HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

AAAAaccountAAAA

132 karma · joined December 4, 2023

submissionscomments
AAAAaccountAAAA··on Germany must stand firmly against client-side scanning in Chat Control [pdf]
I don't think those issues are necessarily interconnected. If I have understood it correctly, many Germans view both hateful propaganda and surveillance as tools of dictators.

Surveillance of private communications obviously has a chilling effect on free speech as well, but freedom from surveillance does not imply a freedom to openly spread hate speech in public.

AAAAaccountAAAA··on Germany must stand firmly against client-side scanning in Chat Control [pdf]
It's definitely not an EU only thing. China, Russia and such have been doing this for years. There have been attempts to introduce it in US (EARN IT Act) as well, and the current regime there might very well end up doing that. Australia has also been pretty authoritarian what it comes to this kind of things.
AAAAaccountAAAA··on Can you use GDPR to circumvent BlueSky's adult content blocks?
All this word salad and smooth talk about the "middle ground" just worries me even more. We have been living in such an unusual period of peace, prosperity and freedom that the pampered, wealthy segment of the Western people is considering children seeing porn as a some sort of catastrophe, warranting extreme countermeasures. However, meanwhile in the actual reality, people are still being killed on the basis of sexual orientation.

I would support reasonable measures to block children from accessing pornographic content, but making people upload government IDs or biometric data does not belong to the realm of what is reasonable.

AAAAaccountAAAA··on F-Droid and Google’s developer registration decree
That was literally before the first production Android phone become available. Does not seem to be a particularly common occurance. Though due to the current world situation, supply chain attacks might admittedly become more common.
AAAAaccountAAAA··on Apple threatens to stop selling iPhones in the EU
One can't rely on courts only to protect civil freedoms. If and when totalitarian measures become politically acceptable and desired, the politicians will simply amend the EU treaties and national constitutions to allow mass surveillance, and disband or subvert CoE and other limitations to their power.
AAAAaccountAAAA··on Apple threatens to stop selling iPhones in the EU
So far, they have implemented only cosmetic measures to address those issues, while seriously considering outrageous things like Chat Control.
AAAAaccountAAAA··on Apple threatens to stop selling iPhones in the EU
Realistically, it would be local competition completely under Brussels' thumb.
AAAAaccountAAAA··on Why use mailing lists?
At least at some point of time it was possible to order Discourse discussions as emails, which you can reply to, and it worked pretty much like a mailing list. Don't know how it is currently, though.
AAAAaccountAAAA··on ChatControl: EU wants to scan all private messages, even in encrypted apps
> I imagine they'd be able to figure out some form of Chat Control that passed legal muster. Perhaps a reduced version of Chat Control, say, demanding secret key escrow, but only demanding data access/scans of those suspected of a crime rather than everyone.

Isn't that pretty much excatly how it is done in Russia, which was ruled by ECHR to be illegal[0]?

https://hudoc.echr.coe.int/fre#{%22itemid%22:[%22001-230854%...

AAAAaccountAAAA··on ChatControl: EU wants to scan all private messages, even in encrypted apps
> Don't get me wrong: I am against ChatControl. Because of one argument I believe to be valid: we fundamentally cannot know what the algorithm doing the scanning is doing, so those who control it could abuse it. Of all the discussions I have seen against ChatControl, I haven't seen another valid argument. But this one is enough.

It is not enough to know what the algorithm is doing. It also needs to be possible (for the average user as well) to stop it from doing reprehensible things. If a client-side scanning algorithm is actually searching for e. g. political content, it is possible to detect it via reverse engineering, but merely knowing it won't solve the problem, but instead lead into self-censorship.

AAAAaccountAAAA··on Denmark wants to push through Chat Control
> Most people do not install custom phone OS images.

They might start to do, if governments become so obnoxious with their surveillance, that it somehow makes life inconvenient for regular people. However, then governments will start to block the network access for "uncertified" devices and software, or even to restrict the access to general-purpose computers altogether. That's why it is better to defeat this politically, than to play eternal cat-mouse games.

AAAAaccountAAAA··on FLX1s phone is launched
Is that really a problem, given the lifespan of a smartphone? I've only really noticed that to happen to decades-old objects.
AAAAaccountAAAA··on Introduction to GrapheneOS
Are you going to do it by making Google Messages to work, or by building an another RCS client implementation?
AAAAaccountAAAA··on PureVPN IPv6 Leak
I have no idea why it seems to be so hard for VPN providers to get IPv6 right. The technology has been here for ages. Also, unlike physical ISPs, VPN providers have no other way to differentiate from each other but getting this sort of things right, so one could except them to be motivated, but no.
AAAAaccountAAAA··on EU Chat Control: Germany's position has been reverted to undecided
I have understood that Whatsapp is not a terribly profitable product for Meta, so it is possible that it would just be withdrawn from Europe, instead of making expensive and controversial modifications.

iMessage is not really a thing in Europe. Apple phones are simply not popular enough here for it to be an useful feature. I guess Apple would just disable it for European users.

