong and can't hide it. If you fail and take ownership of it routinely enough it will allow you to accept it better when you have no choice.

3pt14159··on The leap second’s time is up: world votes to stop pausing clocks
Imagine how we would feel if we adjusted lat-long definitions instead of smearing or leaping time in order to adjust for the slowing down of the rotation of the earth.

Does that sound bananas to you?

Of course it is. That's what we're doing with leap seconds. Only some people smear and some people leap and they don't even do it over the same time or in perfect synchronicity.

Just ditch the leap seconds. They are not worth the cost.

3pt14159··on The leap second’s time is up: world votes to stop pausing clocks
The issue doesn't go away.

> more human friendly formats for display to end users.

This is what's doing the very heavy lifting in your proposal. Leaving aside not knowing when future leap seconds will occur (and thus getting mismatches when broadcasting to different computers that may or may not get the information about the leap seconds at different times) the sheer fact of the matter is that software developers are users too. They will take shortcuts and display TAI as UTC because "something, something people are lazy or uneducated."

We do not need leap seconds. We never should have implemented them. They are a scar on our software for potentially hundreds of years already for any application that seeks to have high accuracy over time.

Time is very frequently a join key or part of a join key in a database and these small differences mean countless hours wasted to investigate "couple of record" mismatches.

Just stop using leap seconds. We will be fine.

3pt14159··on The leap second’s time is up: world votes to stop pausing clocks
Eh. I see the downsides of a lot of that HFT stuff, but there are upsides too. Yes a lot of it is zero sum, but not all of it is. Lowering spreads between currencies, say, does materially help non-finance actors. There are other areas of the stock market that are useful too. Ingesting financials and other non-manipulated data to better reflect a company's true worth at any time helps, for example, employee option holders that seek to have a fair renumeration for their labour.
3pt14159··on The leap second’s time is up: world votes to stop pausing clocks
Yes, but not every logger, db, etc is going to include the timezone. What they did was the right call for the situation.
3pt14159··on What You (Want to)* Want
> Most serious philosophers would agree with the idea that scientific evidence is a good way to rule out beliefs inconsistent with reality.

And how did they get to that conclusion? The answer of whether or not the mind or the senses can be relied upon as a path to bedrock truth is something that cannot be found with scientific inquiry because it begs the question.

> Almost zero serious economists are marxists, almost zero serious philosophers embrace Spinoza with no revisions, and please don't read Ayn Rand.

It is precisely that these philosophers were so well followed, and presently rejected, that I enumerated them as examples of castles built on sand. The very same thing could be said of Russell. If there were a public event, more apparent than even the nuclear explosions that went off in Japan, that was strong evidence for the First Cause argument much of Russell turns to mush.

That a philosopher is serious or not is a function of time and opinion. Not veracity.

> what makes a question interesting

What makes your response interesting to me is that Russel had the very same counterargument to Solipsism and in my opinion Russel decided that he couldn't find the rock so he built his philosophy on sand.

This question was important to me so I went searching in philosophy and I found some value there, some manners of perception that proved useful, but it, in my opinion, is a largely broken field.

3pt14159··on Ask HN: Is there a cloud music library that doesn't keep deleting my music?
The problem with this is that I don't want to maintain an iOS app. I've considered RSS feeds, etc. But at the end of the day holding onto a song you love that you paid for shouldn't be this hard.

For subscription services, I get it. I don't love it, I think the contracts they've all negotiated are stupid, but fine. I get that a bunch of lawyers leads to me not being able to play almost any of my music while I fly over the Pacific.

But the combination of locked-down-OS (something I'm actually for) and legaleses / constant access negotiations means the effort I would have to go through to legally pay for music and actually hold onto it for good and then play it from my phone is too hard.

3pt14159··on What You (Want to)* Want
After a while the speed at which a fan turns in a circle in order to move heated air off a CPU stops being interesting and larger questions that aren't as falsifiable start to seem interesting since they have so many implications to the practical questions that do matter.

For example, "does God exist?" has huge influence on how we think of why wars are caused.

The trouble is that much of philosophy is castles built on sand. The first principles are accepted and then built upon with potentially faulty links from layer to layer until it all starts getting weird. Marxism, Objectivism, Spinozism, etc.

3pt14159··on How to hack the simulation?
Because they lean on their axioms in such ways that leads them to put faith in them to answer harder questions.

It's the same basis that most technically minded people have that leads them to reject the idea that God exists. They put their faith in reason and technology.

3pt14159··on The Queen’s Coup
Well, I make no bones about the fact I loved the Queen. So take this with as much salt as you think you need, but I honestly think that there isn't really a better solution than what we have. Queen Elizebeth did not want the role of monarch. She literally prayed to God when she found out that she was in the direct line of succession. She asked for a brother, so she wouldn't have this heavy burden of responsibility.

If we want a single, final, sole, human decision maker I do not see how we can accomplish this without a monarchy that doesn't come with the massive downsides of attracting those that have a lust for power. That the monarchy is essentially toothless in all but the most dire circumstances is a feature not a bug.

It's like the folks in the military that get slated to man the nuclear weapons silos. Very few want the job because they know that they're only need in the very rare circumstance where the whole world is on the line.

It's illiquid power.

