HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

75dvtwin

695 karma · joined April 12, 2015

programming, enterprise IT. C++, Erlang, lua
submissionscomments
75dvtwin··on Twitter and Facebook's action over Joe Biden article reignites bias claims
Eloquent.

You are probably aware then, that conservatives think of the Democrats as the global Cartel, consisting of - bribe takers and money launders - protege of sexual predators - systemic racists

And that claiming that this is a party, and they have a paritcular platform -- is like claiming that Mexican Mafia is a party with platform.

So you can imagine how suprised a conservative is, to learn of how many people lack even mediocre critical thinking, that is meant as immunity against manipulative and conniving propaganda machine.

75dvtwin··on Twitter and Facebook's action over Joe Biden article reignites bias claims
because we do not want corporations claiming protections that they do not deserve.

Editorializing content by twitter's own employees, or by crowd-sourcing, is still editorializing.

So Twitter and FB, HN and others are publishers, not platforms.

Claiming legal shields that apply to platforms, therefore, is not legal.

This is like claiming taxable deduction of a charity, while being a for-profit-business.

75dvtwin··on Twitter and Facebook's action over Joe Biden article reignites bias claims
and their view on censorship:

https://nypost.com/2020/10/14/if-unreliable-is-the-issue-why...

75dvtwin··on Twitter and Facebook's action over Joe Biden article reignites bias claims
I think the outrage is not at NY Post for posting the alligations or at ABC townhall anchor for ignoring them.

Instead the outrage is about Twitter, FB and others who claim to be 'platforms' and therefore protected under section 230, but instead, systemtically and actively, acting as publishers (that are not under 230).

Perhaps an anology is the outrage and legal consequences , when a for-profit-business uses non-profit charity tax code.

75dvtwin··on Twitter and Facebook's action over Joe Biden article reignites bias claims
I hope this incident of systemic bias by Twitter and others, will not just end in 'amplification' of the story.

I hope the result of this outrage, is that the companies that claim to be 'plaforms', but instead are systemically and agressively -- are 'publishers' when it comes to political content, will face legal system.

Just like a for-profit business would face, when they claim 'non-profit charity' taxation rules.

75dvtwin··on Twitter and Facebook's action over Joe Biden article reignites bias claims
everyone at twitter or FB content moderation roles, or execs -- think they are ethics luminaries and moral compases of the 21st century. Sort of the Supreme Court of ethics and moral judgment.

Really the problem is not with liars, it is with liars that wield lots of influence, power -- and try to actively and systemically circumvent existing law.

75dvtwin··on Twitter and Facebook's action over Joe Biden article reignites bias claims
I think the issue with social networks like Twitter and other, claiming legal benefits of 'platforms' while acting as publishers and crowdsourced-publishers.

It is like having a for-profit business that claims tax umbrella of a charitable organization.

All we have to do is simply recongize, that these social networks are publishers of political content.

So they can choose to continue editorialization by crowdourcing, but comittees, by AI, by whatever they want.

And they can live happily but as publishers.

The ISPs (for which section 230 really was meant) -- can continue to be impartial and claim the protection benefits of that section.

75dvtwin··on Twitter and Facebook's action over Joe Biden article reignites bias claims
Ok, as a former New Yorker, what do you think about this explanation of the outrage with the behaviour of social networks executives:

https://nypost.com/2020/10/14/if-unreliable-is-the-issue-why...

?

75dvtwin··on Twitter and Facebook's action over Joe Biden article reignites bias claims
> Social media sites are legally entitled to censure things they disagree with

That's right. But when they do that, can they claim that they are a 'platform' and not a 'publisher' ?

If paulX is a for-profit-business can he claim that his business a non profit and apply tax code designed for non-profit charities ?

75dvtwin··on FCC to move ahead with 'rulemaking' on Section 230
Of course it is.

