HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

ANTSANTS

2,442 karma · joined August 27, 2012

submissionscomments
ANTSANTS··on Sky to block pornography by default
That's assuming it's actually harmful, which we have absolutely no proof of, just "think uh duh childrens" gut feelings.

Society hasn't collapsed just because kids have had access to internet porn for a few generations. A more libertarian perspective would be "unless you can prove something is causing demonstrable, serious harm, the government should not be involved in it at all, because at best you're wasting resources on something insignificant, or at worst you're unintentionally causing actual, demonstrable damage to society in pursuit of a misguided goal."

Not that it really matters in this case, it's obvious that Cameron doesn't give a shit about porn and is just using this as an excuse to curb civil liberties and justify surveillance.

ANTSANTS··on What taking my daughter to a comic book store taught me
"Problematic?" Why is that? Straight women and gay men enjoying beefcake aren't hurting anyone.
ANTSANTS··on What taking my daughter to a comic book store taught me
Damn, I really should have included JoJo as an example of straight male manga fans being totally cool with ludicrously flamboyant male characters.

http://img3.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20121201210751/jjba/image...

http://animebot.everyboty.net/pix/2994.png

ANTSANTS··on What taking my daughter to a comic book store taught me
Objectification literally means treating a person like a thing. An example of objectification would be a "damsel-in-distress" character with no personality of her own, that exists only as a "reward" for the hero after his struggles. The characters in these comics are not objectified, they are sexualized. They are designed to be sexually attractive, often sporting revealing outfits and exaggerated proportions, but they are still characters with their own personalities, motives, agency, strengths, weaknesses, struggles, and stories. The conflation of the two is absolutely a neo-puritan problem.

If you have problems with your elementary school aged kids seeing sexualized images of women, maybe you shouldn't be buying them comic books about Batman beating criminals into pulps either.

ANTSANTS··on What taking my daughter to a comic book store taught me
Again, I hate to respond in image macros, but the idea that women don't find men like Batman or Spider Man attractive is bullshit.

http://fc04.deviantart.net/fs70/f/2014/258/9/6/tumblr_mtg09c...

(what do you know, the comic that image mocks was written by a guy...)

I'm sorry, but things like the "Hawkeye initiative" are just plain stupid for completely overlooking the differences between male and female sexuality. Look at the romance novel covers above and try to tell me they wouldn't look absolutely ridiculous with the genders swapped. It reminds me of sites like "Escher Girls", a collection of "boobs and butt" poses in art that the bloggers think are "anatomically impossible" and "disturbing", despite being absolutely trivial for men and women to perform alike.

http://eschergirls.tumblr.com/

http://pirate-cashoo.tumblr.com/post/26538269244

https://twitter.com/kinucakes/status/552353978378633218

And judging by the number of female comic book character cosplayers, I think it's safe to say that quite a few women "want to be" these characters, sexualized or not, as well. Women have created strong, sexualized, camp characters like Bayonetta explicitly as female power fantasies, but that never stops a certain band of puritanical American feminists from branding them as "offensive" symbols of the patriarchy.

http://platinumgames.com/2009/04/17/designing-bayonetta/

http://xbox360.gamespy.com/xbox-360/bayonetta/1013849p1.html

http://platinumgames.com/2014/06/27/character-design-pt-1-ba...

ANTSANTS··on What taking my daughter to a comic book store taught me
Batman is improbably built. See how his muscles bulge preposterously from his armor? [1] In real life, most body builders focused on "aesthetics" would have to starve themselves to bring their body fat levels low enough to create that kind of appearance. They would not have the energy afterwards to serve Gotham. A fighter [2] or soldier [3] like Batman would prefer to build up "functional" muscle that will be useful in combat, and maintain much greater body fat levels to provide energy reserves in tough situations. Is Batman "offensive," or is exaggeration a basic element of art?

[1] http://cdn.screenrant.com/wp-content/uploads/Batsuit-Reveal-...

