HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

75dvtwin

695 karma · joined April 12, 2015

programming, enterprise IT. C++, Erlang, lua
submissionscomments
75dvtwin··on A Kaggle Grandmaster cheated in $25k AI contest with hidden code
It was briefly discussed about 7 days ago.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22045696

I posted there, same self-addressed question, that I cannot figure out the answer to...

It seems that intensives to cheat, and environment where 'means justify the ways' -- are overpowering.

For people who are naturally gifted, successful at young age -- why cheat?

Was this historically, always like this?

These insensitive to cheat, to gain unfair advantage, to treat life opportunities without any 'honor code' just seem to be so pervasive now, it seems.

There is a cheating scandal every other week involving most prestigious institutions, competitions, and so on.

These incentives to cheat, basically destroy from inside our commercial model, academics, judicial system, political system and probably military too.

This also creates a new type of powerful currency, and therefore the 'billionaires' in that currency have infinite power -- and that currency is 'dirt on somebody'.

Dirt on somebody who cheated before -- forever makes the cheaters into tools of injustice.

---

Public shaming is reactive, there we need something more proactive at various points. There are needs to be incentives for work verification, as an example.

I also think it is unfortunate but at least civil/commercial law in many countries is pretty much riddled with 'more expensive lawyers produce better results'. And it skews society into basically thinking 'anything goes, really. means justify the ways, and cheating something one can get away with'

75dvtwin··on An alternative argument for why women leave STEM
Gender norms are reflection of society expectations.

Society expectations evolve/change with economic and war conditions affecting a particular society at that time.

Those things, unfortunately, go in waves.

So we can pick different parts of history and we will likely see 'gender norms' are being adjusted for the particular environment at that time period.

On top, there are biological projections, and genetic predispositions that are projected on 'gender norms'.

Things that 'change less' are genetic traits and biological differences.

Combining economics/war conditions, with genetic traits + biological differences, creates a sort of 'superposition' that we are observing.

As a society, it makes sense to accommodate the desire of individuals, but not force people into particular choice.

Accommodating a variety of legal choices, is what we should be striving for, rather than trying to influence a particular path.

It is sort of like trying to introduce new type of species (animals or trees) into a new environment -- and expecting that we know about the ecosystem, to predict the effects of invasion.

Most of the time, with our current knowledge and prediction capabilities -- we fail.

---

Which is why, I think accommodating choices (and not predicting or promising outcomes) -- is what we should be doing.

75dvtwin··on An alternative argument for why women leave STEM
>"... One analysis of 11 rich countries estimates that the average mother spent 54 minutes a day caring for children in 1965 but 104 minutes in 2012. ..."

This is analysis is just hard to believe. Between reading books, preparing food, driving to activities -- a full-time parent spends probably 4-5 full hours, except when another parent takes over or there is a continuous split.

The interrupt costs are also very high (and affect negatively ability to work).

75dvtwin··on An alternative argument for why women leave STEM
For me 'family friendly' means 4-day or less work week, 6 hours a day.

Flexibility to take time off with a short notice, office politics that does not induce constant stress and suspicion of being stabbed in the back.

And being around your young children (before 7 years old), most of the time they are awake.

75dvtwin··on An alternative argument for why women leave STEM
I think it is relevant, that you listed professions where

    a) compensation is very high

    b) hours of work cannot be 're-arranged' due to critical life-safety or court-rules.
Clearly, STEM Academia is not one the above (even though apprenticeship hours are grueling).

I presume there are other professions that do not compensate that well, but have similar 'cannot move dates' constraints.

And it would be interesting to see women participation rates on those.

Perhaps this is a specific factor that has gone received proper attention in various analysis.

75dvtwin··on America’s Coal Consumption Entered Free Fall in 2019
What does 'plodding' mean in this context?

> "... Last year, American greenhouse-gas pollution fell by 2.1 percent, driven almost entirely by coal’s decline and a plodding economy..."

75dvtwin··on Bestpetting Cheated
Main cheater identified as Pavel Pleskov.

According to this presentation

https://www.slideshare.net/DataFestTbilisi/how-to-win-a-mach...

He worked at H2O.ai (but I think he was now fired). Prior to that (again according to the above).

    - Master of Science from Moscow State university
    - New economics school (Moscow)
    - Financial Consultant
    - Quantitative Researcher
    - HFT Fund partner
Overall seems to be impressive track, this is the type of track that often mentioned on HN, the top firms would hire from...