So is a 'for-profit business' is a perfectly fine thing. But having a for-profit business using tax code for a non-profit charity -- would be criminal.

So why does 230 or other shields apply to Twitter or HN or FB?

My point I think more that a social networking company can apply crowdsourced or individual editorialization to political speech. And that application can also be biased, selective and therefore unfair.

It is ok that these companies might do that, but not OK to hide under shields meant for the companies that do not do that (like ISPs)

75dvtwin··on FCC to move ahead with 'rulemaking' on Section 230
a platform, assumes 'neutrality'. If it is not neutral, it is not a platform.
75dvtwin··on FCC to move ahead with 'rulemaking' on Section 230
You are right. We must not have individual-editorial, or crowdsorced-editorial social networks, treated as 'neutral platforms' when it comes to political or legal content -- basically anything that directly affects political candidates in the country(s) where HN has its main offices.

It is like having a for-profit business hiding under a non-profit tax umbrella.

If HN cannot figure out now to avoid editoralization of polical opinions (either by crowdsource or moderators), then do not allow political content. If HN wants to allow political content, and wants to allow the edtorialization function -- then do not hide behind 'neutral platform'.

75dvtwin··on Twitter and Facebook's action over Joe Biden article reignites bias claims
This is exactly right. If FB, Twitter or HN apply their Terms of service rules selectively (or that the ToS are biased against specific political candidates or groups or opinions) -- then they are not a neutral platform.

If they are not a neutral platform, these companies must not be able to claim protections reserved for neutral platforms (like this section 230).

It is the same as a for-profit business must not claim same tax benefits as a Non-profit Charity. If they do, their execs will likely face jail time.

Systemic violoaters, would face more jail time.

75dvtwin··on FCC to move ahead with 'rulemaking' on Section 230
Well, I propose that FB and HN either apply ToS rules uniformly, or stop claiming a 'neutral platform' status.

Another analogy: if you are a for-profit business, do not claim Charity status. It is criminal if you do.

75dvtwin··on FCC to move ahead with 'rulemaking' on Section 230
If HN, or Twitter or FB, selectively apply their 'Terms of Service' in a way that reduces access to pro-conservative positions -- then they are not a neutral platform.

If they are not a neutral platform, they cannot claim shields of section 230.

It is like for a business that hides money in a Organization with a Charity status. We would have that business facing criminal charges in no time.

Why the execs of these platforms demand something different ?

75dvtwin··on Twitter and Facebook's action over Joe Biden article reignites bias claims
Well, I think you underestimate the gravity of this. A thoroughly corrupt money laundering Biden family machine (which also involves children of other previously high profile politicians) -- may become the presidential family of US.

And the social networks in the country, have chosen to do what they have always done with anti-left news -- they censored them.

My view, make the execs accountable now.

They have to be ones explaining why they apply one set of rules to one side of political opinion, and then another set of rules to the other side. [2]

If they are biased, than they are not a neutral platform.

A person who establishes a Charity non-profit, to hide taxes, launder money -- will be held accountable in a just system.

So should be Twitter, Facebook, and others for hiding behind 'neutral platform and section 230'.

Bring them to justice is the only solution. And do it now, before they buy/lobby their way out...

[1] See my comment here https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24797602

[2] https://nypost.com/2020/10/14/if-unreliable-is-the-issue-why...

75dvtwin··on FCC to move ahead with 'rulemaking' on Section 230
It has to be treated as criminal negligence when a platform applies its 'Terms of Use' or rule of conduct, selectively.

I think that will solve the problem.

Today, HN or Twitter can, selectively, diminish visibility of pro-conservative content and posts, while not applying the same scrutiny to the other side.

They can sit there and claim neutrality, ask for 'evidence' and so on.

But really, they are the ones that should be convincing courts that they were not partial, biased or selective in applying their Terms of Use.

75dvtwin··on Google employees are free to speak up, except on antitrust
> Why on earth would any company encourage its employees to speculate and talk freely, when doing so would get them into legal/PR trouble.

