HNHacker News
TopNewBestAskShowJobs

AbrahamParangi

4,563 karma · joined November 18, 2016

submissionscomments
AbrahamParangi··on Hookworm gave the South a bad name (2016)
Aside but my favorite ivermectin study was the meta study that found that there was a relationship between whether or not ivermectin improved Covid outcomes and the rates of endemic parasites that could be treated with ivermectin.

So, people who got the dewormer did better - but only in those places where people had a lot of parasitic worms. The obvious implication being they did better because they had a parasitic worm infection which was incidentally treated with ivermectin.

AbrahamParangi··on India fails to re-establish communication with its Moon probe
Why would the authors have any kind of feelings about India succeeding or failing?
AbrahamParangi··on Deep genetic structure of Africa reveals unique ancestry of the Angolan Namib
I believe the Khoi-San split from other human populations around 250kya. For context all populations outside of Africa diverged less than 70kya and the Neanderthalis/Sapiens split happened closer to 750kya.
AbrahamParangi··on Authors sue OpenAI for using their works without proper licensing
Conjuring things out of thin air does not have side effects because it is not possible.

The whole point of the phrase was to describe a hypothetical situation with no side effects to avoid sideways arguments about "but actually here's some bad things that would happen if you did that unrelated to the central argument".

AbrahamParangi··on Authors sue OpenAI for using their works without proper licensing
Yes, it is value destroying for the creators. It cheapens their work. However, it gives millions more people access to their ideas. Maybe that’s better.
AbrahamParangi··on Authors sue OpenAI for using their works without proper licensing
My issue is not with capitalism but with assuming the present rules of asset ownership are optimal! If we could make housing free - conjure it out of thin air - it would be really bad for landlords. They rely on that income to make a living!

We should still obviously do it. More of a thing that people want is usually good.

AbrahamParangi··on Authors sue OpenAI for using their works without proper licensing
Why do we think that the moebius estate deserves that revenue? Why is that the optimal state of the world, rather than just a capitalist incentive to create more art?
AbrahamParangi··on DALL·E 3
Complaining about censorious moralizing is valid. You don’t have to defend it just because you view it as a partisan attack.
AbrahamParangi··on DALL·E 3
I think you should trust Rolling Stone on conservatives about as much as you should trust Fox News on the topic of progressives.
AbrahamParangi··on I call it the Homeless Industrial Complex
I don’t know that there is any evidence that ”the solution to homelessness is money” is true, other than that we intuitively feel it should be.

The homeless budget in SF has been growing much faster than the homeless population but the problem has been getting continuously worse.

https://files.sfchronicle.com/sfc-graphics-engineering/sros/...

AbrahamParangi··on Japan's Hometown Tax (2018)
The US taxing you anywhere you live is only possible because of the premium people place on US citizenship. Even so, some people elect to give it up when they emigrate somewhere else.
AbrahamParangi··on The Triassic-Jurassic Extinction
The K-Pg impactor was larger than Mount Everest and the energy released in the impact was approximately 1000 times larger than the total combined nuclear arsenals of all countries.

What leads you to the beliefs that you have?

AbrahamParangi··on The Triassic-Jurassic Extinction
Volcanic activity is also the prime suspect in the Permian extinction, I don’t think the author’s statement is out of line. It’s conjecture anyway because the details are murky.
AbrahamParangi··on Hutter Prize for compressing human knowledge
The analogy is not a random lump of particles but all particles in all configurations, of which you are a subset. Is the set of you plus a rock intelligent?
AbrahamParangi··on Hutter Prize for compressing human knowledge
Then expand your target to a universal turing machine and instructions to compute any computable function. Do you consider it intelligent then?
AbrahamParangi··on Hutter Prize for compressing human knowledge
If you had a perfect lossless compressor (one that could compress anything down to it's fundamental kolmogorov complexity), you would also definitionally have an oracle that could compute any computable function.

Intelligence would be a subset of the capabilities of such an oracle.

AbrahamParangi··on On Robots Killing People
I think it matters how accurate something should be before we consider it "good". For many applications, a 99% success rate is unusably bad. A self driving car that recognizes 99% of red lights or stop signs is probably a criminal liability.

A red ball detector that operates at 60hz with a 99.9% accuracy will make an error on average once every 11.5 seconds. I think the issue is not so much the interactions of objects and the world but rather we're just wildly off-base regarding the base performance needed.

AbrahamParangi··on On Robots Killing People
Yeah this is a great example of what’s wrong with all our robots: their perception is garbage.

Reasoning is actually pretty good now. An AI can compose a sonnet on electron degeneracy pressure no-problem but ask it where the red ball is - and really inspect its localization of that red ball and it’s way off. Orders of magnitude of imprecision.

A modern AI can reason through the trolley problem and millions of variants. But it can’t see the person on the track with very high confidence, or be sure that the trolley is going to hit the person or not.