Completely not clear why he needed to cheat, are there other sophisticated cheaters out there for these types of competitions?

May be there needs to be prises for 'checking' other peoples work..?

75dvtwin··on Education and Men without Work
I will make a guess for the causeses (that I stole from somebody smarter Tucker Carlson [1]), and if they sound plausible, also will offer solutions.

a) The reason for "... Instead we have witnessed a mass exodus of men from the workforce altogether. ..."

Is that man are looking for work that allows them to earn more than women, that would likely (or like) to date.

Women are not likely to marry/create family with man that earns (or has less earning potential) less than them.

Just as simple as that -- reasons may be deeply cultural, biological or whatever... but I believe this is to be true.

Solution:

De-urbanization/ De-metropolization of work opportunities.

Basically more gov tech, fin tech, bio tech, and other 'high-margin' business need to spread across a given country (UK, or US or whatever).

That spread will create a number of supporting job opportunities as well, that will equalize the earning potential opportunities, lower cost of living averages, create more 'geographically attractive cultural centers' and so on.

That (lowering cost of living, lowering barriers of entry into sustainable jobs, with less competition), in turn, will lower the barriers of entry into economic stability -- which is a requirement for a modern family core.

It is, actually, desirable, that one-person-income should be enough for a family of 4 (two parents and two children). Whether parents choose that or both work, simulatenously, is up to them.

Stable family creates purpose and emotional stability, necessary for healthy work ethics.

---

With that said, 3 other important fed gov initiatives that will be needed

a) affordable, not necessarily free, but truly affordable health care

b) 4-day / 6 hour work week as a 'encouraged' standard.

c) equitable divorce model where man are treated using same criteria as woman (including for not just financial separation, but children custody as well).

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mgvpxE_WKxw

75dvtwin··on Ask HN: Should I make a lower cost replica of niche software?
There is a number of companies that make what's called 'app-scripts'.

One is appdupe.com there are a couple of others.

Basically they take X-like-Y business ideas that demonstrated, nominally, their worth (in either solving a business problem, or attracting investors).

And they just duplicate those models -- uber-like, tinder-like, etsy/ebay-like, and so on.

They generate the source for apps, backend services, etc --- you just give them your twitter handle, name, logo, contact, fb page... whatever.

I also read when researching this, that some of them produce 50 apps per week.

Apparently, again 3rd hand info, that their services start at 10K usd and go up from there....

I have no idea about the quality, may be bad and may be they they will end up charging 10 times more what you though initially...

So imaging that people are not shy of duplicating a business idea and just applying perhaps to something else, or just a different geographical region....

It is definitely not pointless building software that already exists.

I would say go for it...

Either of 3 things will happen

a) you are successful and completion fails

b) they are successful and you fail

c) you are both successful

in all 3 scenarios -- end users seem to be benefit.

75dvtwin··on Zeta: Functional Neural Networks in Ocaml
I think it is more that 'expert programmers' where told to leave 'domain-specific' bits for power-users to deal with.

Therefore,

- game scene development in games, are in scripts. - Equity derivatives and swap contracts are in Excel - scientific modeling is in python

I also agree with your other though that, dynamic loading enables 're-use' of the core framework, so those frameworks/engines become marketable technology assets so to speak.

The programmers, then in some instances, created DSLs to then auto-generate performant framework-specific code from the DSL-written user specs.

But those, usually, are quite limited and also some power users migrated to be descent (not the expert engine/core-level, perhaps) programmers

75dvtwin··on Does America really give green cards for people to become “agile/scrum masters”
Are you sure that case type 'PERM' means green card?

It may mean that H1B visa was granted, but not Green card (or that initial H1B visa recepient, eventually received green card (this can take a few years) ).

You can still question if giving H1B visa to non-essential or non-fulltime roles in technology or any other sector, is justified --

I just wanted to check if "PERM", indeed means green card

It is very rare that green cards are given as an entry status to a foreign worker.

75dvtwin··on Survey of scientists sheds light on reproducibility crisis (2016)
I have seen your point of view, shared over and over again.

Lack of intensives for reproducible research (and for verification of research) is the fundamental problem.

If you are in the shoes of policy makers (eg politicians). What changes would you propose (through both laws and funding/grants models)?

75dvtwin··on Having Kids
I understand that. I was lucky having dedicated parents, that were willing to sacrifice their own ambitions, and take risks that would clearly be more beneficial to me, rather than to them.