There is another view, and another analogy.

A monopoly that closes ads accounts without any explanation (pointing to their 'terms of use' is not an explanation)

A monopoly that removes apps without any explanation

A monopoly that swallows competition, their patents to further suffocate market space

Is just evil.

Small businesses hurt, consumers manipulated and fair competition practices are poisoned.

So an analogy would be a private contractor for state prison system, is threatening their employees not to talk in public about their practices. While being investigated for corruption, unfair usage of federal and state empowerment, and unfair treatment of the prisoners.

I think this would be ok as far as legal practice, but hardly something one would applaud to, given the context.

75dvtwin··on Merriam-Webster adds 'offensive' annotation after prospective justice uses term
Yes,

The manipulative propagandists controlling Merriam-Webster are shamefully poisoning [1], in real-time, the online reference materials, to give legitimacy to the slander by Senator Mazie Hirono [2] of US Supreme court nominee.

[1] https://twitter.com/jacobkschneider/status/13162312256616325...

[2] https://twitter.com/DavidRutz/status/1316217419732602881

75dvtwin··on Why Software Developers Suck at UX
>But the reason I wanna mainly talk about is that engineers, developers, whatever you want to call them ... > I think great UX designers just grew up naturally having much more empathy towards others and having a much better ability to place themselves in others shoes and see the world from their eyes.

Wow, ok. So software developers (or whatever we call them...) grew up naturally to have less empathy for others, than UX designers...

It seem to hit multiple of logical fallacies [1]

I would like to ask the Arvand from Cakewalk Labs this:

May I also 'extrapolate' that software developers (or whatever we call them..) are not as good parents, spouses, care takers, friends, siblings, when compared to UX practitioners?

Are software developers also closer to displaying symptoms of the illnesses listed here (again when compared to UX folks)

https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/antisocial-pe...

?

While I am disappointed in authors conclusion and explanation, I think observations have merit.

In a typical project, objectively grading (if possible), contribution to 'good' UX of a final product, by somebody who has been full-time software developer for a long time vs somebody who is product owner, or a UX designer -- we will find that the software developer contributed less to good UX.

This could be because, software developers, when working on complex software, must be in the mode of optimizing and reducing, while maintain clarity, verifiable correctness (as it is, eventually, the CPUs that interpret the work of software developers, not opinions of end users...)

That mind set, does not directly translate on to UX work.

In my experience, software developer has to 'switch' the mind set so to speak. To value human interaction constraints, context in which software is used, guidelines and patterns for good UX. And this switch, usually, hard and expensive to do (in both time and effort).

It has nothing to do of how software developers 'grew up' and the levels of their empathy.

I would also suggest that incentives for software developers are different than for UX consultants. So it is natural, and perhaps business-inspired, that software developer would resist software changes that do not expressly address written requirements or bug reports.

[1] https://owl.purdue.edu/owl/general_writing/academic_writing/...

75dvtwin··on Never Again: We Need Science Based Government
Another view, is that applied science that impacts policy making, has become utterly corrupt, and largely unreliable. The transformation happened in the last 30 years or so.

Deeply flawed academia reward system [1], combined with accountability-free bribe dispersing machines (eg book/documentary deals, speech fees, gifted real-estate, insider trading tips), have made this type of science very similar to 'Instagram likes' or 'Amazon reviews' in its reliability.

On top of that, given that elected officials, at least in US, delegate law writing to K-Street [2], who, then, works through lobbyists to entice politicians to buy-into those laws -- we have really, no checks and balances.

With the above point of view, 'Draining the swamp', makes sense for science as well, maybe ?

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24680154 [2] https://politicaldictionary.com/words/k-street/

75dvtwin··on Why I left my tenured academic job
> What should it be based on? Should academics be judged on performance? If so, how?

Thank for the question. It is, indeed, easier to criticize rather than offer constructive suggestions.