[2] http://a.espncdn.com/photo/2011/1223/mma_2011best_29.jpg

[3] https://s-media-cache-ak0.pinimg.com/736x/3c/f4/81/3cf4816e3...

I hate to respond with an image macro, but in summary: https://i.imgur.com/MMdocdc.jpg

ANTSANTS··on What taking my daughter to a comic book store taught me
>Japanese manga is fully of sexy, weird, objectifying stuff that most people really wouldn't want their kids to see, but go to a bookstore in Japan and you'll also see bookcase after bookcase of manga totally appropriate for all ages with young girls pressing their nose into them. Stories about teenage girls getting picked on at school or trying to meet the right guy or saying stupid things in class. Stories about girls who are in bands and office workers and every possible thing.

I, uh, read a lot of manga intended for teenaged Japanese girls. The ironic thing is, a lot of times even the manga intended for girls is mildly sexualized to please members of the peripheral male demographics, yet the original female audience doesn't run away screaming in response. Guys enjoy "girls comics," and vice versa, and growing up around female anime and manga fans, I never really questioned it. Stories about girls trying to choose between a group of handsome suitors, or stories about guys surrounded by improbably attractive women. Cutesy slice-of-life, or ultra-violence. Ones with boobies and panty shots out the wazoo, or ones with homoerotic undertones... we didn't care, we watched it all together.

Meanwhile, in our more "enlightened" mainstream American culture, people write angry blog posts filled with stupid impact font image macros about how they literally judged an entire medium by its cover, because the female body is offensive or something.

ANTSANTS··on What taking my daughter to a comic book store taught me
>I don't get manga at all, but it's a different phenomenon ... and girls aren't in the niche.

That's hilariously false, both in Japan and abroad.

ANTSANTS··on How to Make a Bouncing Ball Game for Nintendo DS
I was going to include that exact screenshot, but I didn't think the HN crowd would be down with iM@S.
ANTSANTS··on How to Make a Bouncing Ball Game for Nintendo DS
The DS was designed to be backwards compatible with the GBA, so rather than leave that required hardware to waste, the GBA's CPU was employed as a sound and IO controller, and the GBA's 2D video hardware was mildly enhanced to suit the DS. For the same reason, both the GBA and the DS provided access to the Game Boy's PSG audio channels, and many games (moreso for the GBA) used them alongside their "native" audio hardware for "free" square waves and noise.

The DS's 3D hardware is kinda strange. It only supports point sampling/nearest-neighbor filtering, like a PlayStation, and has an SIMD-like "geometry engine" not unlike it, for calculating matrix transformations and basic vertex lighting, but it unlike the PlayStation, it has a depth buffer, making it significantly easier to program. It has hardware support for cel/"toon" shading, edge/outline rendering, and anti-aliasing, yet only 2048 polygons can be drawn per frame, due to the very limited vertex RAM. It's kinda strange that they'd implement such features on hardware clearly hampered by more pressing issues, but then again, cel-shading with outlines really helps for readability on the low res 256x192 screens.

It's a very interesting combination of primitive and semi-sophisticated elements, being Nintendo's last completely original video hardware before they switched to an off-the-shelf chip with the 3DS. Hilariously underpowered compared to its contemporary, the PSP, that it thoroughly trounced in the marketplace anyway.

ANTSANTS··on Show HN: Smart pointers for the C programming language
> That said, I've tried making green threads for C and it was a nightmare. I got something working though, so it's possible, but still a nightmare.

By green threads, do you mean coroutines, or something more complicated? Try the libco library, it implements them in under a hundred lines of C + a small bit of assembly per architecture: https://gitorious.org/bsnes/bsnes/source/1a7bc6bb8767d6464e3...

ANTSANTS··on The Rise and Fall of the Lone Game Developer
When did you work there?

What you heard at EA applies to AAA console devs. If you're gambling everything on a blockbuster game with an enormous budget, it's true, I don't think it would be smart to make a PC exclusive today. That has everything to do with the crazy budget management, retail relationships, unsatisfiable consumer expectations, and unsustainable nature of the western AAAs, though. When a game like Bioshock Infinite can sell over six million copies and the developer still goes out of business, there is something deeply wrong with your business model.