AAAAaccountAAAA··on EU Chat Control: Germany's position has been reverted to undecided
Politics are an inherently violent affair. The government is simply a monopoly on legitimate violence. Politicians decide the laws, which result in people breaking them getting beaten up & dragged to a cell. Not to say this is always a bad thing: some people cannot be stopped from misbehaving just by talking, but it definitely is violent.
AAAAaccountAAAA··on Europol said ChatControl doesn't go far enough; they want to retain data forever
Police forces in Europe have been lobbying for this kind of measures so eagerly that it can even turn out to be a national security issue, I fear. What if the police will end up siding with Russian and/or Chinese invaders, or with a some kind of domestic extremist movement, attempting to set up an authoritarian regime.
AAAAaccountAAAA··on Germany's Copyright Clearing House now requires courts for website blocks
That's not a good example imo, since newspaper ads are in any case a curated platform.
AAAAaccountAAAA··on GrapheneOS: Yet another contributor attacked and banned by Daniel Micay
Maybe, but the usual way to deal with issues that attract lots of unwelcome comments is to close it and lock the comments, so that people know what happened. If the issue just disappears, people will end up wondering what happened.
AAAAaccountAAAA··on Secure boot certificate rollover is real but probably won't hurt you
The desktop security model is pretty much the same across the vendors. Somehow, Microsoft seems to get a free pass on this.
AAAAaccountAAAA··on EU age verification app to ban any Android system not licensed by Google
What about the rest? Don't basic rights apply to them?
AAAAaccountAAAA··on Giving Up on Element and Matrix.org
In my understanding, IRC was not designed at all. It has more like been built in an ad-hoc manner. IRCv3 is an attempt to create a clear specificatiot.
AAAAaccountAAAA··on Giving Up on Element and Matrix.org
https://uk.linkedin.com/company/matrix-org

https://uk.linkedin.com/company/element-hq?trk=similar-pages

etc.

AAAAaccountAAAA··on Giving Up on Element and Matrix.org
If those contributions are more a liability than an asset, why not reject them?
AAAAaccountAAAA··on The future of ultra-fast passenger travel
This works as long as the leaders strongly favour economic prosperity of their countries. Russia invaded Ukraine, despite that the countries traded a lot, and their supply chains were cross-linked.
AAAAaccountAAAA··on Giving Up on Element and Matrix.org
> The Matrix Foundation is currently massively underfunded (contributing significantly to many of the complaints in this thread, especially around Trust & Safety) and even then losing money. It gets no money from folks like France or NATO despite their use of Matrix. You can see the list of financially contributing projects at https://matrix.org/support - there are only two governmental entities who support Matrix directly today; Gematik in Germany and another unlisted European govt.

That some specific organization is underfunded does not mean that whole Matrix was built by a few volunteer developers here and there.

> Element on the other hand does have a bunch of customers like NATO, but is also losing money, thanks to governmental Matrix deals often going to system integrators who win contracts with Element's FOSS software and then don't contribute any $ back to Element. I explained the mess at FOSDEM: https://youtu.be/lkCKhP1jxdk?t=740 and there's a good article about a typical instance of this (in German) at https://www.heise.de/news/Wie-Behoerden-und-ihre-Auftragnehm...

That's kind of the point of FOSS. Everyone can crete their own forks, and do not have a duty to contribute money, especially not to an another for-profit company. That happens to all major Free Software projects. Many users of, say, Linux kernel, do not contribute any money at all. Some even refuse to abide by the GPL license (which is less okay), but Linux still not only survives, but thrives.

> (by the way, you seem to spend a a lot of time telling everyone how shit Matrix is; don't you have anything better to do? :)

What is a "lot of time"? A few short messages online?

I think I have explained a realistic user perspective on Matrix. It works, but it has some problems. I have even told that the abuse spam problem has been gotten under control, in the recent threads concerning that.

You have gotten to the point where people care about Matrix. That's a big deal. Matrix is quite possibly a bigger thing now than IRC was at its very peak. That is a big achievement. Unless there is something big I don't know about, your situation is far from hopeless. There is no need to play a victim, give up or to start insulting your users.

The idea that citizens should just shut up about a software project partially built on public money is completely ludicrous.

AAAAaccountAAAA··on Giving Up on Element and Matrix.org
Oh, it seems you are here to just troll and insult everyone. Matrix by calling it just a some sort of volunteer project run by nerds in basements, and those too, who are not pleased with it's problems.

What exactly does have a "call for volunteers" to haul around stuff in a some sort of conference has to do with anything? What has Nextcloud to do with this?

You'd have known that Matrix ecosystem has lots of paid professionals working on it, if you made even a cursory research on the subject before starting to write cheeky comments.

You claimed the problems with Matrix can be solved with a few pull requests. It's your duty to back it up.

AAAAaccountAAAA··on Giving Up on Element and Matrix.org
Matrix is not a some sort of volunteer project. It is used by NATO as their NI2CE, as well as by many other governmental entities. Matrix runs on European taxpayer's money.
AAAAaccountAAAA··on Giving Up on Element and Matrix.org
It's depressing to see and hear that New Vector is rewriting the flagship client about every 5 years or so, with each rewrite taking multiple years. Each time the new client is hailed as the saviour, and then after a while, denounced as obsolete. Soon again, the new saviour is right around the corner.

That is not the way you create high-quality software in a cost-efficient manner.

While Matrix has a value as the pretty much only open-standard IM system with even moderate levels of user adoption, all this makes it hard to actually love it or even to be enthustiastic about it.

AAAAaccountAAAA··on Upcoming coordinated security fix for all Matrix server implementations
> Is that actually right? Feels pretty suspect to me, you have to hold onto the data at least a little bit to transmit it to all connected clients, being a client-server protocol. I don't think this passes by the courts, not any more than holding onto a few dozen or a few minutes of logs in a non-persistent fashion (i.e. in-memory only) would.

It doesn't excuse failure to moderate the service at all, but if there is no chat history, you cannot be excepted to moderate it specifically. Basically, in any even remotely fair legal system, one cannot be excepted to delete something that doesn't exist in the first place.

← PreviousPage 2 of 4Next →