Here are my thoughts on the reward system:

- I would like to see published conclusions challenged (if conclusions are based on data observations or empirical evidence). And if the challenge is clean and results are fair, then:

   (1) The challenger gets a credit (regardless if the paper they challenged withstood the challenge or not)

   (2) The original authors of the paper get credit if the paper withstood the challenge(s).

- I would like to see a different credit system for papers in applied sciences, based on whether the result is accompanied by an implementation. Where implementation is either a working inference system (if this is all based on data), or a prototype. The discoveries that are accompanied by a working, publicly consumed implementations, in my view deserve higher credit score.

In other words, I would much prefer that our academic discoveries are encouraged to build consumable implementations (unlike US Patent law that does not require an implementation of an invention).

-if an published paper or a conference presentation was incorporated by the same team into a patent, I would remove any academic credits received by the team's researches. In other words, I would prevent double-dipping, if I may call it that. If the given paper is incorporated into a utility patent by completely different people (and it withstood the USPTO scrutiny), then that's ok.

- if a specific field of study is theoretical in nature (eg mathematics, may be theoretical physics). I would specifically reward joint publications, discoveries where the theoretical subject matter is incorporated into applied field.

- I would include into the reward system books, blogs and article posts that further public understanding of complex science topics (I would apply it for STEM subjects only). Such that online video lectures, and other forms of free/unpaid public education are specifically encouraged. I am not sure how exactly to measure effectiveness of this, but I am sure minds, brighter than mine, could come up with a fair, automatically-correcting model.

75dvtwin··on Why I left my tenured academic job
And this is it. A reward system based on paper publishing and conference speeches is fundamentally broken.

There are really no built-in checks and balances, unless commercial interests care for it to do a 'check', that benefit that commercial interest.

Adding to that, a now well known, built-in corruption of student acceptance and grading, it is impressive that we get any forward movement at all in applied sciences.

>".. . Now, in general, negative results may have value, and it may be worth sharing them. You could write a negative result paper (I think they are valuable). But wait, most conferences don't like those! Shit. So what do you do? You could write a blog post — as detailed as you want, no page limits, etc. you are the boss! — and move on with life with something better? But wait, blog posts "don't count" (more on this later). And in many environments, "no paper" == "I completely lost my time from the eyes of the public"... "

75dvtwin··on French fathers will now get 28 days of paternity leave
that's great, of course.

But do fathers get same treatment in courts, during custody disputes? Property separation disputes, statistically ?

75dvtwin··on eBay’s Cockroach Cult: The Story of a Stalking Scandal
I would think of the economic persecution of individuals as powerful weapon.

just like with any weapon:

- some will call it 'great equalizer'. Meaning that a victim no matter how small and physically weak, can still fight off a number of aggressors

- some will call it a tool of death making, that belongs to the hands of military (in the case of cancel culture, it would be equivalent to saying that this tool belongs government )

Point is, just like usage of any weapon, the morality and legality of economic persecution depends on:

- what / who is it used for

- amount of collateral damage

- who used it

- were there other means, was it legal

- the manipulative power of the legal team defending the use

One thing we can sure of, any new weapon gets adapted by all sides of a conflict.

The case of misuse of this weapon, in my view, was against Brendan Eich [1]

[1] https://www.forbes.com/sites/tonybradley/2014/04/05/backlash...

75dvtwin··on US home construction surges 22.6%, third monthly increase
> assuming when things eventually open up again more in say max a year or two, they will need/want to be back in the city?

Well, I do not have a huge sample to drive any conclusions. But I know a couple whose adult children live in other parts of the world (one in Miami, the other in London).

So the couple is choosing, finally, to sell their NY city home and move to south east Florida closer to one of the children.

Largerly, besides emotional reasons (lack of feeling secure, feeling of being unwanted, feeling of being robbed by local taxes, wanting to be closer to their children) -- they no longer see that their home price will continue to go up to justify sitting there as an 'investment vehicle'.