If you are an indie, it's totally different. You can do everything on a very small budget with a very small team, perhaps even by yourself. You can plan to break even in the thousands or tens of thousands of copies sold, not millions. You can target the long tail instead of making or breaking your company on the first week of sales. You can have a direct relationship with your fans. Piracy changes from a death sentence to free marketing.

So for indies, PC is a clear win, because:

It's where most of the people that like indie games are.

The dev tools are free and available this second. You don't need to pay or sign an NDA and go through an approval process for dev kits, you don't need to pay for QA, you don't need to go through another QA process to push updates, you don't need a publisher. Just go and make your game.

There is no single gatekeeper. You always have the option to pick another digital distribution store or sell the game yourself. Even if you plan to rely completely on Steam, this fact makes Valve much more lenient and easier to deal with than Sony or Microsoft.

Most importantly, you can give people your game in a zip file. Free betas are awesome, especially for unproven developers. You get free word of mouth marketing, free playtesting, often great advice in early stages of development before it's "too late" to change things, and the peace of mind that people actually like your game and will buy it when you're finished. Do not underestimate the power of the free beta, it is easily the greatest benefit of the PC platform, and has singlehandedly made countless indie devs, even back before they called them that.

ANTSANTS··on The Rise and Fall of the Lone Game Developer
More like, the iOS app store gold rush ended. The indie dev scene is thriving on PC. Stop throwing your time and money away developing for a platform overwhelmingly used by people that don't really care about your games, that are looking for brief distractions while they wait in the checkout line, and by and large refuse to pay even a dollar for the privilege. Don't blame the industry because you avoided the platform used by people that actually buy games, play them for hours a day, tirelessly promote the good ones on message boards and amongst their friends, and will actually appreciate the effort you put into your work.

Also, Donkey Kong was not created by a "lone game developer." Miyamoto may have designed Donkey Kong by himself, but he had entire team of contract developers at his disposal.

http://www.gamasutra.com/view/feature/134790/the_secret_hist...

http://gdri.smspower.org/wiki/index.php/Company:Ikegami_Tsus...

ANTSANTS··on What's New in CPUs Since the 80s and How Does It Affect Programmers?
I should have been clear, I'm talking about Intel and AMD's monster desktop and server-class CPUs here, not mobile. For that matter, mobile GPUs are very different from desktop/console/HPC-class GPUs as well.
ANTSANTS··on What's New in CPUs Since the 80s and How Does It Affect Programmers?
I'm aware of AMD's terminology here, and I disagree with it. They say "SIMD array of scalar processors" where "SIMT" makes much more logical sense to me. I believe the only reason that they maintain this "2-level vs. 1-level SIMD" distinction is because NVidia coined the term SIMT, so they refuse to use it due to marketing concerns/some possible trademark or other IP law liability/pride.

...and now I read your paper, and I need to eat humble pie, because it apparently predates NVidia's use of the term "SIMT." Apparently, even if it makes more logical sense, SIMT is the buzzword!

Either way, I think it's a stretch to say I'm "factually incorrect" just because I used different terminology. Whether you think of it as an "SIMD array of scalar processors", or (to use NVidia terminology) an "SIMT warp of scalar threads" the important thing here is that the execution units in the bundle with the shared instruction pointer operate on scalar values now, rather than 4-element vectors.

ANTSANTS··on Ask HN: What do you need in HN search?
I haven't been able to produce a reliable test case, but I have noticed that fairly often, I try to search for a story or comment that I know exists, that I distinctly remember seeing in the past, and I won't be able to find it. Then randomly, perhaps after reposting said article, I'll try again later, with the exact same search terms, and it will show up in the results. Then a few days later, I look it up again, and it doesn't show up anymore.

I'm sorry that that isn't a terribly helpful bug report, but I think you have a frustrating bug in your backend somewhere.

