HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

8372049

366 karma · joined August 31, 2021

submissionscomments
8372049··on Microsoft AI spying scandal: time to rethink privacy standards
Private mode has very little impact on what you share with the world/through the network. It's there to keep your browsing private from people you live with etc., not from anyone else.
8372049··on Microsoft AI spying scandal: time to rethink privacy standards
While I agree with the general sentiment, I think the problem in this specific case is lack of job security in the US. In most European countries getting fired for something like this would never fly.
8372049··on Microsoft AI spying scandal: time to rethink privacy standards
20 years ago, legal firms sending out threatening letters to people they could identify on torrent trackers was commonplace.
8372049··on You'll regret using natural keys
I'm not sure you're hallucinating. The dictionary I checked lists the printing and journalism terms separately. It's quite possible they have diverging etymologies, meaning both can be correct:

5. Print. a. a thick strip of type metal less than type-high. b. such a strip containing a type-high number or other character for temporary use. c. a line of type in one piece, as produced by a Linotype. 8. Journalism. a. a short phrase or title used to indicate the story content of a piece of copy. b. the line of type carrying this information.

8372049··on You'll regret using natural keys
Having come from a military background where using that is second nature, I'm constantly surprised how rarely I meet civilians who understand it effortlessly. When picking up a package I say "the code is Oscar Foxtrot three-fife" and you see the person processing for a long time to extract the first letter of the word. I've started saying "OF, that's Oscar Foxtrot, 3-5" to help them out.

In other words, asking a customer/consumer to be able to recite something in phonetics is not realistic in most cases.

Fortunately the code already takes this into consideration and removes ambiguous characters.

8372049··on You'll regret using natural keys
i, L and o are left out of the alphabet in the snippet, so there's not really any ambiguity.
8372049··on EU countries must implement right to repair laws within two years
> We have a right to repair and always had, as said.

You don't have a right to repair if you can't access the required docs, tools, spare parts or if there are unreasonable conditions if you do so. I know a lot of John Deere customers who don't agree with you, for starters. This is why "right to repair" is a thing at all.

> Indeed, what is the difference between a consumer and a "professional repairman"?

First, "professional repairman" is someone who offers repair as a service to others, who has it as their trade. You'd think the distinction would be easy to make. It is defined in one of the first articles of the directive.

Second, that you are not guaranteed access to documentation, spare parts and so on as a consumer.

8372049··on EU countries must implement right to repair laws within two years
It's reasonable if you have fiddled and broken something, but a catch-all if you touch it then you lose all rights is not reasonable.
8372049··on EU countries must implement right to repair laws within two years
Having a "right" to repair something doesn't really mean much if the vendors can legally keep documentation and spare parts from you, does it? The point is that this law does not give you any more rights on that matter, it only grants those rights to professionals.

Furthermore, "you can do what you want with it" is misleading if doing what you want with it (e.g. repairing it) will have unreasonable consequences such as unfairly void warranties and so on.

8372049··on EU countries must implement right to repair laws within two years
My point is that this law grants rights to professional repairmen/service providers, not to consumers (or anyone else).
8372049··on EU countries must implement right to repair laws within two years
I am not a lawyer, and definitely not a EU law lawyer, but e.g. in the copyright law, it states that the right to dynamically reverse engineer a program can not be given up through agreement. I would presume that the above sentence about contractual freedom combined with that implies that you can give up the right to have something repaired through an agreement.
8372049··on EU countries must implement right to repair laws within two years
> Article 16 says only

They are referring to Article 16 of the Charter of Fundamental Rights in the union, not this directive.

https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/HTML/?uri=CEL...

8372049··on EU countries must implement right to repair laws within two years
I hope you're right, söta bror.

> since EULAs are straight-up invalid in Sweden

Is there anywhere I can read more about that? I didn't find anything with a quick search. Sources in Swedish are fine.

This EU source says basically the same as I do: EULAs are in principle legal, unless they're unreasonable/unfair.

https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/consumers/unfair-treat...

8372049··on EU countries must implement right to repair laws within two years
> You have the right to repair what you own.

Based on what? Specifically, it's not listed in Article 17 of the Charter of Fundamental Rights [0]

> This is aimed at preventing companies from preventing you from doing so.

This is aimed at preventing companies from preventing professional repair services from doing so.