They are closer to retirement age, so their needs, perhaps are different then others.

They also do not want their children, under any circumstance to move back to NY city or NJ.

75dvtwin··on Telegram messaging app proves crucial to Belarus protests
Oh, that 'politically motivated propaganda' argument.

That's what Lukashenko is using to imprison https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Siarhei_Tsikhanouski .

Who ran a blog and youtube channel, recording, often without the knowledge of the person he was talking too.

It is the same style of investigative journalism as Project Veritas, O'Keefe are using to show the true colors of the people, actions and ideologies hiding, conveniently, behind a banner of a 'legitimate' political party (who also, unlike Lukashenko, have access to far greater resources, including Wikipedia to 'clean up')

I hoped to get across 3 points with my previous post:

a) what's happening in Belarus is systemic, medieval-style suppression of the populous, voter abuse, and political imprisonments.

And the argument that used by Lukashenko, is the same as @dukswuff is used against Project Veritas...

b) One of the imprisoned leaders, exposed the methods of the tyranny, using the same approach as investigative journalism (involving recordings) as Project Veritas, O'Keefe is doing in US.

Technology is important there, but not more or equal to the heroism of the people doing it. And, at least for me, the more dare the retribution, the more heroic actions are of the journalist.

c) Telegram marketing spin manipulating words, trying to assigning the heroism and suffering of the victims -- to their platform.

Just like some in US are using heroism and suffering of the victims in Nazi concentration camps (who did not choose to go there), equating that to people crossing US border illegally and being detained.

This is stealing of valor.

It is being perpetrated in western media daily for many years, and often spills over to events like Democratic National Convention.

====

I am also going add one more point.

The statements Lukashenko is making about Byelorussian's duty to support him, so not dissimilar to the argument Biden is making about the duty of African-Americans to to support his candidacy.

The marks are that similar.

75dvtwin··on Telegram messaging app proves crucial to Belarus protests
@soufron, I agree with you. It is shameful, to call uprising of suppressed -- against systemic unfairness -- as 'Telegram revolution'.

This is akin to stealing valor (basically stealing medals and pretending to be the honorable).

This type of valor stealing, is also happening when people call US border detention facilities as 'Nazi concentration camps'. For people whose family members went through a Nazi concentration camp, hearing such a comparing is painful.

For Byelorussians whose livers and kidneys were raptured by the beatings, whose loved ones are imprisoned -- hearing Telegram marketing spin is painful, like when their valor, their sacrifice is stolen.

Yes of course, without recording technology, in my view, we would not have successful type of investigative journalism that project Veritas has delivered.

Or, without cell phones, the ability of people of Belarus to share images of brutality with the world.

Technology, is helping to concentrate the will power of the masses, against well funded machines of system oppressions.

But the will of the people, their sacrifices, their sufferings -- is the driving force -- not Telegram

75dvtwin··on The Weaponization of Diversity
In US, fed vs local state split -- is also making reforms more difficult, but on the other hand -- it probably prevents monopolization of political opinion + economic will. So over all the separation is good.

I would like, however, federal laws to be updated to protect people from discrimination due to criminal past.

I think a federal law that prevents employers of asking/using criminal past in hiring decisions -- would go a long way of re-integrating previous offenders back into society.

Probably there are specific federal charges that should be hidden -- but majority must not be used for employers, and must not be asked during job application.

I am a sure if such a law would be in effect, a number of people who resource to additional criminal activity, after previous conviction -- would drop at least 10 fold.

These kinds of changes is a must on a road to a more just society.

75dvtwin··on Twitter hides Donald Trump tweet for “glorifying violence”
@dang do you think the above comment and opinions I shared should have -1 and -4 downvotes.

Is that in line with your expectations, given the topic and the manner in which my comments were written?

← PreviousPage 2 of 13Next →