A more concrete issue present in both the old UI and the new one would be that there is some kind of problem with your search form such that, on iOS Safari, the multiple forms control with the little arrows to select between fields pops up, even though there is only one field. This means you cannot see the search results while you are typing, when you would otherwise be able to see at least the title of the first result. Also, hitting "Go" (or now "return") doesn't make the input control go away, you have to hit the X next to the field select arrows to view the results, which manages to trip me up every time. I'm not a web guy though, so I don't know if that last one is inevitable for this kind of form or something.

ANTSANTS··on What's New in CPUs Since the 80s and How Does It Affect Programmers?
Yeah, of course there are tasks that can be executed with coarse-grained parallelism, that can take advantage of multiple threads. It's not embarrassingly parallel though like with graphics, where you have millions of pixels that can be shaded independently of all the other pixels in an image, per rendering pass. In an optimizing compiler, compiled functions are not independent of each other, because data flow analysis will affect code generation, so you can't just compile each function on a different thread and combine the results. At least on a per-file basis, compilation has an inherently serial bottleneck, and that's not considering that 1. not all languages have separate compilation and linking like the C family, and 2. even with whole program optimization disabled, the linking phase can be fairly complicated in modern linker, so you have yet another serial bottleneck. And if you're implementing an non-optimizing compiler, then even with the naive, completely serial compiler, the whole process won't take long enough for it to be worth going to this trouble.
ANTSANTS··on What's New in CPUs Since the 80s and How Does It Affect Programmers?
> What GPU vendors call cores aren't. It's like calling hair brush pins as hair brushes.

I agree. In the past I posted a decent (if I do say so myself) introduction to hyper threading and SIMT here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8245360

I simplified and just said "core" in this post because it was getting a bit long in the tooth already.

ANTSANTS··on Speaking While Female
Yes, because it's probably impossible to solve the problem of women being harder on women, just as I think it's impossible to solve the problem of men being harder on other men (in the grand scheme of life, not just looking at the workplace). It's human nature. If you don't account for that, you could, without realizing it, "solve" the problem of men being harder on women in a professional context, then end up pushing the gender politics past the point of being helpful.

EDIT: I edited my reply to clarify some points just as you responded. I have now addressed your first question, and your second question is based on a misunderstanding due to poor wording on my part.

EDIT EDIT, because I seem to have triggered HN's flamewar detector and it's not letting me post anymore:

>I've been ignoring this premise for the sake of argument, but now it's time to raise an objection: Men aren't harder on other men. Both men and women are harder on women.

Yes, I do believe men are harder on men than on women in the grand scheme of life, even if I concede that men can be harder on women in business and the workplace. Men are significantly more likely to be victims of violence from men than women are, whether in public life or in war. Far more men than women are incarcerated in the United States, where they are subject to worse treatment at the hands of guards and other prisoners alike than women are. A woman being raped is a tragedy, a man being raped is a literally a joke, a timeless staple of "edgy" comedians. Fathers expect significantly more from their sons than their daughters. A young woman living with her parents after college is natural; a young man is ridiculed. Men with problems are often not taken seriously by their peers; instead of lending an understanding ear, they're told to simply "man up" and bear it. Their problems are certainly not taken seriously by the media, which claims that their problems are insignificant compared to those faced by women and that they need to "check their privilege." Perhaps it should not be surprising that men are more likely to commit suicide than women.

Some of those ideas, especially one about the expectations of fathers for a man's success, hint at another element of sexism: the patronizing way that men can expect less of women. If you agree that this element exists and sucks, then you are conceding that men are more critical of men than women. I'm not trying to sound like a "men's rights activist" or anything, but it boggles the mind how people can believe or disbelieve the same fact depending on when it suits their argument.

>>dssacco

>I have to disagree however. Most insults that men give other men attack their masculinity, which is implicitly sexist.