Others, might not have been so lucky.

For me, caring about my own children's health/well-being/future was bit eye opening, in the sense that I was a lot more egoistic, before becoming a parent.

I also think that recognition improved my spousal relationship.

And that's what I wanted to tell my Dad... but I missed that opportunity...

There is a lot of materials out there about family dynamics that get passed through generations. [1]

It is exceptionally difficult for an individual to recognize negative traits that must be filtered out, if he/she is to have a more normal relationships with their spouse and their children.

Most families have traits, that overtime, should be filtered out. But not forgotten.

Significant portion of my parent's upbringing was dictated that their parents went through (physical torture, captivity, war, loosing loved ones, loosing first families during war, real famine, property taken away, ridicule and persecution at work and otherwise, for their ethnic background and so on ).

My parents, filtered out lot of the family dynamics that was passed on to them due to the above.

But we did not forget what my grand parents went through..

And just like my parents, I do not excuse my own actions by saying 'well, my parents that that to me...' or anything like that.

It is a conscious act, not 'natural' (at least not for me), and I work on it with my spouse, recognizing that there is nothing wrong in improving what we learnt in our upbringing.

[1] https://blogs.psychcentral.com/family/2012/03/family-dynamic...

75dvtwin··on Having Kids
One clear change that happened with me, once having a child -- is that I understood my Dad much more.

I understood what made him upset, and I understood how he reacted and why... I started showing same behavioral traits as him. But it was only after I had our first child.

Stuff that I took for granted when my Dad was doing it, now I understood, was actually meant to take an effort, on behalf of a parent.

Unfortunately, my Dad passed away weeks after my first child was born. It felt like the 'nature' decided to make a replacement.... and exchange the life of my still young dad, to our first child...

So I did not have the time to express back to him, my gratitude, my newly found understand of his sacrifices to make his children happy & confident, and, at the same time, isolated from bad/unfair stuff....

Therefore, my advice is, do not repeat my mistake. Show your parents, while they are alive -- that you understand their sacrifice, and you are prepared to do the same for your children....

75dvtwin··on Fleck: A Lisp that runs wherever Bash is
We are at very early stages, figuring out if we can use Hammer2 file system as content addressable storage system.

Our needs are such, that writes are relatively rare, and go into one cluster, while reads of our blobs, need to go to geographically distributed nodes, whose disk topology is different (less capable) than that of a muster, plus they have somewhat-unreliable connectivity to the master.

So Hammer's network-problems-tolerant streaming replication and offline de-duplication is attractive, at least conceptually.

75dvtwin··on Black Friday and Cyber Monday Live Map
I would characterize US's 2019 black Friday as:

- 50% off things should not buy

- 10-15% off things you cannot afford.

Ali's 11/11 in 2019 seemed to be more affordable.

75dvtwin··on Fleck: A Lisp that runs wherever Bash is
Speculating here... but in my reading:

Fleck does not require a compiled executable to be installed.

As long as you have bash Fleck will work. For scsh you have to have to install platform specific executable. If it is available in a particular distro, perhaps it is not that bad.

I write, these days, a lot of Ansible installation tools For Multiple versions of (and almost bare) linux, freebsd, openbsd (and hopefully at some point for DragonFlyBSD).

Today, I have to write shell-specific scripts to do application-centric process management, application-centric backup preparation steps, health monitors, smoke tests and so on.

To minimize my work, I instruct Ansible to preinstall bash everywhere... and then I run the bash scripts.

But writing bash scripts is, well,... unsettling (hard to get used to primitive return values, lack of normal enumerated parameter passing and so on)

With Fleck (at least this is my reading), I will be able to install Fleck via Ansible and then write all the scripts in Scheme (which I much prefer compared to bash, zsh or anything else).

I guess, if, in the future, Fleck will help me to avoid worrying about Powershell, kornshell and so on -- I would be delighted.

Sort of like shell-vm on top of base shells :-)

75dvtwin··on HSBC to shift $20B worth of assets to blockchain-based Digital Vault
no. but it uses Merkle tree, therefore, the often mentioned analogy.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9436847

75dvtwin··on Siberia: 18,000-year-old frozen 'dog' stumps scientists
So.. I have to say, I think you are right.

I do eat meat. And I understand where it comes from.

I should not be judging hunters, live stock growers, or breeders culling unsuccessful breeds, or wale hunters...

