6,297 karma · joined December 9, 2016
I'm going to have to ask for a little more rigour than "they use data".
Data can be wielded in all manner of manipulative fashion to suit a preferred narrative. And when it's wielded by engineers defending large AI (or any) companies, they should at least acknowledge the fact that the data reporting is "coming from inside the house", so to speak.
Let's not forget all the razor blade enthusiasts just screaming at you that you are using babies with razor blades wrong and that it works totally fine for them.
One day everything works brilliantly, the models are conservative with changes and actions and somehow nail exactly what you were thinking. The next day it rewrites your entire API, deploys the changes and erases your database.
If only there was intellectual honesty in it all, but money talks.
Doubly so when they use such innocuous and authoritative titling as "Our World in Data" which implies some collectivist, community-based outlook that this website is indeed not.
To wit, this page is produced in part by the Global Change Data Lab which is a team of economists, and YCombinator.
But that is exactly what it is sold to people to do as a panacea: consume all the data, produce insights.
Nobody is being instructed to be judicious. Everyone is being instructed to use it as much as possible for all problem areas.
Not even a few years ago if you introduced a component to a system that would result in non-deterministic output... Hell, a single function... You would be named and shamed for it because it went against every principle you should be learning as a novice writer of software.
I have used the LLM tools, and I see the real-world potential for these things. But how it's all being sold and applied now: it's upside down.
That means that a large number of high ranking people in these companies projected they would need these people in the coming years, and then some.
I think it may be darker than that, and the overhiring was a tentative measure to build up a charge, like electrons in a capacitor, to release a shock to the market that would achieve two aims:
1) drive salaries down through fear and contest
2) reduce the bargaining power of employees (software engineers were starting to look to unionizing in the past 5 years especially and that has gone deathly quiet even though working conditions have worsened and demands have increased on 'ICs')
It's rudimentary electronics physics. Such physics is regularly applied to economic systems modelling to achieve predictable outcomes (usually making more money).Any objection as to whether these companies executive teams were collaborating should be seen as very empty by now, given we know they are all deeply circularly invested in each other and thus are bound to each other's success or failure.
The move is to review those polices, and decline.
It's actively hostile.
It should be treated as such.
The pain of declining on the privacy or personal rights grounds is intentional on their part. They do not respond to inquiries. And in my experience, companies that just use those tools decline to answer inquiries about it.
https://www.masshist.org/beehiveblog/2013/05/advertising-in-...
If you are looking for one canonical, authoritative source to declare something absolutely for you, you will never find it. No such thing exists for any matter. That is a myth of the internet and people raised on it.
I think this 'pay for ads you are just lucky to be here' thing is a distinctly American invention...
What happens when I am constantly violating usage terms by calling ChatGPT mean names for ignoring my explicit instructions and trying to turn everything into a trite creative writing project.
"Not programming. Not efficiencies. Terrible, terrible poetry."
> metabolically expensive meat machines
Calm down. There is no meat. It's just a giant sponge of wave packets.
Your take is the most S.V. conformist one there is: materialist reductionism, and it is doomed.
Tell me you don't understand hitchhikers guide without telling me you don't understand hitchhikers guide. This is as bad as Thiel and ilk's inverted reading of LOTR.
Don't you see it? That's exactly what "AI" in this context is.
It's the bypass.
Where does it end, eh? Build a quantum "AI" that will end up just needing more data, more input. The end goal must starts looking like creating an entirely new universe, a complete clone of everything we have here so it can run all the necessary computations and we can... ? (You are what a quantum AI looks like as it bumbles through the infinitude of calculable parameters on its way to the ultimate answer)
I wager this is a point that needs beaten into the common psyche. After all, it's been sold that it is not an imperfect tool, but the solution to all of our problems in every field forever. That's why these companies need billions upon billions of dollars of public subsidies and investments that would otherwise find their way to more pragmatic ends.
I don't think it's the bureaucrats. You should hear the Flock CEO talk. They have made it very public that their direct intent is to influence government policy in sweeping and total fashion to enable their service to be the mass surveillance tool of the near future. They sincerely believe that people will look back on them as the saviours of mankind.
That is the most succinct manner I've seen this whole thing put.
I don't trust anonymous online mudslingers when I've seen the salaries of some of the midlevel AI roles. It all stinks.
Worse yet: this person points to one article he disfavours and uses that as sufficient context to slander. And what is being called mud, on the writer's part, I see as just a little dust.
It stinks. Answer the figures.