That's a great point historically, but in my experience it hasn't been true for a while, and the majority of middle-class men wouldn't tell a man to "stop acting like a woman" these days. When a man is told to "be a man," the subtext is not "because you're acting feminine," but rather "because you're acting childish," or perhaps "because men are not allowed to express weakness." You can choose to interpret this as "all men are sexist because they're holding men to a higher standard here," or you can interpret as "men are not allowed to do something natural that is extremely important for mental health." Yet you don't hear anyone complaining about "interalized misandry," people always manage to reframe everything negative about the male experience as a matter of misogyny. As if we aren't allowed to have our own problems unless they involve women.

ANTSANTS··on Speaking While Female
Ok, you can break the stopwatches, I'm sure that will make people more comfortable talking to each other.

EDIT, because HN isn't letting me submit new replies: It was hyperbole. I don't care if it's an actual stopwatch, if you record everything on cassette and tally up the minutes later, or if you use some hip new cloud SaaS bespoke locally-grown web-scale meeting management software. When you implement patronizing means of policing human interaction like this, you stifle conversation and make people feel like children.

I'm especially aware of this at the moment, because HN is patronizingly preventing me from making any new posts because I happened to submit some replies too quickly. A dumb algorithm intended to police flamewars is making discussions ITT needlessly difficult to read, and preventing me from posting suggestions for the HN Algolia Search people in another thread. It is just as annoying and counter-productive to "rate limit" people in real life for the crime of impassioned discussion.

Another suggestion mentioned in the article is that of anonymously submitting and "ranking" ideas prior to the meeting. This is literally an "upvote" mechanism with all the familiar flaws of groupthink and trying to assign quantitative value to ideas. This works poorly enough on the internet, let alone in person.

ANTSANTS··on Speaking While Female
Where do you draw the line between "these women have internalized misogyny" and "people are more critical of their own gender?"
ANTSANTS··on What's New in CPUs Since the 80s and How Does It Affect Programmers?
>If we eventually start doing graphics on CPUs it will because we move to ray tracing or other sorts of algorithms that GPUs are bad at.

Even for ray tracing, I think you'll get better results on a modern GPU. Each individual processing element may not be anywhere near as good at dealing with the constant branch prediction failures inherent in ray tracing algorithms as modern CPU cores are, but there are thousands of them for every CPU core you have, and millions of completely independent samples to compute in a raytraced image. But I suspect that by the time that realtime raytracting becomes viable, the HSA approach I outlined above will be viable as well, and that will be the way to go.

ANTSANTS··on What's New in CPUs Since the 80s and How Does It Affect Programmers?
I had a pretty big post going, but vardump and Symmetry conveyed the gist of what I was going for much more succinctly, so I'll summarize:[1]

GPU cores are tiny because the problems they deal with are "embarrassingly parallel", trivially solved by throwing more cores at the problem. You make the cores as simple as possible so you can have thousands of them on a chip. Modern GPUs don't even have SIMD units per core any more; both NVidia and AMD are completely scalar now. You'd think that graphics would be the perfect scenario for SIMD, since shaders spend so much time dealing with 3 and 4D vectors, transformation matrices, colors, and so on, but it worked out that the gain in throughput and instruction density per-core was outweighed by the power, heat, and die cost of having parts of those thousands of SIMD units sitting idle while working on data that doesn't take up a whole SIMD register. And because context switches are much rarer on GPUs than CPUs, they can have extremely deep pipelines that push compute efficiency even further, at the expense of context switch latency.

CPU cores are, if I may, "fuckhuge", because by and large they can't solve their problems by throwing more cores at them. They take on problems that are inherently serial and branch heavy, like compiling a program or optimally compressing a large file, and throw bigger cores at them (out-of-order execution, branch prediction, speculative execution, multiple ALUs per core, instruction schedulers that exploit the parallelism hidden in the serial instruction stream, large register files only visible to the microarchitecture, etc) while maintaining a fairly short pipeline so that branch prediction failures and context switches don't take too long to recover from. SIMD fits in well here, because the cost of bigger and bigger ALUs is pretty much insignificant compared to all the other hardware that goes into a high-end CPU core. It can be a pain to optimize for, but it's great for middle-ground tasks that need both heavy parallel and serial/branch-heavy computing resources with little latency between the two, like video compression.