I guess part of me was thinking why could not they just relocate the other foxes like 500 miles away and let them live. Russia (even without USSR) still has like 11 time zones of land. It is enormous.

Perhaps, for a moment, I assumed that I had a know-how and was asked to be a 'moral authority', 'ethics luminary' and a re-born principles activist (especially when it affects others, but not me)

I am probably not the only one who fell into that mind set, even momentarily.

But @saya-jin you are right,

there is nothing that indicated that animals were tortured, and I should not have judged how they were 'culled'.

75dvtwin··on Siberia: 18,000-year-old frozen 'dog' stumps scientists
They 'culled' (which means killed) the animals that were not tame enough. And continued doing it for 40 years, it seems.

this is a kind of experiment I would have prohibited totally.

"... Only those foxes that showed tolerance for the nearness of people were selected and bred to produce the next generation, while fearful or aggressive animals were culled. ..."

https://slate.com/technology/2012/03/domesticated-foxes-in-s...

75dvtwin··on Singapore tells Facebook to correct post under new fake news law
Perhaps that's because scientists had abused, the public trust in the not too distant past?

(that includes paper publishes as well authors).

I am interested however to learn/understand opinions of how to make the situation better.

For example, updating insensitive model that would include critical reviews of published work, independent confirmation of published work, and so on.

There could be a bias-adjustment model where if heavy majority of the government or business grants are looking for a particular 'answer' within a given subject-area, there need to be a counter-balance model (that, again, incentivizes a plausible discourse)

Today's intensives model for academia, appears to give lot of weight to # of papers being published.

In the areas where statistical significance of experiments/observations (rather than provable theoretical result) plays an important role -- this particular measure of 'one's academic achievement', could be responsible for the 'trust issues'

75dvtwin··on Apocalyptic Claims About Climate Change Are Wrong
I am not sure that 'dividing' amount of pollution a given geographical region produces, on to number of people there -- is the only righteous and effective measure of international accountability).

In my view, measuring delta in total greenhouse gasses produced, would a better measure for international accords, and their subsequent corruption-free enforcement.

This is why I brought the pollution-per-mile vs pollution-produced analogy.

With regards to > "The amount of emissions correlate strongly to that pursuit of happiness at least for now..."

I think, you are also averaging out to-per-capita that, might not be appropriate...

Say there is energy-demanding and mineral demanding manufacture process, that causes deforestation, pollutes rivers, mows down beautiful mountains to get coal, produces lots of green house gasses.

You are claiming that this benefits, at least, economically, 'every' per-capita person on that country.

But if same manufacture used more renewable energy, and produced more expensive goods. Would the 'per-capita' be worst off?

Perhaps it would not be. Right?

In other words, we really need to measure what that manufacture is doing.

And that's why I think measuring changes in pollution (due to changes in policy of a given country), and changes in preservation of natural habitats -- is a much more effective way to measure policies of governments.

Another way to look at it is this way:

Performance indicators should be relevant to the individuals or institutions that are actually accountable for the execution of what's being measured.

In this case, we are measuring government policies, not individuals. Therefore dividing per capita, should not be used as 'first-order' measure.

75dvtwin··on Apocalyptic Claims About Climate Change Are Wrong
@gttghh, your "... is a shitty argument ... " critique, is insulting.

This is also against HN guidelines

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

>" When disagreeing, please reply to the argument instead of calling names. "That is idiotic; 1 + 1 is 2, not 3" can be shortened to "1 + 1 is 2, not 3."

"

75dvtwin··on Apocalyptic Claims About Climate Change Are Wrong
With regards to

> Measuring per capita carbon

being better...

It is not clear to me why this makes sense.

If person A drive 2 miles per day in an SUV, and another person B drives 100 miles per day in a sedan -- person B pollutes more.

Why would driver A considered to pollute more ?

75dvtwin··on Towards a unified theory of reactive UI
Thank you for sharing the write up.

I think the model you are describing, has parallels with Yaron Minksy's Data Driven UIs, incrementally

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R3xX37RGJKE

Perhaps if you could review the above (if you have not done already), additional ideas/data points might help with your formalization effort.

75dvtwin··on How C++17 Benefits from Boost Libraries
I always thought that writing a non-trivial library that is accepted into Boost, would be like being accepted into a priesthood (for C++ programmers).

In the sense that the standards are very high, and seem to require at least 3 things: expert level understanding of C++, of a number of boost idioms, and of the particular domain/niche that your library solves.

