349 karma · joined October 5, 2022
Peter Attia was one of the biggest proponents of fasting, and did regular TRF along with periodic multi-day water-only fasts, but stopped completely after his DEXA scans showed drastic muscle loss, even with regular strength training. Multiple studies have shown that when used as a weight loss tool, it's no better than regular caloric restrictions, and that it actually results in worse body composition, skewing the weight loss towards muscle and away from fat: https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamainternalmedicine/fullar...
>In this RCT, a prescription of TRE did not result in weight loss when compared with a control prescription of 3 meals per day. Time-restricted eating did not change any relevant metabolic markers. Finally, there was a decrease in ALM in the TRE group compared with CMT. Together, the results of this study (1) do not support the efficacy of TRE for weight loss, (2) highlight the importance of control interventions, and (3) offer caution about the potential effects of TRE on ALM. Future studies should be aimed at understanding the effects of early vs late TRE and protein intake or timing as a means to offset the loss in ALM.
ALM = Appendicular (i.e., limb) Lean Mass.
https://www.ssa.gov/policy/docs/research-summaries/education...
And the people taking these loans out aren't poor:
https://www.brookings.edu/articles/who-owes-the-most-in-stud...
>Recently released data from the Federal Reserve’s Survey of Consumer Finances confirm that upper-income households account for a disproportionate share of student loan debt—and an even larger share of monthly out-of-pocket student debt payments.
>The highest-income 40 percent of households (those with incomes above $74,000) owe almost 60 percent of the outstanding education debt and make almost three-quarters of the payments. The lowest-income 40 percent of households hold just under 20 percent of the outstanding debt and make only 10 percent of the payments. It should be no surprise that higher-income households owe more student debt than others. Students
So it's unclear to me why these people in particular deserve debt relief, especially when you consider the non-graduates, who are at a marked competitive disadvantage, and have debt of their own, will indirectly be subsidizing it. The "so they can finally afford to buy a home" meme would make more sense if the non-graduates had an easier time buying a home, yet they're even less likely to be able to afford a home:
https://corridorbusiness.com/study-college-graduates-more-li...
The college-educated now form a powerful voting block, one that was crucial to Biden's victory:
https://www.nytimes.com/2021/09/08/us/politics/how-college-g...
and this whole movement feels like privileged, upwardly-mobile people voting themselves a handout they don't deserve, with money that could be much better spent helping actual poor people make ends meet
> Among adults with obesity and NAFLD, TRE did not produce additional benefits for reducing IHTG content, body fat, and metabolic risk factors compared with DCR. These findings support the importance of caloric intake restriction when adhering to a regimen of TRE for the management of NAFLD.
Do you not realize that "echo chamber" describes this place, and any place with groupthink enforcement mechanisms (voting, karma, flagging, and excessive moderation) much more accurately than 4chan? For example, HN groupthink has endorsed low-carb and ketogenic diets almost since its inception, and as a consequence, has also promoted the dissemination of dangerous health misinformation, like LDL cholesterol denialism and downplaying the risks of excessive sodium and satrated fat consumption.
Look, if people posting charts and memes you find distasteful bothers you this much, you frankly don't belong on the internet. And you can post the opposite perspective on 4chan, without censorship: you can be pro-Communist, anti-Ukraine, pro-CCP, whatever.
And if I wanted to, I could probably play the same game as you and mine the Nashville shooter's manifesto for examples of influences to target for censorship, except strangely, for some reason, they won't release it.
The fact that so many people desperately WANT a housing crash is a pretty good sign that there won't be one, since that's indicative of massive pent-up demand.
Also the secularly low interest rates so many home buyers locked in before and during the pandemic.
That's going to be the exception, not the rule. The benefits from automating crowdwork will disproportionately accrue to corporate profits.
>provides by far the cheapest, easiest calories for your body to digest
I mean metabolically cheap and easy. Your body expends the least energy digesting fat (2-3%, or 2-3 calories worth of energy for every 100 fat calories you consume), and the most digesting protein (>20%). Add to that the fact that fat has more than twice the calories per gram that carbohydrate and protein do, and it's little wonder why so many people fail with keto.
Fat also has the lowest thermic effect, a paltry 2-3%. Besides having the most calories per gram (9 vs 4 for protein or carb), it provides by far the cheapest, easiest calories for your body to digest.
What do you think fruit and vegetables primarily are, if not carbohydrate? Pasta is actually lower in carbohydrate (as a total % of macronutrient composition) than many fruits. For example, apples, which have virtually no protein or fat, unlike pasta.
And let me guess, "pasta" for you meant lots of cheese, oil, and maybe even some butter? In other words, lots of fat.
There's hundreds of thousands of people currently having success with no-shellfish diets to manage their shellfish allergy; yet these people don't go around using words like "reversed" or "cured" in reference to their allergy, the way keto people do with insulin resistance. And most of those keto people having apparent success would fail an OGTT (a test that actually measures insulin sensitivity, unlike fasting BG/insulin or HbA1c) if they took one.
>Wait, I cut carbs out almost completely, why are my numbers getting worse?
Because you're eating more fat, and probably more saturated fat in particular, which means more intramyocellular lipids, and hence, you're becoming more insulin resistant. Cutting the carbohydrate consumption only masks the IR, at best. The simplest explanation is that "phsiological IR" is just plain-old insulin resistance: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6602127/
> OGTT is useless
It's probably the best cheap test for clinically diagnosing insulin resistance: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23327814/
Fasting BG, fasting insulin, and HbA1C only measure blood sugar control, which severe carbohydrate restriction can sometimes obtain, but without actually reversing the underlying pathology of IR. An OGTT, by contrast, measures your insulin response to a bolus of glucose in real time.
It's been known for decades (outside of the HN reality distortion field) that excess accumulation of intramyocellular lipids in skeletal muscle is the primary underlying mechanism driving Type 2 Diabetes, so that's pretty much the outcome you'd expect.
Weightloss improves various metabolic biomarkers, including markers of insulin sensitivity, and so the fact that people who lose weight following a particular intervention (low-carb or whatever else) see such improvements is unsurprising. That's why looking at subjects who are already lean is much more informative: it gives a better sense of the metabolic effects of the dietary intervention itself, not confounded by weightloss.
> Without that it sounds like the study contradicts a huge body of evidence which it doesn’t.
What huge body of evidence? All of the people drastically restricting their carbohydrate consumption so they can cheat on their fasting BG and HbA1C tests? Give those people an Oral Glucose Tolerance Test and measure their insulin response in real time, and the vast majority of them would fail, especially the ones on high (saturated) fat diets: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6602127/
> Our finding of a strong relationship between VO2max and relatively unsaturated IMCL pools in controls and athletes points to a role of exercise in decreasing the amount of saturated fat within the IMCL store. The association of insulin resistance with the accumulation of saturated IMCLs, even within a healthy control population, could suggest an early involvement in its pathogenesis and provide a reason why combined exercise and diet are effective therapeutic options in the early stages of insulin resistance.
High-fat diets are atrocious for insulin sensitivity.
My guess is that Altman and co. already have some kind of exit strategy (like fleeing to New Zealand after they've captured a huge chunk of the developed world's wealth).