So you can't make one as good at solving the tasks of the other without making it worse at the task it's already intended to do. They tried to do this with Larabee, which was, no exaggeration, a few hundred Pentiums on a chip. Very interesting, but unsuccessful in the market, because it was an expensive niche product that was worse than either a CPU or GPU for the majority of their respectful workloads. What's really interesting, however, is the direction that AMD is taking. Rather than pushing SIMD like Intel, they're trying with their "heterogeneous systems architecture" movement to break down the communication barrier between CPUs and GPUs so that sharing data between the two is as easy as passing a pointer. SIMD is still great on CPUs for dealing with higher level primitives like vectors, matrices, or image macroblocks, but I can easily see the aforementioned middle-ground shifting to CPU threads working in close concert with GPU worker threads, as opposed to the mostly hands-off, one way street common in i.e. 3D rendering today.

[1] On second thought, this didn't turn out to be much of a summary, did it?

ANTSANTS··on Handmade Hero's new lessons about old-school game programming
One of the points Casey is trying to make with this series is that, at least in games, dynamic languages aren't quite the silver bullet for productivity that people make them out to be, and you can write your gameplay code just fine in C or C++. It might even work out to be a net productivity win, because native code debuggers are far superior to "managed" language debuggers (most of which don't handle the boundary between managed and native code at all), and because even moderately well written C or C++ is much less likely to cause performance problems down the line than anything garbage collected.
ANTSANTS··on Is it really 'Complex'? Or did we just make it 'Complicated'? [video]
Someday, mankind will give birth to an artificial intelligence far more sophisticated than anything we can comprehend, and our species will cease to be relevant. A very long time from then, the universe will become too cool to support life as we know it and our entire history will have been for naught. And long before any of that, you and I and everyone here will die and be completely, utterly forgotten, from the basement dwellers to the billionaires.

It's called an existential crisis. It's not a special Sillicon Valley angst thing, everyone gets them. Try not to let it get to you too much.

ANTSANTS··on RISC vs. CISC (2000)
Sure, we all settled relatively steadily on fruitful common ground in the end, and that's all that really matters. I just think it's ironic that people toot the RISC horn so hard in these threads when modern high performance RISC chips are much closer to the Pentium than vice versa. So many people miss that RISC was inspired by CISC microcode, not the other way around, and that the existence of complicated OoO RISC chips basically proves the RISC hypothesis (that you could keep the architecture simple to make it easy to crank clock frequencies up and up) false.
ANTSANTS··on RISC vs. CISC (2000)
Or did CISC win?

Old CISC: Microcoded interpreters interpreting higher level ISAs.

"New" CISC: JITs transpiling higher level ISAs into microcode.

Old RISC: Let's skip the middle man and deal with 80s CISC microcode directly, so as to simplify instruction decoding and pipelining.

Somewhat new RISC: Oh wait, instruction decoding is trivial, at high frequencies we can't ignore the fact that i.e. multiplies inherently take longer to compute than adds, and icache density really matters in an age when DRAM is orders of magnitude slower than the SRAM it feeds. I guess we'd better start reading those Ars Technica articles on the design of the Pentium from the late 90s.

Is "new" CISC wearing old RISC's clothing, or is new RISC just finally catching up to 90s "new" CISC?

ANTSANTS··on Deconstructing K&R C (2010)
cough library genesis cough
ANTSANTS··on The Japanese Communist Party’s New Kawaii Mascots (2013)
I can't pass up this chance to post the Moe Dictators artbook.

https://imgur.com/a/2i3rH

ANTSANTS··on The Japanese Communist Party’s New Kawaii Mascots (2013)
OTOH the ultraviolence on display in a typical 80's OVA might actually make you barf.
← PreviousPage 3 of 20Next →