AbrahamParangi··on Elon Musk went from superhero to supervillain
The argument is “notice this strange thing about the world, what would make this strange thing make sense?”

I asked: who is the highest profile heterodox thinker you know of who is not regularly portrayed as a villain in ostensibly neutral media? Do you find it hard to think of one?

AbrahamParangi··on Vitalik Buterin reveals X account hack was caused by SIM-swap attack
Idk I mean there’s a real trade off to making the app more secure. The causes of insecurity are largely user behavior, and the insecure things are things users want to do for practical reasons.

For example, I have a foolproof way of preventing sim swap attacks: require 256bits of entropy and never allow a password reset, like in crypto. Lose your password? Account is gone forever.

This is more secure but less user friendly. Except for large accounts, I don’t know that anyone even particularly cares if their Twitter gets hacked. You could pretty easily make the argument that preventing sim swap attacks is an optimization for high profile users at the expense of everyone else.

AbrahamParangi··on Elon Musk went from superhero to supervillain
Disclaimer: this is not a defense of Elon Musk, it is a defense of heterodoxy

Who is the highest profile heterodox person you can think of who isn't a "supervillain"? You might conclude, based on that, that heterodoxy is villainous behavior.

Or, alternatively, you might conclude that you are being manipulated.

AbrahamParangi··on In Germany, 27 are in 'preventive detention' b/c they might do climate protests
I would still rather have them sentenced for the crimes they’ve committed - even if sentenced harshly due to their unrepentant disposition - than for the crimes they may commit in the future.

We are all hypothetical criminals and I would prefer that the state not have that freedom to lock people up.

AbrahamParangi··on In Germany, 27 are in 'preventive detention' b/c they might do climate protests
I can't be alone in thinking that jailing people who obstruct traffic and jailing people who we believe intend to obstruct traffic are two totally different matters.
AbrahamParangi··on The U.S. housing market vs. the Canadian housing market
I think this is an extremely important problem for progressive governments to solve because at the moment they’re doing an extremely bad job of it and opening up opportunities for someone to say: “I am willing to do what is necessary to solve the problem - restrict immigration, ban foreign ownership, eliminate environmental and bureaucratic review”
AbrahamParangi··on Google, Meta, Amazon hiring low-paid H1B workers after US layoffs
"while constantly congregating themselves" you meant a different word here but I can't for the life of me figure out which one
AbrahamParangi··on Scientific sleuths spot dishonest ChatGPT use in papers
I can only speak for the fields with which I am familiar but in those fields, peer review is probably a negative indicator. Peer review says that the ideas of the paper are not interesting, meaningful, or true enough to stand on their own. That they require the imprimatur of legitimacy in order to be taken seriously.
AbrahamParangi··on The Decomposition of Rotten Tomatoes
The one useful aspect is that if you only care about the scores of movies you were already interested in, the audience score actually is quite accurate. If you already know "I am the sort of person who might pay to watch the little mermaid" then you can have good confidence you'll like it based on the audience score.
AbrahamParangi··on The Decomposition of Rotten Tomatoes
IMO audience score is more of a proxy for movie quality minus movie expectations. A lot of niche genre films do okay because 1: the only people who watch them are enthusiasts and 2: nobody goes in with high expectations to begin with. If everyone watched them and reviewed them they'd do much worse.

For a mainstream example, take Fast X. It's an objectively stupid movie with a great audience score - because it's exactly what it says on the tin! Nobody is confused about what they're watching. Nobody thinks they're going to get terrific drama or romance or suspense. They're going to get the 9th sequel to a comedy action movie about dudes driving cars.

AbrahamParangi··on Is Google's looming monopoly trial a watershed moment for Big Tech?
I don't believe it's rejecting the monopoly concept, but rather pointing out that monopolies are but one (economic) instance of a broader pattern, monocultures. Monocultures are hyper-enriched in some aspects but depleted in many others and most importantly depleted in diversity. From game theory we can understand monocultures as an extrema on the exploration-exploitation tradeoff (trading off all exploration for exploitation). From evolution we know how this ends (poorly).
AbrahamParangi··on Gaussian splatting is pretty cool
You seem to find the explanation unsatisfying and are getting mad at the tools. The program that defines how you recognize a bird is defined in the connectivity of the neurons in your eye and your brain. The circuit is the program.

It's not at all clear that there is or even should be a deeper explanation than "a function with sufficiently many parameters can approximate any other function with only a small change to those parameters, and thus allows tractable solving" - whether by gradient descent or some hokey approximation our neurons are probably doing.

We have even less of an idea how our own system of "understanding" works than we do of neural networks "understanding". If you're going to be mad at tools that don't provide satisfying explanations for how they work, then look no further than your own brain. Are you going to give up on thinking, just because when you look at it closely you realize you have no idea how on earth you're even doing it?

← PreviousPage 5 of 34Next →