75dvtwin··on The Mind of a Mathematician
Celebrating Tao's successes through media, movies and and other pop-culture vehicles, is very good, and I very happy this is happening.

Shining the light into the continent of Mathematics, and its celebrity inhabitants, brings attention and, just may be a bit of the appreciation, of complex and demanding it is to live there...

But, I do think, that to bring more and more people into the field, we have to also celebrate the diversity and range in the abilities, of the people who have, and who will have, contributed to the science of Mathematics.

I am sure that not every accomplished, and well respected mathematician need to have the cognitive brilliancy of Tao or Nash.

I find inspiration and, to a degree, comfort, in this quote by Alexander Grothendieck (specifically, the point where he felt, by far, he was not the most brilliant person in the room)

>" ..Since then I've had the chance, in the world of mathematics that bid me welcome, to meet quite a number of people, both among my "elders" and among young people in my general age group, who were much more brilliant, much more "gifted" than I was.

I admired the facility with which they picked up, as if at play, new ideas, juggling them as if familiar with them from the cradle—while for myself I felt clumsy, even oafish, wandering painfully up an arduous track, like a dumb ox faced with an amorphous mountain of things that I had to learn (so I was assured), things I felt incapable of understanding the essentials or following through to the end.

Indeed, there was little about me that identified the kind of bright student who wins at prestigious competitions or assimilates, almost by sleight of hand, the most forbidding subjects. ..

In fact, most of these comrades who I gauged to be more brilliant than I have gone on to become distinguished mathematicians.

Still, from the perspective of thirty or thirty-five years, I can state that their imprint upon the mathematics of our time has not been very profound.

They've all done things, often beautiful things, in a context that was already set out before them, which they had no inclination to disturb.

Without being aware of it, they've remained prisoners of those invisible and despotic circles which delimit the universe of a certain milieu in a given era.

To have broken these bounds they would have had to rediscover in themselves that capability which was their birthright, as it was mine: the capacity to be alone.”

..."

see also discussion on HN here

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8604814

https://www.goodreads.com/author/quotes/405977.Alexander_Gro...

75dvtwin··on All Magic Leap Patents Have Been Assigned to J.P. Chase Morgan as Collateral
Newly elected FL governor, in the first 6 months in the office, offered some positive developments in this area.

Computer science and math were addressed explicitly

https://www.flgov.com/2019/06/24/governor-ron-desantis-signs...

---

Highlights of CS/HB 7071 include:

  -    Establishing the “Florida Pathways to Career Opportunities Grant Program,” which provides competitive grants to eligible institutions to create or expand apprenticeship and pre-apprenticeship programs.

  -    Requiring a reverse transfer between Florida universities and colleges to award an associate in arts degree to students who have completed necessary requirements.
  
  -  Requiring career centers and Florida College System institutions to establish regional career pathways guaranteeing college credit toward an aligned associate degree program for eligible students who graduate with a certificate from a career center.
  
  -  Establishing the “Last Mile Scholarship Program,” that will pay for eligible individuals to finish their first associate or baccalaureate degree.
  
  -  Creating increased opportunities for students to take high quality computer science courses in high school by allowing students to count one course as either a require science or required math credit.
  
  -    Codifying Governor DeSantis’ required audit of career and technical education, from Executive Order 19-31, as an annual requirement to ensure high quality pathways for students.

---
75dvtwin··on We Stood Up to a Patent Troll and Won
Thank you for your work. One less patent troll, one small step towards a better economy.

Two questions:

a) what would you recommend, if anything, around personal activism to help to advance the system of patent laws (in US markets)

It seems that you had received as help, anonymous donations, but it means there is an opportunity for more public awareness/participation in some form.

b) for a small company with little revenue, what means of protections to they have? in case they get attacked by these types of racketeers (not just for money, but as revenge, or anti-competition tactic)

For example, are there effective (aggressive, and not just waiting) insurance pools or other similar collectives to participate in ?

75dvtwin··on GitHub tries to quell employee anger over its ICE contract
what would HN commentators would recommend to conservatives in tech sector, who want to show their support for Brexit, for MAGA, for US ICE ?

What can be done to combat the left activism, but in a civil way, yet be effective, and without endangering careers in tech & entertainment?

.. asking for a friend...

Or is the ballot box, anonymous posts and their own kitchen table, are the only places to express?

← PreviousPage 4 of 13Next →