As for the rest of it, the holdings, etc. I looked at the Queen as essentially a guardian of nature and an encourager of those in the military, intelligence and of the many charities that exist across The Common Wealth. Yes, she had many fancy dinners, but we got more than what we paid for. Whether encouraging a single little girl to become a doctor when she grows up or slapping a good-hearted wealthy guy on the back when he donates a colossal fortune to helping orphans the return on investment is obvious. Fifteen minutes of her time yielded (and continues to yield) tremendous return.

3pt14159··on Bubbles
(dmix man long time no see! Let's hang out soon!)

I agree that this is a true work of art. The variation and attention to detail is delightful. I hope more people put together and share stuff like this on HN.

3pt14159··on The Queen’s Coup
I know this seems weird to outsiders, but as a Canadian I quite like it.

Having PMs elected by MPs means that it is harder for a single rabble rousing politician to sweep to power and distort the use of, say, the military.

Having Governers General appointed by PMs, and confirmed by the monarch, means that someone outside of politics (usually a well respected figure like a university president or astronaut) holds the final red line about whether or not an election must be called. Since it's via appointment, the monarch doesn't bear the brunt of the public rage for it. And since the monarch must confirm the GG it means that the position can't be stuffed with an obvious political hack.

It jives better than it sounds it would jive. It's like checks and balances with as many arguments and gridlock.

As an aside, I feel the same way about the Notwithstanding Clause[0] of the Canadian Constitution. It's a useful tool to diffuse hard issues that can't be used against the public to stop them from voting or speaking and since it automatically expires after a short, preset time the power is ultimately in the hands of the electorate.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Section_33_of_the_Canadian_Cha...

3pt14159··on No, You Aren’t Going to Get Rich by Options Trading
People said the same thing with crypto way back.

The truth is sometimes people are able to make money on something. Sometimes their returns are going to be eye watering.

But you should know going in that finance is a game for sharks. If your skill is in mathematics, did you go to the best one of the best universities for it? If not, think long and hard about what type of angle you have that others haven't found. There may be a downside that you're unaware of.

But yes, the market can be be beat if you've got insight.

3pt14159··on Ask HN: Why is there no way to lower amber alert volume on headphones?
These are obviously complete trash. Waking people up in the middle of the night for some random child that was abducted half a Belgium away with no real call to action even if it were in the same very small town.

What we need is political pressure for a pay-to-play solution. You fire an alert at my phone, that's $100 deposited within a week against my phone bill or offered via mail for the pay-as-you-go burner phone types.

Then if the phone goes off I know its something real. Right now it's just a waste of resources and annoyance, probably killing more people than it is saving via sleepy or distracted drivers or medical professionals.

3pt14159··on Story: “It would be career limiting..."
This type of thinking is how we get ants. Ants Lana. Ants.

There are real humans in the loop here. They can easily put their foot down and find another job if they get fired. These are not people at the edge of feeding their families. These are people that buy 94 octane gas at the Sunoco fuel pump for their stupid sports car.

If people don't make moral decisions in their day to day lives the world gets worse. It may not seem like the millions of dollars belong to anyone but they do. Pensioners or millionaires or even just normal folks that grasp their tiny share of the pool via their ESOP.

When people just throw resources and good will under the bus in the name of career advancement they're visibly hurting the world. Each single dollar could have been spent on refugees, climate change, or war relief.

I am very sick of this cavalier attitude by the tech elite.

3pt14159··on Ask HN: Skeptical about my company going “full serverless”. What am I missing?
I've done serverless where it made sense: Data feeds for the Nasdaq where end of stock market day means lighting up tons of servers reactively to incoming data from data brokers.

Everywhere else, I went with traditional deployment of a monorepo.

You only have 100 concurrent users. You do not need serverless. You could serve 100x that amount easily with a simple nginx reverse proxy to your webserver.

This is almost comical enough for me to suspect that it is satire, but unfortunately there are too many examples out there of this type of thinking. It's just infra bloat and a waste of money.

3pt14159··on Just don’t
"Just" is just like the word "k"

To some people it's seen negatively, like they should have thought of something or other, to others it's a stand-in for "merely" or "simply" but I find "simply" much more condescending.

Speaking generally, I heard the word "just" mostly when working on motorcycles or other hands on things like laying down floor boards or finishing concrete. There's a shared respect for the workers in those environments that ascents to a quick course correction by someone that has a better idea. If I heard someone on a construction site say "simply hammer in the cross beam from the ladder." I'd probably throw the level at them. I don't want politician speak at a job site.

But then I found out about how some people in tech hear the word "just" as a signifier of thinking the person is stupid. So I've toned it down. But sometimes.

Sometimes.

Sometimes, really, just put in a caching layer for your webserver or tell me why I'm wrong.

3pt14159··on Microsoft is phoning home the content of PowerPoint slides
Well, the original article was about Microsoft. Since they're the OS vendor too, I discounted that as being reliable for this use-case.
3pt14159··on Microsoft is phoning home the content of PowerPoint slides
> with TLS/SSL inspection built in (you'd need some OS API to enable that).

I'm not sure of that. Provided you can add a cert to your OS, you should be able to get away with a piece of protocol downgrade network gear that you can then pipe to a different (ideally, offline other than UDP receive) computer for analysis.

You'd need to disable HSTS, but other than that I think it should be the solution you're looking for. Oh, and for good measure, ethernet cable instead of wifi.

3pt14159··on Lyft to lay off about 700 employees in second round of job cuts
Then imagine this: War over Taiwan. One way or another all the fabs get incinerated.

Which companies go bankrupt now?

← PreviousPage 5 of 34Next →