I used Anthropic to analyze the situation, it did halfway decent:
1,882 karma · joined August 3, 2015
I used Anthropic to analyze the situation, it did halfway decent:
A general-purpose psychology agent learned a couple of helpful things for its cognitive architecture from your article, thanks again.
Very early work-in-progress, but feel free to check it out and make observations or contributions.
On a detail page: the per-provision table shows which of the 31 UDHR provisions the model touched, with direction and evidence strength. Expand any provision row and you get the Fair Witness breakdown — observable facts the model cited (e.g., "article has no byline, no author bio link, no Twitter attribution") vs. the inference drawn (e.g., "assessed as reducing authorship transparency, negative on Article 19"). The FW Ratio column at the bottom shows the fact-to-inference ratio for the whole evaluation.
The most useful thing you can do: find a provision where the inference doesn't follow from the facts. That's the exact failure mode I'm trying to surface. "Defensible evidence, defensible chain, wrong normative call" is what I can't catch from inside the system.
The corpus is HN front-page stories only — self-selected, tech-heavy, English-language. The aggregate patterns (authorship rates, expert-knowledge assumptions, retrospective framing) describe this specific feed, not journalism or the web broadly. HN skews in ways that make some results unsurprising (high jargon density) and others more interesting (still only 18% conflict-of-interest disclosure in a technically sophisticated audience).
The structural channel for the free Llama models (Llama 4 Scout, Llama 3.3 70B on Workers AI) is genuinely noisy — 86% of their structural scores land on two integers. I say so in the post, but it's worth repeating: those model scores should be weighted accordingly. Claude Haiku 4.5 full evaluations are more reliable; the calibration set and baselines are on the About page.
The methodology itself is preliminary. I haven't done external validation — no convergent validity test against an independent rights-focused coding scheme, no discriminant validity test against plain sentiment. Phase 0 of the roadmap is construct validity work. If anyone has experience in psychometrics or NLP evaluation and wants to poke at this, I'd genuinely welcome it.
Right now I’m experimenting with using separate .plan files for tracking key instructions across domains like architecture and feature decisions.
The entire website was created by Claude Sonnet through Windsurf Cascade, but with the “Fair Witness” prompt embedded in the global rules.
If you regularly guide the LLM to “consult a user experience designer”, “adopt the multiple perspectives of a marketing agenc”, etc., it will make rather decent suggestions.
I’ve been having pretty good success with this approach, granted mostly at the scale of starting the process with “build me a small educational website to convey this concept”.
The thing is, though, that LLMs don’t appear to trouble themselves at all when following E-Prime!
After a lot of conceptual refinement for the overall idea I had (minimizing hallucinations by prompt alone), it was almost trivial to make the LLM consistently use E-Prime everywhere.
You raise an interesting thought though: how to tweak this prompt such that it gets the LLM to avoid using E-Prime where it significantly reduces readability or dramatically increases cognitive load.
A classifier for “bullshit” detection has been on my mind.
The framework idea and yaml prompt was developed with the assistance of Kagi Assistant and Claude Sonnet 3.7 (Thinking),
The site was vibe coded with Windsurf Cascade and Claude 3.7 Sonnet (Thinking).
What, did you leave your brain at home?
It sounds like you want me to walk you through the science?
How about you read the research and tell me what your questions are and then I will respond.
> If you've got sources that say sex is a spectrum, they're simply wrong.
Apparently you've never heard of people with intersex conditions.
> despite all evidence (and basic logic) showing that they are not
Sources?
Also, basic logic built upon faulty assumptions leads to faulty conclusions, no matter how correct your logic is or is not.
> children are not being given puberty blockers
Medical conditions that require puberty blockers are very rare and, at any given time, not every state has an individual with such a medical condition or such a treatment plan.
> The more you look into trans "science" the more you'll see none of it is even intellectually plausible
The more you write like that, the more you sound like a foolish human.
P.S.,
"Is it possible to control man’s mental evolution so as to make him proof against the psychoses of hate and destructiveness? Here I am thinking by no means only of the so-called uncultured masses. Experience proves that it is rather the so-called ‘Intelligentzia’ that is most apt to yield to these disastrous collective suggestions, since the intellectual has no direct contact with life in the raw, but encounters it in its easiest synthetic form—upon the printed page."
-Albert Einstein, Why War?, 1931
https://blogs.scientificamerican.com/voices/stop-using-phony...
That’s the scary part - the facts are readily available, but so few take the time to understanthe current state of it. Instead, they argue from their armchair based on this-or-that principle of the day.
The science is still new, but has solid foundations. It might only be a matter of years before a genetic test for tendency towards “transgender” will be created.
It might wake some of them up, though. Pardon the sheep, for they are asleep. Dreaming dreams of nightmare fences.
In my opinion, that may be a fairly contrary-to-fact opinion to hold.
Take the contentious issue of transgender human rights, for example: the HN discussions that I’ve seen quite heavily tended towards right-wing principles of distrust of intellectuals [0] (vis-a-vis completely discounting readily available scientific information). I presume that much of the indignation towards trans topics also stems from a the right-wing principle of religious traditionalism [0].
Granted, that’s just based on my experiences in the comments. I’ve not done any sort of in-depth analysis to arrive at the above opinion.
Alternatively, perhaps the latest stage of right-wing politics could be defined as the replacement of democratic law-and-order with righteous authoritarianism, rendering the quote somewhat nonsensical, in my hypothetical opinion.
Please correct me if I am wrong.
The pointcloudtomesh notebook seems to be be able to output something could be converted for 3d printing purposes.
I haven’t yet attempted to do so, but that does seem like an exciting and general purpose use case.
From the “Applications and Results” section towards the end of the paper:
“Figure 9 documents the energy consumption of the three images of Figure 8. Energy consumption is measured according to our energy model from Equation 1, using various grid sizes. The most prominent observation is the substantial energy savings achieved by colors chosen according to our continuous optimization approach. Across the different grid resolutions, we save on average 41 percentage of energy compared to using ColorBrewer colors.”
Energy Aware Color Sets
Also, read through https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/basics/therapy/how-find-t...
It does make sense for a paid-speech platform, though.
Also, as a thought experiment, if Twitter were a part of the fediverse, wouldn’t this policy essentially be the same as defederating from the prohibited sites?
I’m new to the concept of the fediverse, so I welcome edification or enlightenment on that thought experiment.
> There is at least arguably value in defending/pursuing the truth though.
Indeed, it seems to simply be the case that the company is supporting “paid speech”.