[0] https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/HTML/?uri=CEL...

8372049··on EU countries must implement right to repair laws within two years
Are you sure about that? The core rule is usually that contracts are binding. In some cases they are void if exceptionally unreasonable.

> While this proposal regulates certain business practices concerning repair in view of the sustainable consumption objective, >it safeguards contractual freedom< and is conducive to the freedom to conduct business (Article 16 of the Charter). The provisions under this proposal aim at boosting the repair market without creating a burden, in particular for small and medium-sized enterprises.

Page 8

8372049··on EU countries must implement right to repair laws within two years
As far as I can tell, this directive mainly mandates that producers offer to repair certain categories of products, for a price or for free and that independent professional repair shops/services can access tools, parts and information needed to do so.

> Producers shall ensure that >independent [professional] repairers< have access to spare parts and repair-related information and tools (From Art. 5)

Unless I'm missing something, there is nothing here granting the right or feasibility of repairing things yourself.

If I understand the directive correctly, producers can void all of this in a EULA. I may be wrong.

8372049··on I got tired of hearing that YC fired Sam, so here's what actually happened
I'm not sure what you mean by that.

In any case it's not a "lecture" in the scalding meaning of the word. Explaining why something is bad is better than simply downvoting.

8372049··on I got tired of hearing that YC fired Sam, so here's what actually happened
The reason you're getting downvoted is because we avoid reddit-esque cookie cutter jokes like that on here. They don't add much to the discussion and lower the signal to noise ratio.
8372049··on Starlink as a means to win at nuclear war
Putin knows that if he initiates a nuclear war, he will lose as much as everyone else.

Helping Ukraine defend against the invaders is not "poking the bear".

8372049··on Starlink as a means to win at nuclear war
Pu-239 is not particularly dangerous, however. It can cause cancer if inhaled in sufficient quantities — which doesn't need much, but is unlikely if it's scattered in the atmosphere.

U-235 is basically harmless.

8372049··on Starlink as a means to win at nuclear war
Pu-239 and U-235, the most common elements in nukes, are not very radioactive. Both alpha decay, meaning they're only really dangerous if inhaled as dust (or if they fission, obviously). Pu-239 has a half-life of around 24k years iirc, while U-235 is over 700 million years.
8372049··on Starlink as a means to win at nuclear war
An intercepted warhead would highly likely not explode.
8372049··on Starlink as a means to win at nuclear war
If your nukes are intercepted before any of them can hit their targets, do they count as functioning nukes?
8372049··on TTE: Terminal Text Effects
I love the five point order-esque style, warms my military heart
8372049··on Kernel developer write a USB driver in 3h for Apple Xserve front-panel [video]
Depends how you define opportunity. Getting really good at something is 90 % putting in a lot of hours and 10 % talent. Putting in a lot that don't pay isn't for everyone, while the really great devs will do a lot of tech work outside the job as well.

(The numbers are not meant to be taken literally)

8372049··on To the brain, reading computer code is not the same as reading language (2020)
Fun fact, when comprehending sign language the narrator voice is the same as when comprehending vocal language. By the same I mean that it works and "sounds" the same, but obviously it has the grammar and vocabulary of whatever sign language you're communicating in. The exact same parts of the brain are at work, too.

I think this implies that the narrator voice isn't really a "sound echo" but rather your comprehension at work. Just like when reading text.

8372049··on To the brain, reading computer code is not the same as reading language (2020)
Equally anecdotally, I mostly agree but have a friend who writes code much like I do. Reading his code is like reading my own.
8372049··on To the brain, reading computer code is not the same as reading language (2020)
My personal opinion is that 'not' (Python-style) should be the operator instead, simply because it's easier to miss a ! than a 'not'. With that said, I'm with you in the 'not isEqual(a, b)' camp.

The exception, imo, is functions that take boolean arguments. Languages should make it easy to show what they mean, and devs should take care to explain them.

sort(reverse=true, numeric=false) is much easier to read than sort(true, false).

(Silly example, it's meant to illustrate the general point, not to say anything about the signature of a sort() function.)

8372049··on GRC SpinRite
Have you tried ddrescue?
8372049··on GRC SpinRite
For reference, the rest of the sentence is:

[I feel] like I used to spend an inordinate amount of time dealing with suspect hard drives.

← PreviousPage 2 of 7Next →